Deadline Vote: Ashaya

Let's not Standard Vote, at least let discussion continue.

 

Should have thought more.

It probably wasn't the Angry Knight. He would have killed Sacrifice in that case.

So either Piggy and Fen is innocent or Blacksmith's sword.

 

Well, 2 deaths. Normal NK and... what?

1) Ser Piggy - Fen and Gambit would have to be both innocent, which I find unlikely.

2) Red Priestess - The one I find most likely, as the Priestess would want an extra power asap, and this is the first night she can use it.

3) Angry Knight - Unlikely. If Gambit was the Angry Knight he would have counter claimed Sacrifice when he died or he would have ganked him.

4) Blacksmith - Unlikely. I doubt the Blacksmith would give his sword this early.

We rangers did check Ashaya, and Anya was given the Dragonglass dagger just to clear that up.

 

Red Priestess makes sense in making the kill. I missed her.
But Piggy makes as much.

If it was Piggy, he knows that Fen is innocent and so did not have to kill him.

If it was Red Priestess, then who did she kill? Sesc or Gaebe? She had to have a good read on them in this case to make the kill.

EL why is this the first night she could have used it? They converted 2 people in Day 1 so they had opportunity or I am blind because I don't see anything in rules about night 2.

 

Well the people she kills have to be Converted before she kills them, so I thought they would have had to be converted the previous night.

Looking at the night action priority again, I may be wrong.

 

It's GEABE.

There was no rape tonight, chances are, Gambit is the Rapist. So he was actually fine with dying in order for town to realise that.

Now that both Sesc and Geabe are dead, either of them could be the Rapist too.

As for how come there are two kills, I need to tell you all AGAIN, that I am the Angry Knight and it is not possible for an Angry Knight kill. (I know that for sure, you people don't because you all think I could be lying).

Well, one of them is definitely a Night Kill. The other one is either a Blacksmith kill, Ser Piggy kill, Red Priestess kill . We have no idea which is which.

1)If it was a Ser Piggy kill, both Fenraellis and Gambit are innocent.

2)If it was a Blacksmith Valyrian Steel kill, Blacksmith have chosen someone he/she trusted to give the sword to. The one who received it then decided to kill Sesc/Geabe.

3)Geabe/Sesc was murdered by Red Priestess. Why?!

Active Abilities:
-SERVANT OF THE RED GOD: During the Night Phase, you may choose to kill a Converted target. You will gain permanently gain both their Active and Passive Abilities. You may use this ability TWICE during the entire game. When you use SERVANT OF THE RED GOD a second time, the new ability set REPLACES your old one. Note that some roles cannot be Converted and thus cannot be targeted by SERVANT OF THE RED GOD. You may not use this ability on consecutive Nights. This kill cannot be prevented.

If this is the case, Red Priestess probably suspected Geabe/Sesc had an info-role, and decided to take that ability for herself.

4) Angry Knight kill. Impossible. I am the Angry Knight. Also, like a bunch of you said, I would have been killed to prove that I am scum.


Out of these four, Option THREE is the most likely. I happen to remember Krogan mentioning that Geabe "point blank told everyone he was an info-role". So either Krogan is guilty, or someone else decided to take the hint from that and ganked Geabe with Servant of the Red God. In this case, Sesc was the one that was Night-Killed.

Another problem here is, should we believe KaiDASH? Ashaya have been acting slightly scummy and all, and it would be fantastic if we actually found scum so quickly. We should not take KaiDASH's word for granted, for all we know, he could be lying.

Still,

Deadline Vote: Ashaya

I think she is scum.

Also, Moridin, I have been suspecting you ever since post #50. I am now even more suspicious that you did not even doubt KaiDASH for a little bit.

---------- Post automerged at 12:23 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:18 AM ----------

Assuming KaiDASH is not lying, I have roughly guessed why Taure did not Zombie Attack KaiDASH.

Looking at the situation at Day 2, the ones with the highest possibility of being checked is either me, or Fenraellis.

Hence, Taure did not attack KaiDASH, as Fen probably isn't the White Walker.

 

Any lie I make wrt LC info would be easily spotted by various town roles - And LC doesn't give me protection from town based kills, so regardless, it's in my best interests to be honest in this type of situation.

 

Now that I think about it, you're right. Even if you are scum you will probably not lie about LC info. Can't believe I overlooked that. I believe you on this point, but of course, not entirely convinced you are town.

Also, Moridin, I apologise for being suspicious of you via faulty logic.

 

I'm suspicious of Moridin, for entirely different reasons. One is his support for Fen in the Lord Commander elections.

Based on his survival, I think Fen's the Onion Knight with Moridin and CheddarTrek being his scum team.

I agree that scum!LC would probably not lie, but I think he would if his scum team has been targetted by the Ranger check.

Deadline Vote: Ashaya

 

Deadline Vote: Ashaya

I think Kai is telling the truth here but that doesn't make me think he is innocent.

Question, what does wrt mean?

 

Guess "With regards to"

Deadline Vote: Ashaya

Plenty of discussion to go around but voting for anyone else at this point seems silly.

---------- Post automerged at 07:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:57 PM ----------

And I'll volunteer myself to go Ranging tonight.

Ranger Vote: Aziraphale

 

I still think Fen should trueclaim btw, while there is still a good chance that (if he is fakeclaiming) the real role can cc him.

The WW should already know his role, or be at most a day or so away from it - so there is no reason for him not to claim at this point.

Fen isn't going to eat a NK (based on his role) because he is essentially vanilla from the scum's pov, so him defining which vanilla he is only helps us and is very nearly valueless for scum.

 

Sorry Ash >.<, I was hoping I was wrong.

Deadline Vote: Ashaya

When shes lynched and once he feels comfortable about claiming, I'd appreciate the Scout coming forward and confirming shes the Walker.

 

Krogan: The Walker is immune to lynches. The Scout finds out who dies during the day. Hmmmm.

Trueclaim Fen?

 

Deadline Vote: Ashaya

Also

This is canon.

 

Deadline Vote: Ashaya

Would also throw my hat into the ranger selection.

 

Ranger Vote: Nemrut

Ranger Vote: Aziraphale

 

Well, some interesting developments today. I don't really have a reason to doubt Kaidash in regards to Ashaya. This is pretty straightforward here.

Deadline Vote: Ashaya

 

My mistake, I got confused over the wording of a different ability. Have the Blacksmith fork over the sword and use it, then check.

 

I wouldn't use the sword just yet, we don't know whether Ashaya really is the Walker or if she is just another scum.

Ranger Vote: Aziraphale

Ranger Vote: Nemrut

Third Ranger?