Does somebody just want to explain to me the setup w/r/t scum GD and the missing role? Its not really in the OP to my satisfaction.

vira/miner would mean that they swapped GD and chose to remove inquisitor from the game?
What would the other witch roles be?

---------- Post automerged at 00:44 ---------- Previous post was at 00:17 ----------

I guess that's a no.

 

If newcomb is real then the witches had gravedigger as role and used it.

We do not know which role was discarded.

There are 13 players and 14 roles. priest ois the only role that is always town.

Scum get an extra role and can swap one of their roles for that role. They have only 1 swap total (which means they cannot switch roles within their team, just swap in the extra role if they want to).

 

Ok cool. Sounds like I don't really have to wrap my head around role stuff since claims could be real or false and still safe for scum.

Yeah, I'm down to lynch miner or owner.
Would move to koalas or slippery to reach majority but I'd probably bitch about not lynching one of the first two.

 

Remove and put miner on a mythical third tier where I really, really want to lynch in one of the first two and this is where I am.

 

Convince me miner is town.
Cuz, like, he isn't thinking like he is.

 

Morning.

I made the mistake of reading up to the current time again when I should post as I go through the thread and then almost burned my breakfast as a added benefit.

My reads list is Snowvon, Jan, and myself are citizens with tom and owner being lesser citizens. I don't trust newcomb. I have a vote on Koalas which I am probably going to move as long as it doesn't get me miss lynched by doing so.

Koalas is reconsidering on me which always makes me want to go I might be wrong here. One of my flaws as a player is I see something ,get focused on it and then read a person through that focus point. It's the conclusion reached through that focus point that is the important part. I am not saying Koalas is now a citizen but probably shouldn't be the End of Day.

I want to be convinced that newcomb is a citizen here by Snowvon and Jan because I at this point don't trust him. It was jan's post about how newcomb would be better prepared that rings the bell of distrust in my head. I think newcomb's explanation was adequate enough but I need that bell to stop or at least be muffled.

I should have posted as I caught up on the thread instead of reading straight through as it feels better to me personally. No one is on right now so I am probably talking to myself at this point. I am sad I am no longer capable of playing large player setups like my first ever forum game.

 

Slippery :
My biggest reason for believing newcomb is town is

because when I see his long catch up posts i basically read them and nod along. i don't really see him trying to push on obvious towns in there or making any mistakes in his reads, if he is scum.

Like .. I am always somewhat paranoid about him because he is the person left in this game which i respect the most in terms of his scumplay, but I think it is more likely just my paranoia.


I wanted to bring up the 2nd point that mal brought up. he said that basically everyone excepted his information as fact straight away.
Which is more or less true but .. if he was scum, then his team has no reason to go against him at the time.

Anyways - I have no real reason outside of paranoia to believe Newcomb is scum. And I really should sleep .. one day.

---------- Post automerged at 16:10 ---------- Previous post was at 16:03 ----------

In the end the decision is yours to make.

 

I will keep the thread open in my background which is breaking my rule about hovering to refresh it occasionally to see if anyone has any thoughts, questions and or commentary.

---------- Post automerged at 10:26 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:11 AM ----------

Hi Jan

Sleep and I are now friends or I am suffering Stockholm Syndrome to Sleep since it has taken me hostage so often lately. I feel I am going to regret this next decision later on in the game by the way on multiple levels.

You should watch Bull if you get a chance as it's an interesting take on the Trial show format.

 

Might do that .. good luck.

I need to buy my meds before the store closes.

 

This will be interesting as I've struggled with this internally and a tiny bit externally but I've made my decision. Hopefully the result will be a good one despite that muffled bell in my mental background.

---------- Post automerged at 11:17 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:14 AM ----------

I am out for a bit as real life marches relentlessly on regardless of what we may want to ahppen.

 

Look you guys can blame me if everything goes down the drain from here.

I really want people to read this and have no idea what we are talking about.

 

that was an odd choice?!

newcomb being the apprentice turned gravedigger.
as what between the two of them does he count?

Like I think it was meant for newcomb .. we'll see how mechanics work.

 

Priest might as well claim in their next post at this rate.

---------- Post automerged at 11:49 ---------- Previous post was at 11:48 ----------

Wait, is this literally after Rob said he didn't really trust Newcomb?

 

why?

It was always a possible play to give newcomb another life.

Risky if he is scum. Precious if he is town.

There are still like 2-3 ppl with mafia and priest hidden between them!

Angels know who the priest is anyway .. so we are fine on that front.

And rob softed nurse so hard .. it made me jiggle inside and out.

---------- Post automerged at 17:52 ---------- Previous post was at 17:51 ----------

he said he is unsure, but trusts me and wants my opinion.

Like honey .. if he is town you can just blame me, fairly easy


I feel like taking risks today!

 

I'm skeptical.

 

There is a chance that Newcomb didnt even got the life and it is on the dead gravedigger.

Or slip and Newcomb are a team and vira was apprentice and they tricked us all.

 

I think it was decided that Apprentice-turned-Gravedigger is the Gravedigger for Nursing purposes.

Also the Assassin.

 

I do not know those things.

Deciding this would be stupid, because sometimes village thinks x but y is the reality.

staying with the original roles is always the save thing.

Apprentice does not become gravedigger, he takes over their duty.