I know, but as long as he's alive there's no one who can say "No you aren't the rebel, I'm the rebel." So it's the obvious thing for a desperate scum to try and claim. It does mean that we'll find out pretty soon if he's telling the truth, as he's the only person who really can be lynched now.

 

Well I've been out at a wedding, so that's why I was not on, but I think the Ollie vote is way too easy, and usually I might be saying that we need a lynch first day bla bla, but if this is the lynch, I'm not going to join in.

Nae'blis last post seems really weird to me. If you don't think he is, and you're doing it strictly for a lynch it just seems like you don't want to help the town. and the sorry, I dunno, it feels like you are trying to cover your bases for later. Like if he dies and people look at who voted for Ollie, you could be like "Oh, well I didn't actually want to vote for him!"

 

Pretty sure we have like, 6 minutes for one more vote.

The information is worth it, folks.

 

Well, that's the whole point. I'm not going to sit here and say "Ok, lets not vote until someone dies and we know their identity".

I know I've only played one game before, but I think most here would agree that a day 1 lynch is usually random, until someone slips up. Ollie might not be scum for all we know, but Eidolonic made some pretty good points, and for day one, that's good enough for me.

 

/me stares at Lochness.

Well, I guess we know who to look at tomorrow.

 

Unless serious WINE (or a bit of retardness) is involved, I doubt Gambit is scum. Roleplaying has led to lynches in the past and his scumbuddies woudn't have let him start a lynchwagon, considering his reputation. His vote could be used to somewhat clear his lynch-target in a scum-ploy, but I was that lynch-target and I know that's not the case.

Eido jumping on him so fast is a tad scummy. Also, he seriously seems to believe that scum lynching one of their own on day 1 (even as derpy as that one is) is a possible thing and a plan he would use, which could easly be what he's doing right now.

Vote Player: Eidolonic

There's little time, I know, but I seriously doubt Gambit is scum.

---------- Post automerged at 01:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:46 PM ----------

Rescind vote

Vote Player: Gambit

Are we seriously this out of time? Fuck.

 

Stojil's initial vote for Eidolonic counts, but his rescinding was literally a second after the deadline. Ergo, we have no lynch. The official post signalling the start of the Night is coming. Please refrain from posting.

Ash: 1
Schrodinger
Vira: 1
Ash
Gambit: 8
Riley Poole, Vira, Eidolonic, Aekiel, Republic21, Bill Door, Taure, Nae'blis
Eidolonic: 2
Gambit, Uncle Stojil
9 votes needed to send a denizen to the Echo Firing Range
Yet to vote: Custer, hgf, Jeram, LochNess

---------- Post automerged 30-04-2012 at 12:08 AM ---------- Previous post was 29-04-2012 at 11:49 PM ----------

nb: Please remember that in this format (constant Days/Night, role-reveal on death), there is a Twilight phase. Basically, if you reach a consensus before the Night begins, the Day will end and your lynchpin will die. The victim's role will be revealed, and you will be allowed to discuss the results until Night falls.

Next time, it may be wise to take advantage of the Twilight.


Day 1 has concluded.

The dark sun sets over the cold snap of Hoth....
​

We have not reached consensus. Consequently, the Echo Base has chosen to send nobody to the Shooting Range. Uneasy murmurs fill the Rebel Base, while the regal Mon Mothma expresses her apprehension with the current predication. The snow around the encampment thickens...


Posting in this thread is prohibited until 11:59PM EST (Australia) on 30 April 2012

Players with night actions need to bold their actions when addressing them to me in the QT. Failure to use the correct format as specified in your QTs will simply result in recording a non-action by me in the player log. I will return a response to Night Actions which have been submitted correctly.



Only the following (17) individuals have permission to post in this thread:

Aekiel, Ash, Bill Door, Custer, Eidolonic, Gambit, hgf, Jeram, LochNess, Merrill II (Original Creator), Nae'blis, Republic21, Riley Poole, Schrodinger, Taure, Uncle Stojil, Vira, and Zeitgeist (Host).

