I'm on my phone. Ask for reasons and ye shall receive, but this was mostly to synthesize my own thoughts. I'm not doing a wall.

 

I liked him for his reads but I kind of agree with whoever said he's being even less involved on purpose.

Also his read on Cobalt makes no sense after WH8.

 

Scum or town?

Like, when have I ever read Kai? Why would you expect me to be?

---------- Post automerged at 03:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:44 PM ----------

So. Point me to what makes them indefensible. Because pushing on Kai placement is laughably bad. Like, obsessed over non poster dC placememt bad.

---------- Post automerged at 03:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:46 PM ----------

Note to self: stop playing so well.

 

More of a TMI illness.

As scum you want to be towny and the best way to do that is to kill scum.

You are always down to pounce on a teammate and are inclined to bus them even before they get heat.

All of that is fine, but you are not accurate enough as town for that to be an even playstyle.


That and a "vast tonal gap". People dislike your tone as town and think you to play well and be reasonable as scum.

 

Yeah I know. I'm more riffing on how awesomely I've been playing this game. I've set the tone just exactly right, and ignored some of fontis more blatant slips. Heck, I'm even gunning for max unreasonableness with the KaiDASH placement!

 

Okay, you don't get to have a gun.

 

you are also making me lynch you by being lame and annoying and me not wanting to lose to what you are doing.

 

I don't really have anything that I haven't put in the thread already, but I can list them all here again.

blab
Vaimes
Adult (Miner)

Jan
Regfan
Fable
Quiddity

fontisian
Jarizok (I should have a read here but I really don't).
KaiDASH
Stanari
Zenzao (I read him as town but I'm really curious about Miner's point, so I want to see what shakes out there before sorting him.)

Acionyx (his more recent posts seemed better, want to reread)
dichotomousCreator (This was my general impression, I got the sense he was very strongly just going with the flow with all of his reads. I could very easily be wrong about this since I didn't detail read his catchup yet, so this is subject to change after I do that and reread the rest of his posts.)
The Waco Kid
Plotless
Cobalt* (A lot of people here who have played with him more than me were saying what I was reading about him was playstyle, so I don't have any faith in this read anymore. If his posts when he catches up are OK enough then I'll probably back off of it entirely.)

First tier is anyone I have legit reason to believe is town, second I just think are town based on ~feeling~, third is null, bottom are scum reads (no real order atm). I don't really have anything strong yet.

 

Rude.

/I'd rather be divisive than indecisive

---------- Post automerged at 04:16 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:13 PM ----------

You reminded me:

@dC, you never elaborated where I was pressured earlier that I disappeared to avoid.


To flip it a bit, pienyan I feel dC sort of led the charge on me. I hadnt noticed any pressure prior to that

 

I reread some of Batmafia. Looks like I was remembering Zeit, not Zen, who had a similar overreaction as scum in a different game. I feel reasonably comfortable calling Zen town.

I find the town reads on Jan confusing. Would anyone care to explain?

---------- Post automerged at 05:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:17 PM ----------

We've already concluded that dC is not in a group qt because he would have known the game had started and faking that would be stupid, yeah?

 

Hi. I'm stuck on my phone and would rather not be walling right now but can make a few replies if anyone is dying for my attention.
Plotless, why did you call me Stan?

 

Eh, wasn't gonna vocalize that read, font, but yeah.

 

I was on my phone, lazy with typing

 

Plotless Stanari pienyan I asked a question recently and I really would like you guys to answer it.

 

Try
Try to forget what's in the past
Tomorrow is here
Love,
Orange sky above lighting your way
There's nothing to fear Eels - Fresh Feeling

---------- Post automerged at 23:41 ---------- Previous post was at 23:39 ----------

Meh .. should have hit the return key one more time.

You'll get it, eventually.

 

zenzao or pie. I'd probably want zenzao to have the pressure to force something with a day kill.

 

I think I would give dC a gun.

 

What about zen's play gave you the sense that they're trying to work out the game?

 

I like him trying to work out fonti (#298) and Quiddity (#318, #327, #337, some others) and fable (#348, #352, #361, #392), especially in maintaining pressure on Fable.

 

What about his process specifically makes you think it's coming from town though?