Discussion in 'Award Winners 2007' started by Lord Ravenclaw, Feb 4, 2007.
Yeah, but Noir or not, Malignat Objects sucks.
Nice work Amerision, definitely deserved it. TFTCD was suprising as it doesn't seem very 'noir' to me either.
i voted for stranger in a holy land. i thought that story was pretty damn bleak for the whole majority of it. though i enjoyed the happy ending, there were times i was so confused whether voldemort or harry would prevail in the end.
Good job Amerision, and great story, very noir-ish lol.
The second and third are a bit iffy to me, gore is great but doesn't always cut it for me and TFTCD just doesn't seem like a noir at all...
I also agree with Darius: Song of the Trees should have gotten second/first; I can't decide whether Equal and Opposite or Song of the Trees was better.
Separate names with a comma.