@RileyPoole: This should be lynch can you please update vote count or confirm lynch please?

 

I never lie either

 

Why does your response have to be "Citrus is scum" if I don't like your plan? I already explained why. I don't appreciate attacking my credibility over it

 

Not even when you're scum?

 

Sloth are you cc me?

---------- Post automerged at 08:48 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:47 PM ----------

You seem scared?

 

Sloth, Snowvon...give me hard time then? I play the only way I know how to play. If I don't answer questions its because I already explained. If you think I'm town then it's working?

If you're scum and this is just distractions then:


If you're not scum then tell me post-game why I'm the worst. I love those conversations.

 

:?




invisible filler

 

Think a seer check is only a waste if the sloth is dead

---------- Post automerged at 08:55 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:54 PM ----------

Comments rubi?

 

Please stop posting at this time.


Updated vote count:

Maiden (7) – ika, Snowvon, MathBlade, Citrus, Lyrium, TerRaine, Maiden
Snowvon (2) – Sloth, Maiden, Dermon
TerRaine (1) – LochNess

Not voting (2) - Burkion, Atum, Rubicon

13 alive, 7 to lynch.


MAIDEN HAS BEEN LYNCHED. MAIDEN WAS A VILLAGER. THE TOWN MAY COMMISERATE.


NIGHT ENDS AT THIS TIME

You guys basically had a four hour twilight, so we'll let this go to night eh?

Sorry about the lateness, my friend had a mini-emergency, all good now. For those that saw it, sorry about the mistake. For those that didn't, don't wory about it.

 

You're not the worst.

It's not even just you. I'm pretty sure you have a majority townread, so giving you a hard time doesn't seem worth the effort. If you want I can send you really angry-sounding PMs late at night.

 

Like I said earlier, my latest posts have been from a phone I really only use to keep track of recent action. It makes it a little difficult to build a legitimate case, but having secured an actual computer I can now answer your question.

First off, your defines of Maiden seems to be based off of a few main factors: meta from WIFOM, B&T and last round were she seems to have been confscum; your incorrect use of statistics to determine the odds of her or Lyrium being town (already pointed out by Rubi; and the "relevant" and "beneficial to Town" questions she's supposedly been asking. You asked for examples.

#296 doesn't look useful or particularly damning, just questioning why ika's list has her as an odd colour. The argument has been made that it shows some sort of scummy self-awareness but that's pretty weak based on how blatant it was. I'd probably have asked the same.

Post #299 is one of 2 posts where Maiden asks a question that is not directly related to defending her alignment as town. It is also a mechanics question.

#423: she tunnels Snowvon a bit I guess, I'm not sure if the question constitutes tunnelling, especially when it's basically the same stuff ika was spewing when he and Snow went back and forth. Dermon gets a question too, again nothing original, lurking and a request for reads. She also doesn't give a read on me in 423, which kinda hurts.

#404 is opening up for a clarification regarding her mafia experience, a defensive one at that. #408 is the follow-up questioning why Rubi knows her first roll alignment in spite of the slips you've pointed out that at least a few people caught.

#416: tries to get ika to tell why Sloth is town. Again, not really original and to my knowledge nothing ever came of it. However, the case could be made that this one was a relevant and useful question, bringing the total so far up to 3, if you squint.

Her shout-out to Bill in #430 to me could be seen as potentially scummy, but might be an actual attempt to get his attention. Doesn't really matter with the hammer but after Riley's comment that wolves were mentorless, I think I've seen a few people attempt to determine whose actually being mentored in the name of scum hunting.

#508 is another defensive question, this time regarding a scum read from Mathblade. Relevant? Yes. Useful, arguably. Defensive? Obviously.

#614: questions a Mathblade townfirm by Rubi, not much reasoning behind it but I'll still chalk it up as useful.

And finally #618, I got a slight town read from that since it's either genuine confusion or an attempt to muddy the issue of whether ika is the seer. She also expresses a readiness for the lynching that follows.

Otherwise, I see promises for a read wall, a one-liner to ika, reasons why she wasn't on/didn't have coherent posts, etc.

Then there's the wall itself. Useful analysis, some reasoning (though there are of course portions where I disagree) and basically exactly what she promised. It's the largest reason I said I got where your town!Maiden argument was coming from.

Reasons I still said she'd be my top vote:
1) Well-established bandwagon. I've already claimed ika's my top scum read as of now. The flip should help once it happens, plus the NK provided I live and my scum reads do as well. I knew I wouldn't be active enough before the day end to get support for an ika lynch, even after the extension. So I didn't try.

2) I still don't see her contributions as a net positive over everyone else's with the exception of Snow. Same issue as above with him. You've already repeated that she's in exams and I can sympathise since I am as well, but moving forward I wash't confident her activity would increase, especially without everyone pressing for her to post.

3) The other prospects weren't all that appealing at the time. I didn't really look into Snow but reading his stuff made me lean Town. Mathblade I lean town as well. They seemed like the largest potentials for an alternative wagon so I went with Maiden.

Pretty sure that answers your question and at this point, I don't really want to put more effort into reading a dead person post-mortem so to speak.

 

I know the thread is in non posting mode but I was asked to relay a message from Sloth. He had to go to the vet for an emergency with his dog >=

 

Relay those messages via PM to the mod (Riley) in the future

 

Night 1 Ends!

The vicious werewolves attacked the village in the night.

Lyrium lies on her bed, guts torn open and savage bite marks cover her body. The Villagers spot a crystal globe lying on the floor on its side, shattered.

Lyrium was the Seer.

Day 2 dawns red.

Live List
1. Burkion
2. TerRaine
3. Sloth
4. Citrus
5. Atum
6. Maiden Dead Villager
7. Ika
8. Lyrium Dead Seer
9. Rubicon
10. MathBlade
11. Titus
12. Snowvon
13. Dermon

With 11 alive its 6 to lynch.

Day 2 ends at this time.

 

.....well fuck.

---------- Post automerged at 10:04 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:00 PM ----------

...I guess I got my wish on Burk not being seer....not sure this is a silver lining

 

"Well fuck" in response to unpleasant deaths is one of the more reliable scum tells I'm aware of.

ika: Why did you claim Seer yesterday?

 

I can't distinguish whether this was a PR hunting night kill or a strong town read night kill.

---------- Post automerged at 09:18 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:17 PM ----------

Do you want TerRaine to respond, or are you going to vote him for your "reliable scum tell"?

Because you weren't very direct on the first and you didn't vote on the second

 

The simple answer is because I think he is scum. He directed the conversation over and over again and is fake raging and is trolling the entire time. We need to lynch him. He even suspected that it would be coming this day and didn't offer any reads other than well I know if Maiden's town I'm next, super ATE.

We need to vote to lynch Ika.

VOTE IKA

 

I'm down.

Vote: ika

Citrus: I'm simply making a note.

 

To clarify any reads in the same post.