Atum

So cobalt outted himself for reg for what reason exactly?

 

Matter of fact, idgaf about anything else, your ISO was convincing enough that I'd believe any world in which you could potentially be scum.

Vote: Regfan

 

You deserve an award for even opening Reg's ISO.

 

What is going on.

 

Listen man, I don't know. I'm not a witch. I do know that Reg's been scummy as fuck all game and I'm going to make sure that's as clear as possible before I get killed for being an 'optimal lynch' or something.

---------- Post automerged at 19:56 ---------- Previous post was at 19:56 ----------

One of the most painful endeavors I've undertaken on this site.

 

After this game, no one will have to suffer like that ever again.

 

I like this Atum post. Alot.

 

This whole reg/atum thing has all the makings of a dumb as hell v/v fight and I'm not thrilled I'm going to probably have to give it some sort of attention.

 

Hmm. Feeling font or Atum here.

---------- Post automerged at 09:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:59 PM ----------

Or, after that post, maybe not.

 

No that's not how this works. If you can't tell me why cobalt makes that move as a witch then you're wasting your time focusing on reg.

 

My time to waste. But hey, how do you feel about Cobalt and Reg right now?

 

Atum, who is your Dame power pointed to at the moment?

 

I think they're both villagers.

 

So let's go through this because you're ignoring context behind most of it;

I town read your entrance into the game, I town read your attitude re; disliking people town reading you both so easily, both of these tonally came across as very genuine and town. I brought up my concern with your decrease in content as the games progressed and explained how that weakened my town read on you, I asked and stated that I was awaiting your catch up posts and reads, they never happened, I still thought you were town but you were moving down my town list due to it.

Then I bring up the point about BoD claiming and we lynch them, you claimed, I found the claim to be a town-indicator, this was all before mass-claim had finished happening. Mass-claim then finished happening and we're left with Judge/Spiritualist being the unclaimed roles, if Judge is scums 6th role then they have to claim their true role which means that the reasoning for town reading your claim becomes nullified. I also found the way that people treated your claim and stopped being interested in following through to make more sense in worlds where you're scum, I've explained and gone into this already.

I've done a lot of "World building attempts" in the last ~48 hours, and it constantly points towards having incorrect town reads initially, I think that could be you, I think that being the case and you being the BoD makes lynching you completely the right move.

Lets put it another way; if you weren't the BoD, I'd not even be remotely interested in lynching you today, I probably wouldn't be looking into you anywhere near the extent I have, I mentioned earlier that I felt okay enough with giving you and Vira a day or two, but the BoD claim drastically changes that in regards to you, it brings up an element where it's optimal to look towards you today. The fact that you're ignored that in your entire way and analysis is incredibly scummy.

 

Uhhh nobody? I sort of figured I'd get some direction before getting murderkilled.

Why? You want it?

 

Point it towards Fluff. He's the Priest and needs it most.

 

Get out of here with this weak mess. How on earth does this translate to: "I have solid logic that points to Atum being scum."
or
"I think there's a reasonable chance Atum is scum here"

Actually, directly after I claimed, you contradict the above post EXPLICITLY. I know this is a game where sometimes you have to lie, but do me the courstesy of not lying to my face about your reasoning when I literally read through your entire ISO post by post.

/r

 

No, it's not. It's incredibly Atum.

Like, Fable is entirely correct when he says that it makes no sense for Atum to just be like "idk about Coablt but this Reg guy is totes a witch, guys."

But the way Atum's ignoring that way of looking at the game, and the way he's ignoring the utility of lynching the BoD here regardless of alignment, and the way your read on him took that into account, is just... not really an alignment indicative thing for him? If anything I think it actually makes him more likely to be town, sad to say.

Granted, my meta with him is not large. But him being this specific kind of oblivious / bull in a china shop just... radically doesn't fit my idea of his scumgame.

 

Done. /10townies

 

Give it to me!

Being vanilla in a WH is feelsbad.

---------- Post automerged at 21:09 ---------- Previous post was at 21:09 ----------

Or fine I guess fluff can have it.