Bluh, assassin, not dob.

 

It does depend on their exact composition, true.

How do you feel about a colbalt - watchman assassination?

---------- Post automerged at 09:52 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:47 AM ----------

 

Don't necessary think scum don't have KP, decently likely the person with it just wasn't online between Fables soft and Fluffs hard claim.

Assassinating Cobalt seems suboptimal.

Is having the Old Dame claim if they're in the POE and contemplating lynching them a +EV move here? Cuts down the suspect pool by 1, if they're town they can give Fluff an extra life and we have control of angel/demon chat and have reduced the suspect pool by 1 and if they're mafia well we lynch mafia.

---------- Post automerged at 07:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:59 PM ----------

Feels like a win/win move

 

Not great about it. I have a reasonably strong townread on Cobalt.

 

I don't regret it at all. I did it so people could have a PoE that actually made sense instead of dicking around most of the day looking at me and fluff.

 

Not happy about having to claim, but the more time we spend looking at non townclears, the better.

 

I mean, the choice isn't just a binary between 'claim now' and 'claim near end of day'. There's a lot of time between those two points.

Given fluffs play it's kind of moot anyway but still.

---------- Post automerged at 10:11 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:04 AM ----------

This is pretty good I'd think.

 

If the BoD isn't in the PoE, it gives scum that information, but given how many town clears we have, they're not aiming at BoD, so yeah, at first glance it seems good.

 

I still think cobalt is probably a witch.

His posts are all like I AM EVIL YOLO.

---------- Post automerged at 10:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:44 AM ----------

font is Rubicon doing this because he just doesn't get it or ???????

 

Have a thumbs up+

 

Um hi we aren't lynching my hard clear THANKS

 

Hi.

My lynch pool is still [Rubicon, Kai, Koalas, font, Jarizok].

 

I think Kai is honestly openwolfing at me here

I'm almost universally townread, my claim fixed a haunted check and he's proposing me as an assassin target?

 

Vaimes
Jan
---
his fluffiness (Priest)
Fable (Acolyte)
---
Delphine (Oracle)
Miner
---
Cobalt (Watchman)
Regfan
---
Atum
---
Jarizok (Gravedigger)
---
Vira
Waco
Newcomb
---
Fontisian
KaiDASH
Rubicon
Koalas
---
owner (Fanatic)

I only have Jarizok higher by virtue of his claim/usefulness. I could be misreading one of the three below him, but eh. The four above owner should all die.

 

Why is Atum higher than Jari?

 

a - so what, b - you don't get credit for something that happened after your claim, c - if you're a witch you're not watchman anyway.

 

The role circlejerk alone has eliminated what, six? Seven people from being lynched? Unless anyone can come up with plausible theories for Delphine or Cobalt being scum.

(I know Kai has a scumread on Cobalt but realistically, if Kai is a witch, who else is he gonna push?)

I'm town. I explained why I think Newcomb and Waco aren't scum with owner, feel free to check those out and stuff. Vira is...towny, I guess, but there's a lot going on so that doesn't hold a ton of weight anymore. Same for Atum, but I still ~think he's out of his scumrange? Possibility of coaching for either of them, but eh.

---------- Post automerged at 20:58 ---------- Previous post was at 20:58 ----------

I have a much easier time reading Atum.

 

A, do you honestly think that the rest of town consensus agrees to assassinate someone that's widely town read?

B - I'm not taking credit for anything, I had no way of knowing my randomized result corrected a haunted priest check - the odds of that happening are like next to nothing, so do you really think I'm bluffing here?

C - I don't feel the need to justify myself to you because you very well could be a witch, but the fact that I'm directly contradicting your proposed assassination should tell you that I am indeed what I say I am.

---------- Post automerged at 09:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:01 PM ----------

I mean... true. Poor Kai.

 

If your scum and fucking with me here, please nominate an appropriate quote for my signature.

Pretty much the only world I see Newcomb as scum at this point is if he was distancing with the owner vote, plus "let's get wagons" thing, figuring Miner was dead to rights, and had nowhere to go when Delphine drops the oracle claim. That seems unlikely.

Given the subsequent claims
owner [9]: Newcomb, The Waco Kid, Regfan, Vira, Cobalt, Jarizok, Vaimes, Atum, Koalas
Rubicon [3]: Fable, Delphine, His Fluffiness
Jarizok [2]: owner, KaiDASH
Regfan [2]: Jan, Fontisian
Koalas [1]: Miner
Miner [1]: Rubicon

(nods)

tbc...

 

To name a few: Jarizok, Waco, Kalas, Rubicon, Atum.

I wouldn't have committed to fontisian as town either.