Who are you lynching?

---------- Post automerged at 08:13 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:12 PM ----------

Aren't you the "I'm bored because the game is solved" person? Show me a solved game, don't just tell me.

 

I'm voting Rubicon, who I've gone off multiple times about. At this point, Jari is falling back onto town side. I just want to lynch Rubicon. I thought D2 would be easy because we'd only have to wait for Rubicon's flip, but that looks like it isn't going to happen.

 

In no particular order its late, I still have a lot to do for tomorrow IRL, the hour and thirteen minutes from when you posted (40 minutes from me posting) is not enough time, you still wouldn't be caught up which was kind of my main point and when its a 10 small things that all add up it's a lot easier to dismiss individual pieces then it would be if it was just one or two big things.

 

Is your case the same as Typhon's? Is there a point on him I haven't addressed?

 

My case is the same as Typhon's. Who do you mean by 'him'?

 

Your main point is that I'm not caught up and I'm trying my best to contribute anyways?

You're right it's easier to dismiss individual pieces instead of the big piece, but the greatest reason why that's the case is because the individual pieces are concrete and much easier to talk about than the big piece. I also don't understand how you expect me to address the case otherwise unless I just flat out don't contribute; I also think that my rebuttal of Rubicon having no real motivation to continue the conversation in either of those instances and too much being made out of a very very early interaction is absolutely a valid point but instead of addressing the substance you just criticize the general approach (which is, coincidentally, not a new point at all).

---------- Post automerged at 08:26 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:25 PM ----------

Rubicon.
If your case is equivalent, defend it. Don't complain about your lynch not going through while simultaneously doing nothing to help it along.

---------- Post automerged at 08:27 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:26 PM ----------

Why is Jari going back to the town side? What has he done today that looks town?

 

~30 minutes until day end. You have ~20 minutes to place any final bids!

 

Can you make a quick summary of your case on Rubicon?

 

Vira's Rubicon case is Typhon's Rubicon case, apparently.

 

Oh fluffiness.

 

Re: case on Rubicon.

Basically, these are my points.

1. The Cobalt lynch will go nowhere and the very fact it’s the main wagon over other possible lynches (Rubicon / Kalas / Fluff / Font) bothers me.
2. Rubicon’s flip will give us the most information. If he’s town, I’ll tie myself to the pyre and save you the trouble.
3. Rubicon’s activity isn’t alignment-indicative. I’m always more active as scum because I have more motivation to post and keep the game up. Inactive games with me as scum are depressing because no one’s trying to catch me.
4. Rubicon, as outlined as Typhon and some of my posts, has shown scummy behavior. I know you, Nacho, have argued against this, but as you just told Fluff, his case is my case (though I don't agree with him about you/Waco at this time).

All of these together makes me want to lynch Rubicon the most.

Jari has gone up because other people are behaving more scummy than him. This isn't the first time Fluff has done a drive-by vote, and after Tom continuously aping my wagons on D1, I'm automatically suspicious that Kalas is now on my D2 wagon.

 

Jari makes no sense as scum with Cobalt. Minimal sense as town, I grant you, but no sense as scum. No way he hard townreads the guy leading the lynch on his partner when it would have been infinitely easier to join me on Rubicon.

Agree/disagree?

 

Not having embedded photos really takes the oomph out of most of these pictures. Hoping fluff will post a follow-up to it eventually but won't be particularly surprised if it never comes.

 

Jarizok
Typhon

Miner
His Fluffiness

Koalas

Vira

Rubicon

Nachomamma8 The Waco Kid
Cobalt
Tammy Fontisian

I have townreads on everyone above Rubicon.

The fluffiness things is some sort of culmination of small things he said.
The way he played around tom Eod1.
The way he gave reads d2 (he did not read me town because everyone did, he had a reason that made sense for him)
His approach and derpy-ness. There is no part of him trying to appease or being the town-fluff people want him to be (Which was scum-fluff last time around).

I am close to saying the top 4 are just lock town.

 

With a playerlist that is 2/3rds here, I really don't see the benefit of lynching someone who's as active as Rubicon is.

Like, he's going to be mentally exhausted as scum if he has to keep up this play for another 4 days.

Can any of you guys point me to where exactly Cobalt has been at all towny?

Yes, you can make the case that Cobalt's flip doesn't really tell us anything.

But then I'd like to know what Rubicon's flip will tell us?

Also, didn't we all want to lynch Rubicon last game, and then that boat just sailed down the line?

 

Agreed, especially when Cobalt's getting replaced.

 

Vote Rubicon

I think I am willing to trust Typhon. I agree that this lynch gives us more to follow up on.

 

In the like, 15 minutes we have, Jan what are you rolling up for tomorrow?

 

Are you physically unable to state any specific part of Typhon's case that you agree with?