My last name is Moon and first name is Shadow. I'm apparently stoic with a kind heart. I do some coin tricks. I miss my wife, who's dead, sort of.

 

ShadowMoon? Isn't that part of Loki's lore or something? I remember LJ mentioning something like that.

 

Shadow is the main character of American Gods, and the SPOILER:

Spoiler

Son of Odin

so it would be a town role.

 

LJ said Shadow Moon(a.k.a me) would be able to confirm her role. I cannot.

 

I said that my flavor made it sound like he might. Did yours mention me at all?

Are you part of the Old Gods or New Gods?

---------- Post automerged at 11:07 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:43 PM ----------

I did not look at this spoiler, but I will if it would be useful.

 

It's not, just spoils the end of the book.

 

Koalas visited fontisian and fontisian got neighbourised. In more experienced players view, when someone gets a qt made, does that sort of thing count as a visit? Is this something we should be considering? A koalas, elemental scum team?

 

The neioghbourizer visits fontisian so yes it does count as a visit. If I was a neighborizer and chose to hit Fonti for some reason would I give the claim to TMNT for some reason? No I wouldn't have.

---------- Post automerged at 06:49 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:47 AM ----------

I'm a little busy myself till tomorrow but Tempus Fugit Jan

I'd like some thoughts and reads please.

 

So it seems like everything revolves around these prs and whether what they said happen actually happened. In order:
Fonti was visited on N1
DemonTurtle tracked Koalas to Fonti N1
Fonti was neighbored N1 with TMNT
TMNT is lynched
Koalas roleblocks Elemental
Fonti is murdered N2
Koalas claims Jack of All Trades
Elemental claims Bodyguard

a) Both Koalas and Elemental are scum. Koalas is the chat maker from N1 and Elemental is Mafia goon.While possible I think this is pretty unlikely BUT Koalas just rolling with an assumed doctor role here instead of claiming JOAT feels a bit weird.

b) Elemental is scum on a 4 man team and Koalas is town. Doesn’t make sense. Elemental would have the Media role and power for qt’s, but already having made a qt with Fontisian, there was no reason to go back and make another. Unless I’m mistaking how this works and it’s just a general powerblock (sorry in that case). Not to mention Fonti still died.

C) Koalas is scum and Elemental is town. Doesn’t make sense. Out of all the people to roleblock, he chose Elemental who was most likely the next lynch and just adds pressure on himself instead of a mislynch.

D) Elemental is scum on a 5 man team and Koalas is town. I can see this being a possibility. However I don’t know how likely a 5 man scum team is in itself with this kind of flavor or honestly at all.

E) Both Elemental and Koalas are town. Also a possibility.

A couple questions before I go in and redo my reads, whats the possibility of a 11/3/2 type game? Because if we’re dealing with an Odin/Loki team some things might start to make more sense.

---------- Post automerged at 06:01 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:55 AM ----------

actually nevermind that doesn't make sense either ugh.

 

Well, if you were a scum neighbouriser right? I mean we're in that situation.

TMNT did have a qt with fontisian. And he was a goon. So he didn't do it himself. So someone else did. And that person at no point said it was them. So that person's probably scum?

Am I being irrational? I mean whether it's you or not, the above makes sense, right?

 

One thing I think could be possible. The neighbourizer is also a delayed kill, so that fonti would have died regardless, and then Kalas managed to stop Elemental carrying out another kill. Could allow for the presence of only 4 scum in the game.

Either way N think we should be looking to lynch either Banks or Elemental today.

 

Possibly, but snowvon died the first night, right? So someone has to have a direct hill style ability.

 

I'm on board with that plan. Neighbourizer can be a delayed kill? That kinda fits with the New god of media I suppose.

 

Old Gods.

/tenchar

---------- Post automerged at 06:06 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:02 AM ----------

As Blorcyn said, Snowvon died in N1 and that mostly must be because of a scum kill. A vigilante who mis shot is also possible, but if they had, they'd have killed someone else too by now. It wouldn't make sense. Plus, you have my word that I didn't do it

 

Yes I'm suggesting that scum would have this on top of a direct kill each night. It's possible since we've seen the other scum role also have two parts to it.

 

I'm almost a hundred percent sure it's a scum neighbourizer. Any town with that ability should have claimed when TMNT said he neighbourized fontisian.

 

Vote: Banks

Do stuff. Actually play the game.

 

Agreed!

Also, if people could give reads, not repeat the same mechanics discussions we've been having, that'd be awesome.

 

Sorry for my lack of activity guys but this week RL has been really busy.

I'm willing to claim if you want me to, but I can say I'm vanilla town, well I have a power but for what it's worth I can't do much with it.

Regarding how many scum are out there I'd say one more if the setup newcomb posted here is to be believed, and that would be The Media.

I can really see the a 11/4/1 set up for this game, but for that setup from what I gather from the lore Loki (LJ) is the most likely candidate for neutral. Otherwise it might just be 11/5

The neighborizer is scum otherwise he would have claimed when TMNT did.

I was surprised when Fonti survived N1, so I'd guess that the might have used a oneshot skill on her but she was protected by Koala. Now as they no longer have it they can only perform one kill per night, but this is just a guess. She made for a pretty obvious target so it was reasonable she would be protected so it makes sense that scum would avoid her N1.
Jan: Is it normal to have so many roles with only oneshot powers? Could this also be part of the medium level difficulty of the game?

So far I have my doubts regarding elemental, Koalas, Banks and a bit on LJ.

---------- Post automerged at 07:32 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:08 AM ----------

If fonti was killed on N2 due to delayed kill we would have seen 2 people die on N2, due to normal NK! and another due to delayed kill.
If delayed NK! is real then Kalas is the most suspicious person right now.

This is another theory I came up after reading about the delayed kill, what if Koalas skill is: the person you visit after a night circle will be neighborized once that happens no skills on them will work.

Then he only had to visit on N1 and but then why would he claim to visiting her on N2 when he doesn't need to?

 

Wut?
/10char