When I wrote the first sentence I was not sure on the answer.

 

Hey Fluff, I asked you a question.

What do you think you're doing, right now, to advance your team's wincon?

 

Yeah, this feels like Miner just attempting to limit information we recieve upon his lynch, think or at least hope if he's town here he'd focus on reading what he can of the thread and posting reads. I'm pretty unlikely to be moving my vote anytime soon; far too much that points towards Miner being scum with his awkward entrance and interactions with Fonti, his de-crediting her and then stating he scum reads her which are actions that don't mesh. His continued active lurking but no actual scumhunting or transparent thought process and his attempt to defend himself by lying about his recent meta here and his complaint about lurkers being given a pass over himself.

Like I'm pretty sure he's scum here and haven't seen anything that points against it.

I find Fontis reaction towards Miners recent posts and her "If I die I think this" as fairly genine? I think the actual action is something she can fake but the way that it transpired feels like she legitimately thinks he might nuke her as scum and her reads left behind are all things that make sense with her stances. I feel quite a bit better about her being town.

---------- Post automerged at 10:53 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:52 PM ----------
Newcomb - Lets have a fun little challenge, lets play "Name the scum team", we'll both take a shot at 5 names here and see who named more scum postgame. I'll let you go first.

 

Yeah, Miner hasn't done much since his return that gives me a lot of faith in him.

 

[Miner, Owner, Koalas, Waco, Jan]
Regfan

 

his fluffiness, consider this a seconding of the above.

Also Newcomb, question for you in #914 when you can

 

I'm somewhat buying Rubicon's frustration with how he's being perceived ITT given the context of last game.

Anything more in-depth will have to wait until I can sit down at a computer.

 

I'm taking [Miner, Owner, Jan, Fluff, Vaimes]

 

are you really taking Vaimes

 

I don't actually like Reg's read of me here. I think that would have been an easy thing for me to fake.

 

I'm kinda intrigued at both of you including Jan in your 5 man team despite a light LT and a null read given.

Bayes theorem to the test I suppose

 

Yes although it's not entirely a serious guess, I just feel like replacing him with Cobalt would be sort of a cop-out type guess and you'd already taken Koalas who I might have considered before him. I'm actually feeling a bit better about Rubicon lately and I feel like how the games played out there's a decent chance he's the wrong scum read I had and I still have Waco as town, leaning the same way with Fable and I'm in a weird position of wanting Kai to be town. I also think Miner/Vaimes make sense.

 

Here's my dark horse hipster team:

[fontisian, Cobalt, Jarizok, Regfan, Vaimes]

 

Newcomb probably wins here tbh.

---------- Post automerged at 12:14 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:12 AM ----------

Don't worry I'm pretty sure you're still in both your ranges here.

That fact is pretty much the only reason my slight W read on miner isn't stronger.

 

How does Miner/Vaimes make any degree of sense in a world where fontisian's town?

I reeeeeeeeally don't see that early fonti/Vaimes interaction going like that if that's the world.

---------- Post automerged at 09:16 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:15 PM ----------

can you explain this for the dumb-dumbs in the peanut gallery

 

@Fonti - It's not the fact that you've posted a "here's my reads when I die" type post, I've faked that as scum and think you're capable of doing so too. It's that the specific situation you posted it feels very natural to do so and the fact that Jan crossposted with the same sort of "Miners setting up KP" strengthens that it's a legitimate concern you could have had there rather than an attempt to get town read.

@Waco - I don't think I've had a town read on Jan this game, my concerns with him are something I've been pretty vocal about. I'm not really interested in lynching him anytime soon but not having him as town right now is a concern.

We only have two different reads here and I think his Waco one is probably wrong? So I think he only wins here if Koalas is scum and neither of Fluff/Vaimes are and I feel decent about Fluff being scum. I think a draw is probably likely.

 

Man, when did Fable become top poster?

 

I've been top poster for over 24 hours lol.

 

Humm, fair enough.