Okay doing my readwall a bit untraditionally as this thread is going really really fast. And knowing my lucky it will slow down between now and then.

Scum & Riddler I think are: Lyrium, Snow, Sloth, Mala (sorry babe), and Citrus


--Lyrium--

General arguments as to why she is scum:

1) The long ass fights with Terraine.
2) https://forums.darklordpotter.net/showpost.php?p=778007&postcount=702 -- While Sloth IMO is scum or Riddler (more likely Riddler getting to that later) Sloth did bring up a good point that Lyrium isn't really as open as prior games.
3) IMO Lyrium is probably crumbing or communicating to buddies. The way Snowvon is interacting with Lyrium looks like a bit of coaching and vice versa. A certain post (not saying which in case I am wrong) rubs me as a phone malfunction after Lyrium's post about her phone or a crumble/code for reference later.
4) Lyrium for all the argumentativeness in some of the posts seems to be sheeping the votes a lot (minus the Terraine fight in the beginning that went nowhere) that still seems like trying to forcing it.
5) Pushing no lynch again after being told it's a crazy idea. :/ Not really sure why she did that again.

I am thinking Sloth is the Riddler because Lyrium and Sloth having the same alignment and her not voting Quanksor would seem illogical to me if this team is accurate. There is a possibility of Lyrium Quanksor Sloth Snow Citrus with Lyrium being Riddler and then Mala town but IMO if that is the team and then Quanksor would get poked tomorrow this one I'm not as worried about.

-- Sloth --

Reasons why likely Riddler -- Like Lyrium mentioned Sloth seems to be power hunting. 683 is also misdirection Sloth was doing in a game as scum. By asking what benefit he'd have by calling someone Riddler psychologically people's brains may tend to discount the possibility of him being Riddler.

Lyrium and Sloth are likely not on the same team as mentioned earlier. However both are pinging pretty high up on my scumdar. There's been fishy play from both of them. Either my radar is busted or one of them is the third party.

Sloth just doesn't really seem like himself. Usually him or Lyrium or someone from DLP leads a MathBlade is scum wagon really quick for really nothing. I'm kinda shocked it didn't happen this game. I expected him to be more aggressive but even approaching his lynch he's all "Well I've given the information" and then throws caps and bold around to make it sound more like him. However a lot of the planning and other elements I've seen in Sloth's town game seem gone. It's almost like Sloth is trying to skate by.

---- Snow -----

Snow seems to be having his sheep town game but with a lot of buddying of Lyrium. 719 is a good buddy post where Lyrium seems fishing again and Snowvon shuts that down.

A lot of my Lyrium/Snow coalignment is 319 and previous but continues to have evidences of buddying throughout the thread.

Snow generally just tags along most of the time and I don't really see him trying to solve the game. Not sure if he's solving the game or what is going on.

-- Mala --

Sorry babe. Purely a read from prior posts since you haven't been on yet to continue.

-- Citrus --

Very little activity here too. RL maybe?

The limited activity in this area makes me a bit skiddish something is up but right now this is what I'm thinking.

-------------------------

Towniest of Town

Me duh

Q -- For all his derping I really think this guy is town. The mass claim idea he had was utter crap but definitely seems to poke and prod and look under every bush.

Fishy Justice -- While with a few limited posts I can understand where he is coming from and why.

Riley -- Does anyone suspect him? I think it's pretty clear he is town.

Kento -- Seems new but it is quite possible he has a mentor. He tries to explain things and let people see rather than scream it outloud and drag people following.
---

Most everyone else is town by default because so many scumspects except

---

Rubicon -- For the life of me I just can't get a read on this guy. I keep trying to figure out if he's town or scum and it is mind boggling.

----

I meant this to be longer but got interrupted by Titus and... things.

 

I think all the town roles are a 10 myself included.

 

Ok. I am actually in a position to finally start reading through and catching up. I'll be around for the next few hours reading through etc., if anything specific needs to be directed to me feel free to post @Citrus etc. and when I get to this page I'll see it please and thanks

 

Yes...Me too...

