Aria Slippery = Rob Alloy

---------- Post automerged at 03:42 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:40 PM ----------
Jan how do you feel about Snowvon? Do you think he's a potential lynch toDay?

I'm somewhat reluctant to do so given the way I'm currently reading him but if we're staying away from those people I think it should be considered, at least. I feel like he'd have defended me to Citrus regardless of his alignment, in fact, especially as a witch to make me feel comfortable with him.

 

I don't really care how you're reading me, I want you to explain why you think town would fakeclaim Priest and draw out the real CC.

 

Prophylaxis
Would like your thoughts on the game-state right about now

 

his vouch there was nothing.

I give him some towncred for his reasoning for his meh play early on today.
I do not want to kill him day 1 for this, because i dont think he would mention being in a bad mood as scum.
Nothing hard tbh, mostly my gut.

 

Justify your read on me.

 

Well, a lot of it is process of elimination for Day 1 lynch candidate.

I'm not willing to vote for Jan, LochNess, Proph, Slippery, dLGN, Citrus or Plotless. (Or Kai until he posts). I highly doubt there's going to be a wagon on Waco or Cobalt. So that basically leaves you and Snowvon. Snowvon I've been gutreading as leaning scum and more or less same with you. :/

 

Why are you not willing to vote for LochNess, Jan, and Citrus?

 

I'm not liking your reads after all the major reveals happened, but I'm not really sure that's your fault.

 

There are two roles that might soft/claim priest to not get lynched and get night kp on their head n1.
The real priest is not that likely to ever counterclaim d1, they stay silent, get a check and out d2 for the most part.

That is an easy world where rob is town and claimed the way he did, as not priest.


Kais play is even easier, because if rob is real, what kai is doing is giving the priest cover, and confusing the scum.
Also possible as one of two protective roles in this game.


There are easy reasons why both of them might be town, and it is way easier to think about it tomorrow instead of today.



Sure one of them might be mafia, but killing one and if that person flips town (because of the gd claim) killing the other one in the process is the worst thing to do, in my opinion.

 

Jan's been major townread by most people in this game, including me, and the wagon is just not going to happen.

I've been townreading LochNess all game too, so I don't want to vote for her.

Citrus- well, he claimed oracle and backed up Slippery's claim, so I don't want to lynch him until we figure this out. Also, doesn't that automatically make him towny?

 

i really dislike this line for some reason. particularly as newcomb has come into the game saying virtually everything I have been thinking and you now know that I am confirmed town (but lol at you even bringing up citrus doing it to a partner..) you've scumread newcomb and myself, had citrus as null, are skeptical of aria... sorry buddy, your reads are trash tier but you probably just rolled scum again and for that you need to die.

citrus I really like newcomb, I don't think he's a good vote. if this is his 60% I don't ever want to wolf against him when he's feeling 100%.

Vote: Jan


---------- Post automerged at 16:10 ---------- Previous post was at 16:07 ----------

citrus did claim oracle on me, not slippery. elite derp. and yes, he's probably always town.

as much as I would like to think loch is a wolf and I got that sense from just one post, I agree and don't want to lynch her today.

why do you feel so strongly about jan? what do you think is alignment indicative that he's done? also, what do you think about the fact that he's null read citrus (oracle, 99% town), myself (town), and doesn't think you (you're town fypov) are obvious town like some of the rest of us?

you sure you don't want to vote him?

 

Damn, I'm confused because I honestly don't really want to lynch anyone right now.

Also, my gut feelings are all over the place with Newcomb now that I'm thinking more about it, and honestly, same with Jan.

 

i agree with you about possible alternative motivations for both slippery and kai's plays. however, I also really like newcomb so far and won't let him be lynched today if at all possible. so, you mentioned loch and proph - analyze them?

 

But I feel like I should trust the game progression/logic more than my gut feelings.

With Jan, he's been really active and contributing in the game, asking questions and whatnot.
And honestly, his recent reads post bothered me and I don't really get why he's so unsure about me, but I feel weird scumreading him because of it. I don't want to be scumreading people based on what they think of me in the game, because that doesn't seem logical, idk.

---------- Post automerged at 04:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:14 PM ----------

The Citrus nullread also bothered me, but maybe I'm missing something about the mechanics.

---------- Post automerged at 04:15 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:14 PM ----------

I'm also not really caught up on the thread yet and I have a good few pages I need to reread and write on.

 

can you explain the bolded for me?

 

And I thought Jan conceded that you're probably town? With the claim thing he pulled, which I'm still not sure how I feel about.

 

he did but it's not looking good for him otherwise fmpov.

my top town are

citrus
aria
newcomb
plotless

maaaaybe loch.
maaaaybe waco (where the hell did he go?)

in that order. add me to that list and he's been null on or disliked my top 4. that's just way too backwards for me.

 

dLGN does this "lynch outside the claims" thing make sense to you?

I still don't see why we want to deal with the WIFOM headache tomorrow.

Actually Prophylaxis too I feel like we've been kind of on the same page w/r/t this.

---------- Post automerged at 01:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:21 PM ----------

Also dLGN why is Citrus your top town?

 

dLGN, this is a helluva towny post from Jan though. I really do not want to lynch Jan right now

 

to explain this a little further:

if slippery is ever confirmed witch in this game I think that post clears aria with how she assumed oracle citrus cleared slippery as town. (i suppose it could also clear slippery if aria is a witch).

it's elite in how damn natural and honest it sounded. if you're a witch you're a god. if you're with slippery you've all but won the game already, if I had to decide.