Why Batman? Why waste a roleblock option on Math that could be put to scum

 

Honestly I am thinking everyone should outright claim. If they use the Clayface to kill one of us the rest of us can plan out actions.

 

Odds aren't good, but they're not zero. Unless we don't even find the scum team, and since Lyrium is obviously town to anyone who looks at her play instead of assumed night actions, uh?

 

Don't claim. It makes Riddlers job that little bit easier (they cant assume protection so there'll take the chance anyway).

 

I'm considering fake claiming.

 

So Clayface can only choose to be Riddler once. Riddler can only make one guess (one player with one role), therefore there is some merit in the mass claiming idea?

 

Riddler/Clayface can kill everyone. Bad idea.

 

If town agrees that this is best approach I will go first but I want everyone to mention their opinion on the idea.

---------- Post automerged at 11:45 ---------- Previous post was at 11:44 ----------

Okay bad idea fuckery.

 

Wait....Do we have mod conf. Clay can only make one guess? i thought he could only choose Riddler once....as in the next night he can't choose him again. Not that he only gets one guess

 

Eh, I've been trying to look and see how most people convince others to lynch their suspects, since I think I'm usually fairly weak in that respect. But no I'm definitely trying. I dont suppose you'd be willing to lynch Titus tomorrow?

 

Mod Question:

Riddler can only guess one player\one role at a time?
Re: Clayface - " Roles can only be chosen once." - Therefore, Clayface could only choose Riddler once?

 

No. Riddler can keep guessing if right. We have to assume the same js the case for Clayface.

 

"-At any point in the Game the Riddler may match a Player to a Role. If correct that player is committed and the Riddler may guess again. This does not pierce protection. If incorrect the Riddler may not make any more guesses during that Phase. "

This ^ is why I'm assuming only one guess at a time?

---------- Post automerged at 02:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:46 PM ----------

Oh yeah, if incorrent then Riddler can't make any more guesses. Damn. Is that a loophole?

 

Math is implying Ter and Titus have cleared each other. If that's true, both our top scum reads are wrong.

 

One guess at a time, but multiple guesses that phase, if they're guessing correctly.

 

Yeah, I missed that part. Ugh. Filthy scum.

 

Could you point me to that?

 

Idk, scum has to be blind not to already make some guesses.

 

Hang on, does Riddler count as a mislynch? If so, than Batman can't do anything after all.

Fuck.

 

Terraine hard core defended Titus along with something they did. However they said they didn't do that thing. But they did that thing.

So if they did that thing then Titus is town. If they didn't do that thing they are both scum.

I can't say more than that to protect them.