That 'vomit' post can definitely be taken as offensive, especially when's he's dead and can't say anything back/etc when someone said something like that.

Why do you want to discount his reads/walls? Surely you don't think literally all his reads are less useful than Fishy's?

 

Mainly because my read on Sloth turned out to be abysmally wrong? I want to take the time to go back over everything and try to compare before I level a definitive accusation against Lyr as I had with Sloth for the better part of the last week.

 

Question for people voting Lyrium, do you really think her play marks her as scum, or do you just have issues with it? I can see the latter moreso than the former.

@Rubicon: Thanks for the response.

 

See my first wallish post for today. I have reasons for finding her scummy and/or Riddlery

 

The question can't claim, not until at least Riddler/(is it clayface) are dead, so obviously we can't just rely on them coming up with answers for us - even if they have done so, they'd need to justify it by examining his reads. And that's why we all need to do that. And yet, you're closely examining Fishys whilst by and large telling us to dismiss Sloths, when Sloth contributed far more that can give tells.

 

I think we're ignoring that Fishy was Black Canary. I think it's pretty likely he was killed as a result of protecting another player, rather than for his reads or to deny town information.

 

Let's try to be adults here and not take offense at little things, like this is DLP..its not My Little Pony land. He has a QT and he can say whatever he wants in it. Secondly, Sloth is wrong about at least one thing that I know for sure..does that mean I should discount all his reads no (which is why I suggested Question investigate his reads) but I also don't hold them to be the Oracle of Truth (I mean if FOnti died screaming Kill Lyrium, Snowvon, RUbicon and his fluffiness I would have suspected myself even).

TerRaine's been baiting me and this is how I respond, it'll get one of us killed and maybe it won't happen next time. However, she's been warping my words for some time and I am not dealing with it in any way but this. *shrugs*

 

Citrus, thoughts on the following five players?

Qgqqqqq
his fluffiness
Quanksor
MathBlade
Zenzao


Is anyone else having trouble posting?

---------- Post automerged at 11:03 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:02 AM ----------

Wouldn't the killer have died too?

Unless it was someone with protection, or something.

 

Ugh, true, I forgot that aspect of the role.

 

If that were the case Atum we'd have 2 deads. A town and a scum. From what I see he was either NKed or Riddlered. We'd have to wait on the flavor to see if it provides answer

---------- Post automerged at 02:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:04 PM ----------

Ninja'd by a Rubicon and Atum

 

If Kalas doesn't announce survivals at night, the Penguin could have killed her.

Kalas/Ika: Are Night Survivals announced?

---------- Post automerged at 02:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:08 PM ----------

And by her I mean Black Canary.

 

How long did it take you to find this post?

 

On a side-note, in the time it takes me to write one post like this you guys tend to have knocked out seven or eight posts. Then catching up and responding to those puts me further back by the time I get ready to post again. So anything posed my way is gonna take some time to get back to you on :/

 

Lyrium, you perceive any attack as baiting.

Atum, I've thought Lyrium was scum since about halfway through day1. I'll restate my case plus observations I've noticed since, when I'm home to di so.

 

Sloth (9): Citrus (#182), Zenzao (#226), His fluffiness (#388), Mathblade (#501), Rubicon (#504), Snowvon (#535), Lyrium (#718), house (#788), TerRaine (#796)

---------- Post automerged at 01:13 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:12 PM ----------

Sloth (9): Citrus (#182), Zenzao (#226), His fluffiness (#388 ), Mathblade (#501), Rubicon (#504), Snowvon (#535), Lyrium (#718 ), house (#788 ), TerRaine (#796)

 

"Any attack as baiting" - Umm..okay I don't even need to say anything. Like what does a player do in respond to an attack? Roll over? Bend over?

And again just to reiterate, this is DLP...there's a certain level of idk rough and tumble which makes this joint different from all the other gin joints available. Like if you really mind being called a twat then say so but otherwise if someone can dish it they can take it.

Citrus, I'm trying to reread all his posts now. Why does the time matter though?

 

A riddlers guess overnight vs the scum NK will be clearly differentiated

There is no announcement of someone surviving a NK. The only technical one that would be informed would be Etrigan. Anyone living by oracle or outside sources would not be informed

 

Because it took me fucking forever to go through the entire thread and I want to know when you probably started looking through all his posts

 

ISO?

/tenchars

 

You can just look for posts made by a specific player.