I disagree.

Mathblade being this insistent on miner being town when miner was the counterwagon.

Not voting to save themself.

I might be wrong, but I don't think scum!mathblade plays it off like that if the situation is that dire.
There are points where you happily bus to either fake spew a partner or survive and get the cred for them dying.

 

Still have a hard time seeing scum!fluff doing This Thing as a Witch.

Like. We lynched scum D1. Witches flubbed their kill. And fluff just keeps fluffing.

 

Don't believe Wacos reads even remotely; can't fathom the placement of Typhon and my slot at all especially given that Miner is effectively confirmed mafia here. His "Math is absent from his catch up wall" ignores that I devoted an entire post solely based on Math, this a huge huge thing to miss.

 

I.. don't even.

That list is so far away from him saying you're buddies that this reaction is much ado about literally nothing.

 

This post is just bad... And Mathblade should no why. Does this look familliar?

 

maybe.

i don't think koalas alignment matters for it.

Sure he can prepare an answer .. but i am curious to know what it is anyway.

 

I read your seperate post. It was weak on reasoning and the beginnings of a pure defense on a player you were simultaneously saying wasn't town at that point

 

I probably should reread Regfan, I might have been biased because I was fervantly reading the thread and he just kept seeming to say exactly what I wanted to interject.

But at the same time. Those are town things he was bringing to the thread.

 

Don't buy this stance or reasoning from you at all, if you'd read #904 you'd have noticed #893 where I devote a wall post on my stance/thoughts on Math and there's an entire discussion that occurs from it.

---------- Post automerged at 09:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:44 PM ----------

There's absolutely no way you miss that post if you're town and reading through the conversation with an attempt to discern peoples alignments there.

 

Uh, no, I read it (as I said above), and actively think it's a waste of time. You claimed a town read on Math for no reason, briefly acknowledge scummy things, and then hand wave them into not lynching Math.

You and Mathblade are blatantly tied together

 

I think the first part does, I have a few theories about last night, both differ based on his alignment. I would have liked to have seen his natural unproded reaction to that happening, you reminding him of that comment from earlier doesn't really help.

 

Regfan, take us back to your entrance. Where in the list does Mathblade go?

Because I did also find that a bit weird how they wasn't in there. Like, you did elaborate later, but leaving him out of the wall gives a bit more flexibility on how you push them later.

 

Hey. Hey Math. I broke this game wide open!

/conf!town

 

I mean.

Waco has played enough withow both miner/me to know our interactions were not even sorta w/w, and past that I've been towny as /fuck/. I just noticed my name in yellow bc I thought it was a given for everybody not Math that I was a consensus townread at this point.

But you're right, the Reg bit is worse unless he's literally pushing Miner, Reg, Math, in which case... I mean I don't really think we're in that world.

 

Not even remotely what happened; my push on Miner had nothing to do with a read on Math but entirely to do with being very very confident that Miner was scum here - the case on him was significantly stronger. Wanted to make sure the D1 lynch was always going to be my strongest scum read. Where my head is at with Math is very apparent, I've gone over it multiple times, I think they could plausibly be scum here, I don't think they're the most likely scum in this scenario but they're not out of my suspect pool at all and I will be analysing them when I go through Miners ISO.

But run me through your thought process here. First of do you agree Miners always scum here? If yes you're trying to sell a world where I replace in, pull a wagon of one partner and drive it onto another; that makes no sense whatsoever especially when it's combined with scum taking a lolshot at souping N1. Your read and thought process doesn't mesh; you're effectively stating that I a) Hard bussed and then b) Didn't take a safe night kill but instead went for a suboptimal soup attempt on Jan of all players.

 

/conf!town 2 - electric boogaloo!

 

Squarely in the null pile. Didn't add them in the pile initially because a) I had conflicted thoughts on them in general; town reading their first half of the day play and scum reading elements of their second half and b) I wanted to spend an entire post solely on them to try and convey my headspace about them with others as well as try and work out exactly where I am with them myself.

 

To Waco's credit, my Reg paranoia did resurface a bit, which makes me not reject his argument out of hand. I'll try and do a Reg mindset later in the game day (ie not in this RL day).

 

/conftown 3?

 

Mindset analysis*

---------- Post automerged at 08:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:57 PM ----------

Damn it Snow. /conftown 4