1. I don't really see the big deal here. Yes, I'll use a different styles to get reads on different players. In Newcomb's case, I thought he was either misunderstanding or deflecting my comments, so kept pushing on it a few times to see how he'd react. That said, you overstate the surge. For example my #914 to Newcomb fits right into the same catagory as some of the other examples you cite.

2. Fable in short, I was already convinced on my read of him. If you'll note, I'd kept my vote on Fable for a while hoping we'd get that wagon, so he wasn't a priority re-read. As for letting off on him posting wise, 2 reasons. 1) After my war with Titus in Naruto, and my tunnel on Majube in HP Mafia, I've concluded that repeated going after people I'm already confident are scum distracted my game, so after thinking Fable was scum, I turned my focus to finding the others 4. 2) He had the breakdown thing and I didn't feel like adding on it.

3. This is just bad for many reasons. Firstly, I used a gambit that 1) had already been used on DLP 2) Wasn't very subtle with the alphabetizing, and the fact it but consensus towns Vaimes and Vira on the bottom. I was hoping to get something from it and sad I didn't get much, but wasn't surprised that it didn't last long.

Additionally, it wasn't Rubicon who shot the gambit apart, it's was Snowvon who called it out first, then Fable, before Rubicon cleaned it up.

---------- Post automerged at 09:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:45 AM ----------

Alright, I need sleep, badly

 

Good morning.

I'm the Assassin, but everyone already knew that.

Off to study.

 

I mean sure, but like pretty much the entire town was more or less on my wagon. Anyone in particular?

---------- Post automerged at 11:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:17 AM ----------

Alright there are literally two roles that haven't been claimed for town.
..

 

Uhh, what???

Miner [6]: Fontisian, Regfan, Cobalt, Rubicon, Vira, Vaimes,
Rubicon [3]: Fable, Delphine, His Fluffiness
Fable [2]: Jarizok, Waco,
Owner [1]: Newcomb,
Jarizok [2]: Owner, KaiDASH
Regfan [2]: Jan, Atum
Fontisian [1]: Miner

Abstaining [1]: Koalas,

 

Should I claim?

 

Out of 7 confirmed town, 5 were not on your wagon. You really need to re-evaluate here.

---------- Post automerged at 11:33 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:32 AM ----------

(I forgot to put Jan as green)

 

Delphine

Are you sure Miner's town here?

Maybe go check your QT. Do you wear glasses? Did you have them on when you read your check? It would be a totally understandable mistake.

---------- Post automerged at 08:50 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:41 AM ----------

????

I said nothing in that post that I hadn't been saying either explicitly (with my focus toDay) or implicitly (with my lack of push on potential gambits / The Quartet toDay).

 

Newcomb correct me if I'm wrong but you haven't claimed yet have you?

 

Nope. Don't really want to. I will if we mass claim, since, yeah.

 

Not just referring to people on my wagon bud

 

Uhh. Delphine, are you sure he's town?

 

Yeahhhhh I'm not comfortable Nursing Delphine.

 

Then Nurse Fluff.

 

Can't nurse a holy.

 

Oh.

Then just Nurse Delphine. There's no way she and Miner are scum, no matter how hard Miner tries.

 

Probably an unpopular opinion but I'd nurse reg.

I get delphine is a safe bet but reg is almost always a villager as well and he's more likely to do something with the extra life.

 

Mehhh, I have my concerns.

---------- Post automerged at 18:39 ---------- Previous post was at 18:39 ----------

About Delphine that is. Reg is fine with me.

 

Which are?

 

If the scummies have multiple lives + KP in their team but no info roles, faking that D1 and then having town lynch through the PoE for a while gets them in a really good spot. They know there's going to be a bunch of town clears, because town has basically all the town info roles and they start the clears themselves.

The play then wasn't to panic-save Miner "the weak scum player", the entire set up was about getting town to clear a bunch of people, including 2 scum, and lynch through the PoE for a while. If we don't realize this plan early enough, witches use their KP and tank it out with their extra lives.

It's a bit tinfoil, but Koalas is probably scum regardless so it doesn't matter too much today. Just don't want to let scum!Koalas nurse scum!Delphine to give them all those lives if I'm on to something here.

---------- Post automerged at 19:03 ---------- Previous post was at 19:02 ----------

They would have obviously had and discarded Oracle in this world. Owner was Fanatic, so she might have then been playing this scummily to elicit a check rather than get lynched?

---------- Post automerged at 19:05 ---------- Previous post was at 19:03 ----------

How many roles would scum discard over Fanatic anyway?

 

The lynch was between Miner and Owner. Why save Miner, the 'weak scum player', and get rid of Owner who was apparently playing badly so she could get an extra life?