--- Post automerged ---

Look I am not voting the afk person that stated that she is sick as hell. It is pointless pressure and just dickish.

We could both unvote until we find something else, but like .. Not touching that slot for at least 24 hours and then we will see if she comes back and what she is doing.
Or you tell me where else to go and I see what I think about it in an hour.

Unvote

 

I don't see what you are seeing. Think you can help me see it?

 

I'm not voting Tsaiah, I switched my vote?

 

It's time dependent. He scumread me when the only thing I'd done that game was shitpost. And then once Newcomb cased me he jumped immediately onto that case and said "oh yeah his earlier posts were bad too I see what you're seeing" but like my earlier posts were RVS posts.

 

@Jan

This is where my vote is and where yours were? Unless I missed it, only Tsaiah said they were sick?

 

I haven't been at my best in the last 12 hour, sorry. Brain not working at full capacity etc.

Sure.

Vote Nothing Happens

I remember colouring these letters before, yes.

Spoiler: Secret to the colours

I colour every letter that is part of the word yellow in said colour just because she told citrus to not use that colour.

My secret way of still being a dick.

 

By our powers combined!

 

Thanks, I follow but I can't check for that without more synthesis than I have in me right now.

Loooool.

 

I guess you're right that it wouldn't be hard to fake. I just thought the general tone read incredibly sincerely to me in the moment.
--- Post automerged ---

Spoiler

That's all fair enough I guess. I just believe in the town as team approach and I don't feel like town works effectively, or more importantly I work effectively, if we're all just doing our own thing.

Again, I suppose it comes down to a difference in preference in how to play the game.
--- Post automerged ---

Then you'd be wrong, but alright. I tend to take my time before strongly scumreading anyone, especially with new players.

Otherwise thanks for addressing the other stuff. Makes sense.
--- Post automerged ---

Now I'm scared.

 

@M Plus 7

 

Dammit, how do I keep missing these? XD Sorry about that.

Hmmm, good question. I guess confidence seems more towny to me and arrogance seems more scummy, all else being equal of course.

Like... the difference might just be with respect to the lack or presence of a smug or similar tone. Arrogance is just confidence with a dash of smug. Gemma conducts herself rather confidently, for example, so maybe that's causing me to read her tone more generously than I should.
--- Post automerged ---
Oh, you know what, I think it's because the thread just took me to my most recent post and yours was directly before that, and I just went down from there. I'll have to watch out for that. My bad.
--- Post automerged ---

Alright.

Vote: Citrus

Now I need to figure out why I think this.
--- Post automerged ---

So I'm curious: do you avoid tone-based reads in general or...?
--- Post automerged ---

Feel better soon!!
--- Post automerged ---

Tell me more.
--- Post automerged ---

I'm getting there.

 

Somewhat tangentially, what are your thoughts on Tsaiah's dozen or so posts?

 

You could be right, but I prefer not to read into anything like that.

 

Sorry for obsessing over this but I think it's an interesting comment and worth pursuing; where do you see smug, specifically, in Eido's posts?

 

I really need to look at her again.

I actually am at a computer, but not for long. The plan is to super quickly dive into ISOs of fonti, Citrus, and tsaiah.
--- Post automerged ---

No worries.

I mean all of these comments respectfully by the way. Eido seems like a super cool person. I don't think he's a jerk or anything.

Spoiler

Smug level: 2

Spoiler

Smug level: 7

Spoiler

Smug level: 1

Spoiler

I guess this one is the opposite of smug. Lol.

Spoiler

Smug level: 3

On a scale of 1-10. Everything else has literally no smug.

Maybe I'm totally misreading his tone. That's what I got though.
--- Post automerged ---
Oh, and there was another post where he admits he has a bit of an ego, but that seems too self-aware to be smug. XD
--- Post automerged ---
I need to look at fen too and try to quantify how I'm feeling there.

Ahhhhh too many players not enough time

 

I would go Tsaiah > fenwicked > Citrus > fonti from a length and imminent relevance standpoint.

 

Thoughts on tsaiah:

Spoiler

This looks very slightly more townie to me than not. Super gut. I just see genuine gears turning here or something.

Spoiler

I'm torn on this one. Could be genuine, could be buddying. It might have been more ideal if she had cited at least a specific example or something.

Spoiler

This is also sort of vague, which is uninspiring, but otherwise seems genuine to me. I really need to hear more though.

Spoiler

Again, lack of specifics is not ideal. That said, I sort of like the bolded/underlined sentiment because it mildly displays a perspective in which tsaiah is honestly trying to sort me.

Spoiler

I cannot sort this bolded/underlined sentiment without falling in love with it, so null.

I'm not a fan of the red colored stuff though. I've seen scum say stuff like this before. The lack of specifics is most troubling here.

Overall it's a tough determination to make. I can see why she'd be in the POE. I suppose I'd say... after this review, my gut leans very slightly town; my brain leans null or very slightly scum.

 

You might want to delay on fen. The slot isn't being lynched until it gets replaced.

 

Right, my read is basically in what he hasn't done. His ISO is meme responses to people. He's showing up enough to post those things and that's it. People somehow seem content with that and I don't get it.

Well, letting the vote hang out there didn't seem to do anything. I saw one comment about Kai being potential lynch bait at some point and another more generally from Beru about many of the votes in the game being naked or otherwise unexplained. By giving a reason I wanted to draw attention to him. I don't really see a difference in goal between the route I took and "trying to generate discussion", which I appear to have done anyway as a side effect.