I'm saying people are not cookie-cutters to use the same mold to read. He doesn't seem to react like any of the players I know, hence not assuming.

To the first question, it'd be much easier to answer it if I had, oh say, a lovely readwall we were promised a while ago.
Second - yep. That's what I'm doing. Not pointing out YOU, one of my scumreads, are the one using faulty reasoning to explain why your vote left someone else.

---------- Post automerged at 08:55 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:54 PM ----------

Are you...purposefully twisting the meaning of my words or something? Is that really what you think I'm saying there?

 

They can. If this were someone like Titus (who played in the Choose Your Side game) then I'd figure she just had bad reads and was too stubborn to see it. But I don't think Sloth is actually the type of player to be in that position. He's the type to have a plan, and to write every post with a goal. And I think his goal here is to misdirect town.

We need to lynch either Sloth or Quanksor. I don't want to waste another day talking about them both. I want to be able to analyze a major lynch wagon on someone who's dead. If I can't have Sloth, I'll settle for Quanksor and hope my original scumread on him was correct.

 

MFW.
{Ter, insert a random fact here}

 

How do you intend to read him?

Do you think faulty reasoning is scummy?

 

Quigly, are you really willing to be lynched toDay?

 

Thanks Rubicon. Far out, that reads even worse in retrospect.

I meant this as something that reads like it was a coached reaction with a Rubicon-Quanksor pair.

I get this, but previously I was unsure what your take on a lot of people was, despite asking several times, and I found that seeming avoidance very scummy. I'm not saying a readwall is good - I'm normally not fond of ones like I just did, but I needed to clarify things in my own mind - but when things like the Sloth suspicion come, seemingly, out of nowhere, I find it suspicious, and opportunistic.

 

Sloth, you yourself admitted to not entirely being there for CYS and for that filler game so IDK that proves my point? Like you self-hammered as town and didn't seem to really care even in CYS until the End Was Nigh. So it seems like you are stating that scum lies within me, Rubicon or Snowvon? Ok, do better than that then give analysis and give teams or evidence or proof.

And not the stupid circular argument your pulling with me because no in CYS I don't remember you really questioning me at all. I remember TItus tunneling me like a lot and then some other players and a whole lot of focus on third party but you sort of didn't do much that I remember or if not correct me with details.

 

He's new. Just analyze him and wait to find a pattern. There's no hurry and shoving him into a box will just fuck things up for later games.

I think you were asked to back up your change, had nothing and was the best you could come up with.
I think you using faulty reasoning is scummy, because I generally expect better from you than that.

 

Depends on the mood/season. As in, how pissed off your last post has made me.

But no, if everyone were to jump on me I'd defend like hell, because that's my responsibility to do (whether town or scum). But I think the town would be better off for having lynched me (given they don't know my alignment).


Like Rubicon said, we want a lynch not just for aiming a bullet at the scum team, but also for moving the discussion along.

---------- Post automerged at 10:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:04 PM ----------

What's MFW?

 

You know its a game right tho? Like everythign that hppanes in FIght Club stays in Fight Club. Also its hard for me to like people unless I feel liek I know something about them re texture or flavor or idk (not heavy RL stuff tho bc its a game so yeah) sense of humor, did you not like my attempt to feel your not a bot with Quiggly Wiggly Piggly?

 

[qupte]They can. If this were someone like Titus (who played in the Choose Your Side game) then I'd figure she just had bad reads and was too stubborn to see it. But I don't think Sloth is actually the type of player to be in that position. He's the type to have a plan, and to write every post with a goal. And I think his goal here is to misdirect town.[/quote]

To be in what position? To be arguing with/suspicious of town?

---------- Post automerged at 10:08 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:07 PM ----------

Honestly, none of your recent posts have pissed me off, I was just stating a fact.

Although the nicknames are getting more and more ludicrous, and not in a funny way. Can't you just call me Q and be done with it?

 

...ok, I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt and not assume you're bringing this up pointlessly again like you have been doing all game. So...what's your point? I don't get it.

Read. My posts.
I am not going to read them for you, Lyrium.
I've been saying what I think connects Rubi and Snowvon, I've been saying what connects Snowvon and Fluff.
I've been saying I think you're THIRD PARTY, and why.
And this is not the first time you've asked this very same question. What the hell.

To be honest, I don't really remember doing that much in CYS either, so I'll give you that. But that was one game, where I wasn't paying attention. Live with it. Or don't, whichever you want.

 

No, I think it has to do with Sloth dealing with me as well which Rubicon picked up on and SNowvon as well.

In the Werewolf 2 game that Riley Modded, during the first roll SLoth knew I was scum even though I tried to fluff post as usual. Then we had to reroll roles because somethign mechanical mistake and then Sloth guessed I was the Seer. THerefore, his trying to and getting me riled up is not Sloth at his optimal play, hes better than that. Like a lot. better.

 

What I meant was, I may desire to leave the game/be lynched more based on if a players posts are annoying me, but I won't let that affect my gameplay.

I didn't with Muriel, and you're not anywhere near as trolly/annoying as him.

 

Above is to Quiggly, Piggly ,Wiggly aka Agent Q aka that dudebro

 

Honestly....There is only one way I can see Quank being town with his reactions here...and I think it's a stretch

....and if by some slim chance this theory is right than this is a DUMB fucking play on his part and isn't going to work.

 

"My Face When." Like, an expression of disbelief when I see something.

 

There's no reason for why I'm third party though? Like there's only one third party role. So what is your reasoning or what basis is that on?

IT seems more to me like rolefishing.

 

How is this addressed to me? I don't get it.

 

To post #671 or maybe someone else asked why re: Sloth.