Why is Menace not listed as in the Asylum?

 

Menace is in the asylum, Lungs fucked up.

 

Its dirty but fuck, I don't see anything against it.

 

Menace is in the asylum. If the Eidolonic is dead, an asylum kill and lynch will kill him.

 

We can't asylum kill him and lynch kill him, can we?

 

Again, its dirty but I don't see anything in the Rules that says Asylum inmates are exempt from Lynches.

 

You can asylum kill and lynch someone. I asked Lungs about that during night phase. He mentioned neither pierces protection. Honestly, I don't think betting on Eid being dead is a terrible idea considering.

---------- Post automerged at 06:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:57 PM ----------

I just want clarification that both kills will go through before he can modkill. Can we get that?

 

Asylum Kill: Menace

Deadline Lynch Vote: Menace

Now you are the Lunchening

 

Fishy: Here's the timeline Lungs gave me:

Vira's Bullet Punch Kill
!! Lynch; Asylum Decision; Jon's Command Seal
-> Klackerz's JudgeKill; Castiel Introspection
-> Mishie's protection
-> KaiBOT'ing
-> !! Irene's Asylum Commit; Everyone learns who is in the Asylum

The arrows indicate the times that Menace can get a modkill in if he is released from the asylum or asylum killed before being recommited by the Irene or the Mayor. You'll notice that all four points are after the lynch and asylum votes are processed.

Unvote
Deadline Vote Menace

I'll hold off the asylum kill for the moment, though it seems like an unneccessary procaution.

 

First, I would like to formally apologize. I have had some undesired(well, of course they are) real life circumstances arise which have tempered my game participation drastically. I feel that's rather unfair to you guys, though, and thus felt obligated to apologize. That, and I'll be avoiding the next Mafia game, if one starts in the next couple of weeks, as a result. Probably the only reason I wasn't mod-killed yet is because I at least checked in on my QT during the recent Night Phase for a moment.

-----

Anyway, that aside, I'll at least try to finish this game out, one way or another. As things are, I certainly see the benefit of so-called 'striking while the iron is hot' in regards to Menace. Well, presuming The Eidolonic is dead. A roughly one in three(one in four?) chance, I believe.

Deadline Lynch Vote: Menace
Asylum Kill Vote: Menace

 

Why not bet everything on this?

Rescind Lynch Vote

Deadline Lynch Vote: Menace

I'll hold off on the asylum vote as I'll be here.

If the Eid is still alive we're screwed.

 

I know what you're thinking, punk. You're thinking, "Does he have three layers of protection or only one?" Now to tell you the truth I forgot myself in all the excitement of Day 2. But being this is a free modkill on Jon you're giving me, a kill that will result in my getting another layer of protection on top of you guys no lynching, you've gotta ask yourself a question: "Do I feel lucky?"

Well, do ya, punk?

 

Can we wait at least a few hours to see if the KaiDASH reveals, as that plan kills Menace whether the Eidolonic is alive or not?

 

Rescind Vote.

Deadline Lynch Vote: Menace.

 

Asylum Kill: Menace

Deadline Lynch Vote: Menace

Once you were ve gone, now you will be gone.

 

A KaiDASH reveal doesn't seem to be happening.
Asylum Kill: Menace

Let's look at scenarios for tonight.

Scenario 1
Menace survives and tries to Modkill. The Eidolonic is therefore still alive.
1. Sesc should place Menace back in the asylum, as we can't be sure that the Irene is still alive.
2. The Irene should commit Stojil.
3a. If the Modkill succeeds, the Moridin (whose kill is not protection piercing) should kill off Menace's extra life. The day start message should say that Menace was targeted in the night, but lived anyway.
3b. If the Modkill fails and Stojil is incarcerated, the Moridin (if he's alive) should kill Stojil.
3c. If the Modkill fails and Stojil is not incarcerated, the Moridin should consider attacking Menace if there is any chance that the Eido would be killed between the lynch vote and the Moridin kill. If the Eido's death is unlikely, the Moridin should consider not attacking to avoid giving Menace more information.

Scenario 2
Menace is lynched.
1. Sesc should incarcerate Stojil, as we can't be sure the Irene is still alive.
2. The Irene should incarcerate Sesc (unless you guys can think of anyone besides Stojil more likely to be scum in this scenario).
3a. If Stojil is in the asylum, the Moridin should kill him.
3b. If Stojil is not in the asylum and Sesc is, the Moridin should kill Sesc.
3c. If both Stojil and Sesc are not in the asylum, the Moridin can do what he wants and Sesc is confirmed scum.
The Moridin should remember that the Vira may be able to hijack his kill.

Lynch votes:
Menace (1+6) - Jon, Rents (DLV), Font (DLV), Fen (DLV), Fishy (DLV), Vira (DLV), Azira (DLV)
Font (0+1) - Kalas (DLV)
No vote (4) - Sesc, Stojil, Caesar, Riley

With 13 alive, we need 7 votes to lynch. We absolutely need two more votes to account for Taures, and a third vote would be nice in case the Vira tries to bullet kill. Kalas, Caesar and Riley, I'm looking at you.

Asylum votes:
Kill Menace (6) - Vira, Jon, Rents, Fen, Azira, Font
No vote (5) - Fishy, Sesc, Stojil, Caesar, Riley

---------- Post automerged at 10:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:44 AM ----------

Correction:
Asylum no vote (6) - Kalas, Fishy, Sesc, Stojil, Caesar, Riley

 

asylum kill menace

deadline lynchvote menace