Graveyard: None


Night 1 has started.

 

This is a filler post.Don't look at it.Look below for Night 1 Shenanigans.

 

Night 1 has concluded.

Some of us did not survive the night...
​

Last night, a hooded figure with a DD-6 blaster pistol broke into the quarters of Riley Poole, killing the victim. When the gathering Rebels take a closer look at the body, a terrifying shock electrifies the chilled, morning air: Riley Poole is a sun-tanned boy with sandy, blonde hair... with an odd, metallic device in his drawers. A lightsaber, which could only mean... a Jedi Knight.


Day 2 has started.

Posting is now permitted in this thread until 11:50PM EST (Australia) on May 1, 2012.


Only the following (16) individuals have permission to post in this thread:

Aekiel, Ash, Bill Door, Custer, Eidolonic, Gambit, hgf, Jeram, LochNess, Merrill II (Original Creator), Nae'blis, Republic21, Schrodinger, Taure, Uncle Stojil, Vira, and Zeitgeist (Host).

Graveyard: Riley Poole (Jedi Knight)

 

I'm pretty sure the scum randomly chose him. I looked back at the posts Riley wrote and he made no impression whatsoever. So this seems like a lucky shot.

 

Yeah, he'd only made two posts, and I can't see anything to suggest his role. So they must have just been going for someone they thought wouldn't be protected. It's a bad start for us.

 

Alright, first thing first, sorry about yesterday. I derped. I thought we had some time, still. We now don't have any info at all but from the night kill, which sucks both as news and as info since looking at Riley's posts there's nothing to go on, except for a mistrust of Custer which could be WINE'd up from every direction and a vote on Gambit which isn't much better.

I'm going to wait for Eido's answer to my last (damn) post for now, but my suspicions are on him at the moment.

 

Well sorry if people are not happy that I let the day go by with a no lynch, I just honestly really feel that Ollie is not scum, and that killing off a townie for the voting patterns isn't a good idea. I know that I probably look very suspicious now as pointed out already, but I didn't want to vote for someone who I believe to be town.

Anyways, I agree that the Riley Poole kill was just a random, someone that the scum haven't interacted with.

 

In a game with the reveal on death, lynching is important not only because you can kill scum with it but also because you gain great, immediate info. Without, we're practically where we were yesterday only with a townie less. It's as if our game started on day 2, pretty much.

 

Well, on the bright side, of all the non-vanilla roles, the Knight is one of the least important, at least in my opinion.

So, it could be worse.

Sorry I didn't wake up in time to help lynch someone. Anyway, I still do not think Ollie is scum, and I really don't want us to get hung up on him.

 

Me neither, if it wasn't clear already. Clinching his last-minute lynch, yes. Leading a lynch on him from the start of the new day, no.

 

Maybe it's a silly understanding in my mind but the way I see it is, if people actually think Ollie is town, then wouldn't it be better for him to be alive? I am thinking he really is a vanilla townie, and we already see who voted for who, so we already have the vote pattern started even though the lynch didn't go through. What would be such a big difference if Ollie was lynched and found out to be a vanilla townie and then we saw the voting? Sorry I am no trying to get hung up on Ollie, just I am trying to understand.


If Ollie turns out to be scum, I am going to look like the biggest idiot ever.

Anyway just gotta work for a bit will post back with scum reads in a bit.

 

...

You sound a bit too sure of Ollie's towniness, LochNess, which is making me second-guess myself. And I don't know if him not being around after what happened on day 1 is a good sign or not.

 

What happens is that we can eliminate one possible person who can potentially be scum. Maybe Ollie is a vanilla townie, but can you be absolutely sure until the role-reveal? Of course you can't.

Anyway, sucks that the Jedi Knight had to die on the first day. I'm off to sleep. Hopefully, others will post by the time I wake up.

 

For some reason I'm getting a bit of a scummy vibe from Stojil. Between the first night lynch error (possibly deliberate?) and the rather eager pointing of fingers at Lochness, my spidy senses are tingling.