Well, I feel like Koalas doesn't have to be scum is probably a better way of putting it if he nurses me here.

But, like you said, I'd be really really surprised if he nursed me here.

 

Hey look, sane people! \o/

 

Right. It doesn't confirm him, there are still worlds, but it would make me want to look at other people first.

I agree it's not likely to happen.

 

Mentally classifying the town as "two types"

---------- Post automerged at 09:32 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:30 PM ----------

The real question here is, if Koalas doesn't nurse me or Delphine, does that mean he's confirmed scum.

 

Just so we understand how insane going down this rabbit hole is let's say koalas does agree to nurse miner and people start entertaining the idea that he's a villager then by extension you give leeway to fonti for suggesting it and rubicon for backing it up.

Now having done that I want you to create a witch team that does not include any of the three mentioned above and that actually make sense.

glgl

 

Hi, even if Kalas is town, that does not by any means equate to either Rubicon or fonti town.

Besides, if it's really a scum!Nurse, you have to pressure him in order to either out as scum, or use it on confirmed town and thereby getting the most out of a witch role.

 

How come?

I could see fontisian working that angle as a witch.

 

So you would give leeway to koalas for nursing miner but not fonti for suggesting it?

 

Koalas nursing Miner here means zero. When you give someone an out like that and say "if you do this we'll lynch elsewhere," and they do it, that means, like. Nearly nothing.

Witch!Koalas has two choices here. 1) Give the semi-townfirmed Hunter an extra life, probably guaranteeing town control over that KP. 2) Out as mafia.

Gee, I wonder which one he's going to do? KP can be put on town, dead witches are forever and you just lost one D1.

Like. Someone convince me how it's alignment indicative at all?

 

Like I said, he's not town for it, he's just not necessarily scum.

Besides, are you so confident he's scum here?

I'm /like/ 80%, but I'm perfectly willing to have him drop his KP on a townfirmed player and then lynch elsewhere.

 

Knowing fonti, yes.

 

Not like if we lynch elsewhere Kalas can do anything here.

---------- Post automerged at 09:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:51 PM ----------

Oh also, has everyone claimed?

 

Can we stop talking about how we'd read Koalas and what we'd do if he nursed Miner and just wait for him to do it.

 

What Newcomb said.

My vote is staying where it is until Kalas is in the ground.

 

I'll admit in a way I really want koalas to nurse miner not because it's a good idea but more because I'm more interested in seeing where fonti and rubicon would move.

 

I would move to Kai.

fonti would move to me.

These things are obvious.

 

How about we all stay on Kalas like sane people and have a good time.

 

This is a 100% read then?

 

Point to a post where Kalas has done something towny.

 

There's definitely something ironic here...