Caesar: Is there a reason your readwall is less detailed than usual? Could you go into more detail on your scum reads? (I realize this is extraodinarly hypocritical.)

I had actually forgetten that, probably because I've tried to repress all memory of Mini Mafia 1. Guess it's time for a re-read. Fake Edit: So painful.

What are your scumreads (other than Proph)?

---------- Post automerged at 05:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:12 PM ----------

Forgot about this:

Because that is the kind of thing Kalas tends to post as town? I'm not really sure how to explain it. I just would have expected scum!Kalas to jump on Sesc's post and attempt to lynch Aekiel, rather than pointing out Aekiel's problem post.

 

Scm: Aek for his logic and posts.

People I'm not happy with: basically anyone with under 10 posts in this game.

Sesc, don't want to say meta but I know how generally bored he is on Day 1. Content tomorrow will be telling.

Fishy, is he even playing? The meatiest posts are slim pickings, the rest are worthless. Proph connection is the best thing he's caused all game.

Bill, I actually have less of a problem with. Contents content. Even if only spread over six posts >.>

WN, not horrible. blab pressure was good. But then earthquakes and shit.

Lochness, Fishy the second with more mechanics discussion. Just all kinds of bad.

People that make me want to tear my hair out: Rents. I'm not going to speculate on replacement reasons but his replacement needs to be grilled. Thoroughly.

---------- Post automerged at 09:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:39 PM ----------

Hmmm. May have stumbled on something here. fonti do me a favor? Compare my/Lochness'/Fishy's content before/after my post 98? I need a second opionion.

 

Kalas: I'm not sure what you're asking. Do you want me to compare Fishy and Lochness's content before post 98 to their content after post 98?

 

Compare mine Fishy's and Lochness' content levels (and post numbers I suppose) before and after. Relatively/number of useless posts vs decent posts/whatever measuring stick you want to use.

 

I would like to ask anyone who is attacking Fishy Justice to read his other games. He's surprisingly good at being /very/ scummy while town.

---------- Post automerged at 06:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:17 PM ----------

You mean just try to sheep Sesc?

The statement feels rather passive to me.

(also, do we want to look for a replacement for Rents?)

 

Proph,

1: Thats irrelevant to Aekiel's interactions with him
2: Meta doesn't excuse his actions at all

 

Do interaction analysis /after/ one of them flips?

Of course it doesn't, but account for it when you're trying to read Fishy Justice. I got burned from reading him in Firefly and MM4. I'm glad he actually died early in both of those games - would hate to mislynch him in lylo.

 

Fishy prior to post 98
Post 27: RVS votes Sesc
Post 29: Defends RVS vote for Sesc
Post 73: Response to blab’s pressure with a fairly useless comment on blab’s roleclaim, a question for Aekiel and a comment on last game. Most of this post is filler.

Fishy after post 98
Post 119: Pressures Luckylee. Responds to Aekiel by calling me, blab and, to a lesser extent, Proph town. Says that Aekiel “might” be another scum read and asks him a question.
Post 125: Follow up on Luckylee that doesn’t really say anything.
Post 134: Repeats the arguments against Aekiel, votes for Aekiel and posts a vote count. Does not explain his rescind vote from Luckylee.
Post 161: Votes to extend the deadline and answers Wetnurse’s question about likely scum numbers.

LochNess prior to post 98
Post 31: Checks in, and promises to contribute later.
Post 59: Apologizes for absence, and promises to contribute later.
Post 67: Judges the veracity of blab’s claim and coaches scum on claiming. Promises to add more content later.
Post 80: Pressure on Luckylee for being vague and passive.

Lochness after post 98
…

Kalas: Now, what exactly are you seeing?

Fixed that for you.

Like I said, it's hard to explain.

For the Rents replacement, a friend of mine is interested and just joined the site. I'm not sure how long it'll take for her to get through the sorting hat stuff though.

 

Hm. It just seems weird to White Knight Fishy Injustice, he should defend himself. (Hint, hint, post more Fishy)

 

I am seeing this

And this

And these

Before 98: Minimal content from Fishy, Lochness and myself.

Conclusion: Kalas is scum.

After 98: No improvement and no content respectively, improvement on my part.

Conclusion: Scum!Kalas responding to pressure. Lochness null. Fishy? Can't read him ever. Don't even try guys.

Pressure on Fishy: Meta's not an excuse but meta guys.

fonti explaining meta!read on Kalas: meta's no excuse, Kalas is scum and your defense is bad.

Yes this is Proph again. No I am not going to let this go. What he reads and how he reads it is completely dependent on who he's posting about. What's scummy on me is null on someone else is null (leaning town) on person number 3. If that is not scum posting in nutshell then someone please enlighten me.

 

I laughed audibly.

Okay. I'm not seeing what you're seeing, though, but it's fine if it's merely something you can't explain/gut read.

Alright. I had a couple replacements in mind.

 

Proph: Could you address Kalas' post?

Everyone not on a main wagon/not voting: Vote or at the very least make a case against someone, preferably before we no lynch.

Vote Count:
Aekiel(5)- Caesar, fontisian, Fishy, Luckylee, Prophylaxis
LuckyLee(2)- LochNess, Aekiel
Kalas(1)- Rents
Blab(1)- Wetnurse
Caesar(1)- Bill Door
Wetnurse(1)- Blab
Prophylaxis(1)- Kalas
Not Voting(1)- Sesc

 

You can consider me as an honorary vote on Aekiel, but it'll leave him one short of a lynch so I'll leave it for a while.

 

Unvote, Vote Aekiel

3 hours, one vote from lynch. I doubt we'll get any other lynch and I think Aekiel is scum anyway.

@fontisian: you switched Prophylaxis and LuckyLee in your vote-count, i think.

I'll look in here later again, but I'm not feeling well today.

 

blab: Huh, could have sworn I put Proph first. Thanks.

If Aekiel flips scum, I'd like you to target Lochness, and if Aekiel flips town, I'd prefer Proph or Fishy.

Hard for me to say when I don't know what you're seeing. If you're wondering why I'm not attacking Proph though, it's because I want to see Aekiel's flip first and I'm optimistic about my chances of not dying tonight after blab's reveal.

blab's ability only kills the target if they have a different alignment than him, so I have no problem with him targeting strong players.

 

@Sesc, fontisian: Thanks, I'll wait for the flipand reread.




It would be nice to hear something from the lurkers, have Aekiel answer any of the posts around 130, have Proph answer 190, but, well, I doubt these things will still happen. I am not sure there is really anything left to say, so from my point of view feel free to hammer, I am going to have to go the pharmacy now.

 

blab, I think you should target either Proph or fonti. I think your ability is best used as a pseudo cop check.