So either LochNess got really unlucky as town or took the eas/lazy way as scum.

And on the other hand we have von who makes the worse check, and his reason is i randomized it.

I am just so done with this game right now.

---------- Post automerged at 20:15 ---------- Previous post was at 20:13 ----------

But Kai is stupid, you should never forget that.

Using it on LochNess would be 10 times more valuable to town.

The two of you are unlikely to be alligned, so if you can confirm her info, we can just believe it.

It is most likely right anyway, but this is just meh.

I get why kai wants you to 50/50 it, because that way they are both forced to say the truth if you are town.

 

There really wasn't any 'good' check, if we're talking about Night 1.

In general, yeah, I'd rather have waited, but oh well.

---------- Post automerged at 14:17 ---------- Previous post was at 14:16 ----------

:/

then isn't it the same result if they both think they have a chance at me double checking their claim?

 

the problem for me is more that everyone and their mother called cobalt town after his reaction in the last minute of d1.

Chances of him being scumw ere so low at that point, that even if plotless is scum, he would never say cobalt is scum.

That makes checking plotless borderline useless to me.

LochNess could have had a greencheck on anyone else and just change it to the easiest target in the game.
If you watch her and she claims wrong, then we just know there is scum ebtween both of you and her check might be wrong, or your check.

But the infos we get out of that are so much more, and worst case you just tell us that her check is real and we have a confirmed town (or the exact team of three which is unlikely).

 

Can we all agree based on the night kill, plotless's check and Snowvon's recheck Cobalt is town ? I think there's exactly a .00001 chance (made up percentages) the team would be exactly Cobalt, Plotless and Snowvon to believe otherwise.

---------- Post automerged at 03:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:20 PM ----------

Stop echoing my thought process.

 

Proph is probably town because I don't know if he would have taken that risk if he were mafia to link that much .. well after the whole fontisian thing last game you never know but I don't think he would have.

I think Snow is mafia and the fact that he didn't check me doesn't really make sense. I think he didn't want me or whoever I got information about cleared. (Aka say I had received info about Jan or Newcomb for example and I said that, then he would either have to agree to look town or disagree and have that person who is being listened to go against him seriously and he didn't want that risk)

Vote: Snowvon

 

This being patient is beginning to wear on my nerves. I will recap all the information we have. dLGN is confirmed town Nurse due to the death of Citrus confirmed town Oracle. Cobalt is nearly 99 percent confirmed town Gambler.

The combination of the Citrus death , Plotless confirmed Gravedigger status and Snowvon's claim makes this true. No one has counter claimed so we should assume all the other outed claims are true.

I know my role and am humoring Kaidash at this point. Only one role was removed so there is only so much that can be done by the witches in that regard of fake claiming.

Is my recap clear and concise enough ? Does anyone need me to explain anything in it?

 

~Vote Count 2.01~

[1] Snowvon ~ LochNess (#865)

[10] Not Voting ~ Aria, dLGN, Jan, KaiDASH, Newcomb, Plotless, Prophylaxis, Snowvon, SlipperyAxII, The Waco Kid

With 11 alive, it's 6 votes to soft-lynch and 9 votes to hard-lynch!

Deadline is at Thursday, January 28, 2016 at 9:00:00 PM (Washington DC, District of Columbia time).

1.01 | 1.02 | 1.03 | 1.04 | 1.05 | 1.06 | 1.07 | 1.08 | 1.09 | 1.10 | 1.11 | 1.12 | 1.13 | 1.14 | 1.15 | 1.16 | 1.17 | D1 EOD

 

So people I'm not voting for today:

dLGN, Slippery, Plotless
Probably not Jan

KaiDASH doesn't look like will happen. I don't really have a read on this guy.

People I'm open to voting for:
Newcomb- I kinda wanna keep him around, he's very active and he has interesting things to say.

People I'd prefer voting for:
Proph and Loch I'm still confused about, and I'm getting more suspicious of the latter.
Waco and Snowvon- Not really any new thoughts..

Tbh, I used to think everybody was scum now I think everyone's town and am confused.

---------- Post automerged at 06:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:44 PM ----------

Wait, are we waiting for Slippery to reveal his check or???

 

I am unsure what we are waiting for .. there are two possible copchecks.

Outside of that i am curious about prophs thoughts because he wanted to reread the game, and i am sceptical of him to say the least.

 

so how likely is it that slippery is the DOB who was baiting a CC? (LC too, but our counterplay against that is roughly 0 so it's less relevant).

 

Kaidash The chances are zero . I would have forced you to hard claim in the world I wasn't real. I would have never told every one to claim priest because in the world you are considering I want to narrow the field down not widen it.

You could say I was trying to do some reverse psychology to find the people unwilling to claim it I guess. That's a possible world if you are town but it isn't this world we are in right now.

---------- Post automerged at 07:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:23 PM ----------

I said that imprecisely by the way I did not check Kaidash as that would be the third worst possible check. If he holds the claim then he is automatically a witch from my perspective so it doesn't matter. If he is D.O.B. or Loose Cannon he just takes me out anyway if he is a witch and they have those roles.

 

Why are you not revealing your check, SlipperyAxII

 

That question could be asked to both of them.

Just to be sure that it is not one of the copying the other one or whatever, i would like both of them to give reasons to why they checked said person and maybe reads they got from that check and post it at the same point.

Like both do that within the next 70 minutes and post at that upcoming hourmark (3 am my time, 9 pm gametime).

Just my idea on how to handle it, they can also just both claim.

 

Aria I am waiting for Kaidash to rescind his soft claim or hard claim it.

 

Oh. This whole time, I thought KaiDASH was trolling lul

 

Why wouldn't witch!LC!Slip have fired into you at the start of the Day to stop you from revealing your check?

Also Jan you know the PT's target is informed that they've been peeked, right? Just if you're factoring that into your mechanics about Snowvon's power use and shit.

 

Peeping Tom - Once per game, you may observe the private actions of any non-holy character. If that character is dead, you may make decisions in their place.

Unsure if it does in the forum version. But if you say so, then there is even less of a reason to check the gravedigger last night.

 

Huh. I actually didn't check myself. I was the PT in WH12 on FS and that's how it worked. Kinda assumed it worked the same here.
Plotless did you get told Snowvon peeked you?

---------- Post automerged at 05:07 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:07 PM ----------

And yeah, Kai and Slip do what Jan said.

Even if Jan's a witch he still has good ideas.

 

The reason I checked the person I checked was due to the interactions they had through out the game. Today it was interesting who the people who were suspicious of this person and the people who decided to defend them. I know their alignment now so that gives me a little bit better view on the game. I am being cryptic I suppose.

I was going to do some reaction tests but I decided it might have lethal consequences so I checked Prophylaxis who is not aligned with the witches. That's anti climatic.

 

Oh Newcomb .. you can' even make yourself believe that i am scum.

The important point is to find a moment where both of them are here and post it at the same time.
So just prepare said post and talk to each other to find a moment as soon as possible.

---------- Post automerged at 02:14 ---------- Previous post was at 02:13 ----------

Are you not able to read what we were talking about rob?

---------- Post automerged at 02:18 ---------- Previous post was at 02:14 ----------

It is fine if you disagree with my proposition, but outing without anything is like the worst play ever.

The check is good, if proph is town that would be quite valuable, because the citrus kill made him look kinda bad.