What does that make you think about his alignment? Or are you just saying that for no reason?

 

That was at Miner right?

 

Jarizok, read walls are a shorthand used to concisely rank your reads. Making without detailed explanations is meaningless, as it gives readers no insight into your thought process and all scum to adjust reads and make up shit after the fact.

You're overreliant on them. Changs that, and your play will improve.

Also, try not to take cues from Kai.

 

I'd generally agree with you, but this list speaks for itself.

 

If it spoke for itself, would a third of the game be asking you for clarity?

 

I've only just posted it. You're the first to mention it.

---------- Post automerged at 03:06 ---------- Previous post was at 03:05 ----------

Mention it > react to it.

 

So does it speak for itself, or were you going to elaborate?

 

Babe. You've been saying that read list since the beginning of the Day, just without the pretty colors.

 

The pretty colors make all the difference.

---------- Post automerged at 03:11 ---------- Previous post was at 03:11 ----------

But fine, I'll give you my thought process.

 

I know. That's why I introduced it to this forum years ago.

---------- Post automerged at 09:11 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:11 PM ----------

Lovely, thanks.

 

If Newcomb is scum we lose the game straight up, and he's vouching for Von. Since we lose in any world where they are scum, I'll play in townfirmed Newcomb/Snowvon world.
Miner has been individually arguably the towniest of everyone here and Koalas hasn't been that active but townie when he has been.

That leaves Tom Fonti and Cobalt as scum. Tom and Cobalt aren't w/w together from what I've seen, so that leaves Tom/Fonti or Cobalt/Fonti. I'm thinking Cobalt/Fonti but since Fonti is in both teams she's the best lynch in my book.

 

Why do we lose the game if Newcomb is scum?

 

Because he's got us all wrapped around his pinkytoes.

 

Your Miner and Koalas reads needs some.... what do you call it. Work?

 

But townfirming you because of no alternative is fine?

---------- Post automerged at 03:20 ---------- Previous post was at 03:20 ----------

To be honest, it could all use some fleshing out.

 

Like... you're repping a confidence level in that read like you can PoE the game without having an actual case. I'm kind of not super buying that being a genuine mindset with how inexperienced you are combined with how generic your town reads on Miner/Koalas are.

 

Finding substantiations for my claims is on my to do list, but today I've just been sitting back enjoying my birthday. I figured I could try a Kai day.

It was not well received.

---------- Post automerged at 03:22 ---------- Previous post was at 03:21 ----------

What can I say, I'm a confident guy with strangers on the internet.

 

Writing me off as town is fine as either alignment here. I'm obviously town, if you're mafia then from your point of view I'm /super/ obviously town, and if you're town then congrats you have a correct read.

 

That's exactly what Mafia!Newcomb would say.