It's contraindication to no one else talking. Look at your posts today, Ash. You know that playing actually opposes boredom, usually?

 

Town (for me):

Stojil: He was the first to vote for Lochness, our first mafia lynch. And we already had been considering him town from before.

Sesc: He was really suspicious of me. If he were scum, he along with his buddies could have easily pushed for my lynch and since, there was some suspicion against me already, town too would have joined that wagon and mafia would have won. So, I am almost certain that he is Town.

Ash: I don’t think she is scum because, she did show her suspicion on Lochness, even before there was that series of votes on Lochness. And there never was any suspicious connection between her and Lochness or Whooves(whom I consider scum). So, she is off the hook for me.

Fontisian: I did thought her as scum on start of previous day but her posts that day and later on does more than to convince me otherwise.

Scums:

Castiel and Whooves.

Let’s start from Lochness’ post( #180) on previous day. She was under immense pressure and she makes a huge post, but at the end shows suspicion on Castiel. Castiel, who has been very silent throughout the game, suddenly, is hyper active. He exchanges couple of posts with Stojil, and what we see in the end is him and Whooves, both desperately appealing others to remove vote against Lochness.

Lochness’ suspicion against Castiel, was clearly planned to divert attention from herself. Castiel at that moment was the best placed scum (he seemed the least suspicious). This is where I really got suspicious of Castiel, and it was the first time in the game too. But it didn’t really work and in the end, he and Whooves voted against me. Though, no one really came in to that trap.

I think lynching Whooves would be the best, since he already has a vote against him.

Lynch : Doctor Whooves

---------- Post automerged at 04:12 ---------- Previous post was at 04:06 ----------

I stated the last post, couple of hours ago and got distracted. That's why didn't see Sesc's post. Though, it doesn't affect my viewpoints any how, so meh.

But Whooves now has 3 votes and require only 1 more for hard lynch.

 

Guys, something came up and I couldn't be and won't be around much (if at all) in the coming days. I don't have time to try out the plan I had in mind and, also, I don't know if I'll have another chance to later on share the info I have, so here it is:

I'm the Joker, the town Schizophrenic. Every night I can target a player and randomly get one of four results: a check, a kill, a roleblock or nothing. Night 1 I targeted Rapscallion and he checked town. Night 2 I targeted Kens and I killed him. Night 3 I targeted Doctor Whooves and he checked town.

That's why, today, I've continued to poke Whooves without actually voting, despite all signs pointing to that up to yesterday. Now, there's the Godfather role to keep in mind, the scum that checks town. He could easily be that (I think Rapscallion can't, considering his opposition to LochNess), but I also think it's safer to go for another target.

Lynch: Castiel

for reasons that I already stated in the past (although some of them were links to Whooves). I'm very tempted to go after Ash/fontisian, but I think my vote would be wasted there, anyway, since they apparently have gained town-reads from the majority of you, and I will probably be unable to check again and change my vote accordingly. So, good luck with the game.

@Sesc: I disagree. There are many players, posts and situations to discuss. The fact Ash (and most of you) aren't doing that shouldn't be my and Whooves' discussion's fault. At all.

@Eido: if you want and can replace me, be my guest. I honestly don't know when I'll be back reliably. Sorry.

 

Mod Note: Kalas will be replacing Uncle Stojil effective immediately.


Votals
Doctor Whooves (3): Fontisian, Sesc, Rapscallion
Castiel (1): Kalas

Abstaining (3) Ash, Castiel, Doctor Whooves

With 7 alive, it is 4 to hard lynch and 3 to soft lynch.

Day Four Ends in 19.5 Hours.

 

Hey guys. I'm fairly busy till days end, but Eid was kinda out of options. Going to be spending what time I can going over the thread with the available information and hopefully get a few quality posts out.

 

Assuming what Stojil said up there is true, Whooves is indeed town. (as I suspected all the game I might add) There are currently 3 votes on Whooves, with 7 people alive scum can hammer the vote any time. (unless both of them are already voting for him right now) Either way, one of you should remove your votes just to be safe.

I am still not sure what to make of Stojil's RR. I expect town to have 3 power roles (going by the last Mini mafia game). Two are known and dead. Because of no night-kill last night I expected the last role to have blocked the kill. Stojil's RR tells us he did not do that.

So either scum did not kill last night intentionally, or Stojil is lying. But if he is lying why would he town-firm the guy who he has been after the entire game?

Like I said before, I don't know what the fuck is true anymore.

 

Wow, wtf.

Well, when I read Stojil's post, I seriously went wtf. Then, I went hurrying to rescind vote but wait - why hasn't scum already came in and hammered in on Whooves? Or either of Fontisian and Sesc is scum? Or is Stojil lying (that would just be ?

I will have to probably go and read the game once again, with this new context.

