I've gone back and forth on you a few times. I don't have any peg I'd want to hang a solid read on. Your first post could come from either alignment. Your lurky/RL busy persona could come from either alignment. The fact that you didn't try to grab the town leader reins in the first 24 hours when I was exclusively shitposting could come from either alignment in the context of being RL busy, though in a vaccum I think it makes you slightly more town.

Not sheeping fonti; I'm interested in her case, because the "multiple levels of fakeness" thing is something I haven't even seen or felt a little bit of. And as we saw in WH13 fonti is best judged on what she actually does (like the way her big pushes on you and Kai were just... not good.)

So yeah, more interested in fonti's read on you to read fonti.

My own read on you is pretty ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Gun to my head you're town, but I just haven't paid a ton of mind to it tbqh.

---------- Post automerged at 10:35 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:34 AM ----------

like Citrus I literally can't remember anything you've done this game other than your first post, getting into a short slapfight with fonti, and kinda listlessly poking people. RL is RL, obviously, but idk why you'd expect me to have anything approaching a strong read on you at this point.

 

Noticed this on reread so more fuel for miner=town fire that's not a teammate post

There's worse things than being off on Caphriel's walls, citrus' blatant apprentice claim and vaimes turboposting day one

Like deathmatching pozzai and fighting him to be lynched first

Vons. He's rarely acknowledged me in games directly ever; wh14 he sort of background agreed with me and it feels like his "haha acio's uncomfortable with me I'll vote with him" was meant to shake me on sloth

 

I didn't say I expected a read, I just got the impression from that wallread thing that you had no thoughts on me whatsoever/was shrugging and saying "I'll just do whatever Fontisian does" basically, which isn't too great if you were also not really reading Fontisian.

I know her posts are sparse, but thoughts on Fontisian right now? Gun to head thoughts etc. kinda like what you just did on me above?

 

Sloth was pretty adamant that he suspected me and fonti earlier, and he was really active on that first day, but now that we've kind of bw against him he's disappeared. Could be RL problems, but it's also a little off that he won't come and defend himself now.

 

I agree, but I also can't shake the horrible bad no good evil feeling I get from demon's vote post

Like, the first sentence plus second sentence is kinda Caught For The Wrong Reasons, the third is ??? with the cop claim thing I don't even know how to read that, the part sheeping me with Von but not voting Von and then voting Sloth is like ewwwwww.

idk I have a real hard time seeing that post come from town.

 

Oh DLP didn't update for me. Weird.

 

Hey.

Scum genuinely were tossing the idea around of me being the Priest. I have a pretty good track-record of ALWAYS getting scum to say "Citrus might be priest" in covenchats for Night 1 night-kills.

I'm serious about this. Look at my past 4 witch hunts or so. I am scarily consistent in being considered the Priest.

Yeah I was blatant as fuck in hindsight but as of going into D2 looking at individual QT's I was definitely doing a pretty good job thanks

 

If sloth was town, he'd defend himself. #141 He goes, if I hang, flip town, how are your reads affected?

Well, now if he hangs, noone will know anything because we're all bwing him, so any one of us could be maf. If that's the case, then he should reiterate that defense if he was town, to argue his defence as an innocent.

If he's scum, then he could wait it out, see if one of us slips up, and latch on to that and claim scum for that. So it might be why he's staying silent now.

 

Gun to my head she's town. The way she's interacting with the newbies is something I'm not sure she bothers to fake as scum, but that's real fucking thin. I'm also agreeing with some of her reads which is a good sign.

On the other side, we've got the super fast chain of townreads which is pure scumfonti from WH5, and the "getting ahead of where the thread is going" with the Miner townread and Von scumread.

Really the biggest thing I've got for town fonti right now is that with Sloth/Snow looking so goddamn mafia I don't think fonti really makes sense as the third in that world.

 

demonturtle miner11121

Ex: you both say Sloth is suspicious/scummy for not coming in to defend himself. Let's say Sloth is scum. Knowing that he has a bunch of votes on him (5 actually), plus pretty much no thread-consensus on anyone except him, he hasn't posted since.

Why do you guys think this is suspicious/adds to the idea that he is scum. Isn't the expected consequence of not posting in this position...getting lynched? Is there an ulterior motive? Is he relegated to his death? Like I'm trying to get you guys to explain: why exactly is it necessarily scummy ("suspicious") that he isn't defending himself or whatever, as opposed to any other reason. You both posted saying that within like a post of each other.

 

If Sloth was town: He could just be busy and not looking at the game. It happens, juggling RL stuff can be hard. Though, he said he was going to provide a read later on Fonti, but he never did. If Sloth was scum: He disappeared because he's given up and is just going to let himself be killed.

 

Great, this is the kind of stuff I was trying to get you to explain!

Waiting on you still demonturtle

---------- Post automerged at 12:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:43 PM ----------

Ehhhh.

I like miner's response more than yours Demonturtle (and I like it a lot independently too, it reeks Town to me), unless you have anything more to add than that

 

This thread exploded with activity. Sorry if I post something that someone else said. I may not be refreshing the thread constantly.

 

Man if the team is Sloth/Von/demon I'm going into my champs game with the burning confidence of a thousand suns.

Really hoping Acio is town because that would be pretty fucking embarrassing.

---------- Post automerged at 10:49 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:47 AM ----------

Ehh that's probably not the team actually.

I don't know if I can believe Sloth getting bussed that hard when there's no counterwagon.

 

Yeah I can kind of see it either way hrm. Means I need to reread

Immediate thought on the cop thing though was that it would be ridiculous to fake that as scum.

 

That's a pretty good point actually. Yeah I need to reread too.

 

Citrus wrt sloth situation: he's come back to mafia from a hiatus right? What do you propose rusty scum does if they get hit day one and don't have any immediate allies in thread (that they haven't scumread whoops) and then town starts picking apart interactions?

 

Probably lurks it out and waits for the wagon to collapse a la Ixta in WH13.

:fire :fire :fire

 

If Sloth was town, wouldn't he be defending himself? If he gets mislynched, it will only hurt the town. If he's innocent, shouldn't he putting up a fight? I don't think getting angry would help any, but explaining why he's town and things like that.

 

If Sloth was mafia, wouldn't he be defending himself? If he gets lynched, it will only hurt the mafia. If he's guilty, shouldn't he putting up a fight? I don't think getting angry would help any, but explaining why he's town and things like that.