If Ser Piggy can kill, that means there have been two mislynches. Which means that Fen is innocent. So if Ser Piggy can kill, he should kill the one person he knows is innocent?

Either you are scum making a fairly stupid play, or you misunderstood the role of Ser Piggy. Given how much said role has been discussed in the past ouple of pages, I'm leaning towards the former.

 

Let's look at possible scenarios.

We lynch Fen and he lives. He's either the Liar, the White Walker or the Onion Knight. If Ser Piggy gets a kill, we could tell that Fen was innocent by the extra kill. However, the lack of an extra kill is not proof that Fen is guilty, as the scum could have skipped the NightKill in order to show only one kill (Ser Piggy's) and paint Fen as guilty, something that would require Ser Piggy to reveal to disprove (and that would be bad).

We lynch Fen and he dies. In this case, he was the First Ranger, which would make lynching him a stupid move on our part.

So, yeah. I'm not seeing the argument for lynching him. If we trust Kai enough to reveal the results, we could ranger check him again, but then again we have the issue of only Kai knowing the real check result and the rest of us taking it on faith - which is something people already are uncomfortable with for the previous night's check.

 

Ranger Vote: Anya

Ranger Vote: Krogan

I concur, it doesn't really seem to make much sense to lynch Fen at this point.

 

That was totally stupid. I wasn't thinking straight.

Now I'll think about it again and post then.

Sorry.

 

Ranger Vote: Krogan

Ranger Vote: Anya

So lynching Fen isn't really good, and neither is lynching Sacrifice :/ What about the people who perpetuated Fens failed bandwagon? If he's town, they had no reason to really do it, if he's scum they could be his buddies.

 

If I could lynch the person that I am most suspicious of, it would be Gambit. Just look at his posts. Just blatantly scummy.

Hmm, can't hurt to see if anyone else agrees....

Deadline vote: Gambit

 

Ranger Vote:Eternity Lost
Ranger Vote: Anya

So Aekiel died tonight and yesterday he stated that it would be likely that scum would kill Sacrifice if he was targeting somebody who was not in their faction. Well maybe he was wrong, but what if he was right? Sacrifice wanted to go for Vesvius. So maybe he was on the right trail.

Other possibility could be of course that they saw Fen surviving and not knowing if he was the WW decided to not yet kill a role that can off him if he really is tWW.

Or you know, Sacrifice didn't die, because he is the scum team who had a kill yesterday.

It would make sense killing Angry Knight knowing he is not targeting you, because you can't know if maybe later in the game he would change his mind.

 

Well, since WW has yet to steal my votes,

Ranger Vote: Krogan

Ranger Vote: Anya

 

Really kind of out of it today. Can't think of anything of worth to post. I'll just throw my ranger votes on the wagon.

Ranger Vote: Krogan

Ranger Vote: Anya

Will weigh in with witty and insightful commentary* when I don't feel like shit.

*Commentary will not be witty or insightful. In fact, it will probably be completly wrong and be a source of great amusement to observers and shame to me in the post game.

 

Ranger Vote: Krogan
Ranger Vote: Anya

 

Well, unless SerP has his power activate today (which would mean that Fen is innocent), Fenraellis should be the default kill target for all roles that can do so (in the event they need to activate).

 

Sob, no Ranger love.

Ranger Vote: Krogan
Ranger Vote: Anya

Because I'm too lazy to go back and check - how much longer do we have in this phase?

 

48 hours from the start of day, which means we have about 20 hours? I think.

 

More than half the day is over, we really must decide on something. If lynching either me or Fen is a no go, we have to go for someone else.

 

This day phase lasts for a maximum of 48 hours for us to determine a lynch target and rangers to go ranging. We have about 20 hours left I believe. I don't really have any good ideas on who to lynch right now, Gambit is looking suspicious for reasons that have already been stated but not enough to warrant a lynch vote just yet. I'm going to throw in my ranger vote now as I will be going to sleep soon. I'll check back on the thread in the morning, reread the thread a bit, and see if I can come up with any good ideas then.

Vote Ranger: Anya

Vote Ranger: Eternity Lost

 

Since Kens seems to want it...

Ranger vote: Kensington

Also, I dunno about you guys, but Gambit is very suspicious to me, and I already cast my vote. I don't really feel comfortable lynching Sacrifice or Fen.