And just to be cautious:

Rescind Vote

And also, it would be interesting what others have to think about this.

 

So Stojil was town? Aw, fuck.

Since he's already said it: I'm Clayface, vanilla town. No powers, just the ability to be incredibly stupid and spend half of my posts arguing with another town member.

 

Rescind vote
I'm inclined to believe Stojil, but I also think that there's a good chance that Whooves is a scum role that checks town. My thoughts on Castiel 's scuminess were partly due to his connection with Whooves. Whooves' role reveal as a vanilla town means nothing, as scum players were probably given fake alias to claim, but not fake roles. So, if Castiel flips scum, I still want to lynch Whooves.

However, the assumption that Whooves is scum or both Sesc and I are scum doesn't make sense at this point because we are no longer at MYLO. We can afford to mislynch once, so I doubt that a mafia will want to hammer the lynch now.

Castiel: This game and last game aren't really comparable for role ratios, because the main mafia team didn't have any real roles last game besides the godfather who checked innocent. This game we know that they at least have a rolecop. I suspect that you realized that and are just doubt casting.

I'm not as sure that Castiel is scum as I was about Whooves before Stojil's RR, but with Whooves out of the picture for now, he's our best target.

Lynch: Castiel

Kalas: Who are you thinking of targeting tonight?

 

There weren't enough posts to read and gain any information from.

I looked back, and I think Castiel is the most scummy.

So, not much to say. And I am off to sleep.

Lynch : Castiel

 

Maths:

4 man scum team
3 scum, 4 town, 4 to hard lynch
Dog pile first target 3 scum, 3 town
NK 3 scum, 2 town, scum win

Potential problems: Judge mechanic/ even-night town kill

Judge could give them pause but I find the role.. unlikely(?) in this setup. Given they had 5 hours from when Stojil RR'd where the second Night 2 kill came from to Rapscallion Rescinding I'm more inclined to say they were unable to bandwagon rather then unwilling.

So assumption being now scum team of 3.

???, Lochness, ???

Looking at the wagons:

LochNess (5): Uncle Stojil, Rapscallion, Sesc, Fontisian, Ash
Rapscallion (2): Castiel, Doctor Whooves
Abstaining (1) LochNess

Given the first 3 posts after Stojil's original case against Lochness (post 168) I'm feeling significantly better about a town!Rapscallion and a scum!Castiel.

Scum team: Castiel, Lochness, ???

Third scum candidate, in order of likelihood to me at the moment: Ash, Sesc, Godfather!Whooves

fonitisian: Ash most likely check target. Also what post was your RR thing? I'm having trouble tracking it down.

 

Kalas: I suggested a role-reveal plan in post 176, but since we lynched scum yesterday, I no longer think it's a good idea. Could you elaborate a bit more on your logic? It's hard to follow.

 

I don't think Kalas is scum. If Stojil was town, then Kalas must be too.

Although Stojil's timing for his post was odd, I think he just wanted to gain info on the people who bandwagoned on me, and only stepped in before the lynch votes passed the point of no return. After all, I had three votes on me - enough for a soft lynch - and according to him, he wouldn't have been able to post before the day's end anyway. If he hadn't told everyone then, I'd have been lynched.

About Kalas' maths: he's basically saying that a four man scum team is unlikely (or at least a definite loss for town), and so giving his ideas on a three man scum team.

---------- Post automerged at 22:21 ---------- Previous post was at 22:20 ----------

EDIT: When I say 'Kalas must be too', I mean that he must be town too. Sorry.

 

Day Four Ends!


The forums are being annoying.

Pretend there is flavor here.

Why so serious?


Castiel has been lynched!


Castiel was Robin.

He was a Mafia Goon.


Votals!

Castiel (3): Kalas, Fontisian, Rapscallion
Kalas (1): Sesc

Abstaining (3) Ash, Castiel, Doctor Whooves

With 7 alive, it is 4 to hard lynch, and 3 to soft lynch.


Day Five will begin in roughly 24 hours! (Hurricane permitting)​

Mod Note - Day Five start may be delayed a while because of the hurricane that will be hitting me and potentially a couple players. Thanks for your patience - I will mass PM the living players in the game when I start Day Five. Do try to get any night actions in in the next 23 hours, though.

 

Please sir, may I have a filler?

 

Day Five Begins!


The sun rises in Gotham, as the fifth day of the villains quest to eradicate the Bat begins.

Overjoyed at the development of the day prior, they meet up and realize that... none of their number is missing.

Again.

How curious.


No one has died in the night!



Livelist!

Ash
Doctor Whooves
Fontisian
Kalas
Rapscallion
Sesc


With 6 alive, it is 4 to hard lynch, and 3 to soft lynch.


Day Five Ends in 72 Hours!​

 

Suuuup Sesc?