I can't believe I spent that long trying to bullshit how I lost powers because of Kyubee and make it seem logical. I probably watched enough Madoka to have that high pitched theme song stuck in my brain.

And Titus just had to go that game else if Rubicon or a cultist killed someone Titus would discover a cult and then flip

 

I'm actually pretty interested in Math's scum read on me considering I'm not fully caught up. Is it just a gut vibe on my prior posts or has something to do with my previous slot owner?

 

MathBlade, I only lead a wagon on you that one time and I learned from it. In the CYS game I believe you to be third party and to be helpful to town regardless of the madness around that.

As to me and Snowvon, yes I am blatantly obviously being friendlish to him because I can't help my scummy self or more realistically I just appreciate his fluff a lot.

I'm not sure what be more open means. I've been so open its hilarious which is why I'm ultra paranoid of Sloth. Also can you put hyperlinks to posts (actually could everyone put hyperlinks to posts they want people to be able to read and respond to??).

 

No. I should just observe them and convince others they're scum. Why would I want to do anything else?

You're an idiot if you think anyone here would be this transparent about...anything o.o
No offense.

...Wait, you said several reasons. None of these are reasons.
I talk with the people playing? No shit. I also you asked you questions.
Not a reason to vote me over Quank, but ok.
And...good night?

...What the hell was this?

 

It was prior Aekiel posts. I generally keep the same read I have on a player and then see how the replacement handles that role. If they are polar opposites then I try to break things apart. You have had one post since then and I had a scumread on Aekiel.

 

One question though as it's a pretty decent scum tell on ms, but site meta wise here is it normal to hunt for scum AND the riddler at the same time, or just scum here?

 

OMG MathBlade, according to your logic my long fights with TItus (who was town and I was town and we were both town) ...I mean did you forget that? Actually, I didn't want to fight TItus but she was hounding me to a degree where I couldn't help it.

 

Depends on the player.

I think we should be hunting both. However I have...NO idea how to ferret out the riddler role

 

Actually like the vibe of this post by gut. Definitely feels like something I'd do as town, but probably not as likely do as scum one hundred percent. So I kindaaaa want to reach and say maybe town, even though I disliked the previous post in regards to you trying to hunt for all the scum and ridder rather than just trying to go for one and then the other.

 

I see you as anti town, not sure whether scum or third party - I hadn't even considered Riddler before Sloth brought it up.

 

Q who are you addressing?

 

Depends on the player. I generally look an interactions and why people do certain things. Which lead me down the paranoid rabbit hole of why kill Lyrium night one in the Sloth game. The later the games go the "crazier" I may seem but I usually get evildoers the further I stick around.

---------- Post automerged at 22:30 ---------- Previous post was at 22:30 ----------

^^ Who is you in this post?

 

How lovely, your opinion is noted. Now, is your role to hunt anti-town or scum? Because you can't be anti-town as scum since those are the same things which is why I ignore the blah blah blah that you spew.

Remember either you think I'm town playing anti-town. Or that I'm scum playing anti-scum or pro-town. Or that I am third party Riddler, which the one point I'll agree on Ter with I have no clue how to figure out who Riddler is.

So pick which of the above you think I am now and be clear in what you mean. Don't conflate two opposite things.

 

Ugh. What the hell.
Ok, so I kept making these obvious scum moves hence why I'm scum to you, and now I'm so good at scum obviously I look Town...?
You never did answering a single thing I asked you, you realize.

Holy shit, really? That's something scum!font would say. -__-
You keep looking for reasons outside of 'THIS IS WHY SLOTH IS SCUM' to lynch me.

 

Third party hunting didn't end up being a super reliable tell in Lexi's Choose Your Side game. But that had eight third parties so it might have been a special case.

 

Titus is Titus.

It's not that you were fighting, it was how. Most of that was summarized in a prior post. I just glossed over it since was trying to get something up and had already mentioned it. Didn't want to have town beat a dead horse again.

 

THe above to Quiggly Wiggly Piggly, so much Ninja-ing