Dumbles is Dead I think. But he may come back as Harry's phoenix.

 

He'll turn a Gandolf...

 

that's it!! that's exactly what he'll do. he'll come back and go "harry, you must find the horcruxes and destroy them, destroy them before your 7th year is over or else the author would have to write another horrible book!!" maybe i'm just over exaggerating though. he probably will turn a gandolf though

 

Dumbledore the White (due to his pasty complexion)

 

*twitch*

 

XD twitchy! ... reminds me of that story Smile by.... someone i dun remember at the moment..

 

read that, she stopped updating a while back though.

 

DUmbledick's death was really pussy also. A.) he begged, but B.) Death eaters invade and the ONLY person who gets killed is ALBUS?! This is unrealistic SHIT by JK (what else is new though,eh?) I mean Bill gets some scars?

The most fair thing would have been for some students or REAL characters (NOT 3rd Tier characters who have only been mentioned ONCE) to get killed.) I mean this is a LOAD OF CRAP!!


Anyway, DUmbles is going to come back as Harry's Phoenix familiar or something stupid to show the parallel betweent the Dark and the Light (i.e. the neutral form of immortality is the PHilosopher's Stone, the Dark have Horcruxes, and, if you're good enough, people turn into PHoenixes, hence How phoenixes are created, (but never die))

 

Yeah wtf was with him crying over that crap. The guy got a "withered hand" and he wasn't crying like a lil bitch the whole story about it. The whole cup thing still bothers the hell out of me, there's no way he could of gotten the liquid out there if JKR followed the rules she set down in like the prior damned sentence. It would of been better for Dumbles to conjure a muggle device of somesort and drain it that way. And why the hell wouldn't he transifugre the water to oil and burn all the zombies in there? or cast the fire spell before hand, since Harry is too stupid to figure it out later.. despite being told exactly what to do.

And the bad thing is, even 2nd tier character's like ppl in the other houses in Harrys year, we couldn't care less about, since she gives NO BACKSTORY for 90%+ of the characters beyond a quick line or two

 

nah, I look at 2nd tier as Stan Shunpike and Hannah Abbot, and Susan Bones. 3rd tier. Know ONLY their names. Wow their deaths really hit me hard. HEy tell me about some random guy in CHina who got murdered, and watch the single tear roll down my face.


ANd why don't they LIGHT A TORCH!!! HOW about a FUCKING ZIPPO?!!

IF he was able to get the "liquid" into the cup, why doesn't he just dump it on the GROUND?! So fucking stupid. I swear to god the woman creates plot holes big enough for Midknight to drive his truck through. THESTRALS?! WHy didn't Harry see them any other year, OR on the way to the train AFTER 4th year, after Cedric DIED?! And why didn't James and Lily keep a RECORD of who the Secret Keeper was, just a slip of paper in a vault?!

I'm done. too many inconsistencies. Will make my head explode if I think about them too much.

 

Yeah it is pretty clear that it must be drunk, after all it can't be scooped up.

 

In that example, they'd be 4th tier characters that died then. So and so's mother died. Like I said in the bashing, nuke magical britian and you'd only be missing characters no one cares about, lol

Another huge hole for you to think about, and one that's currently giving me HELL to explain: . Werewolves only transform when moonlight hits them (PoA when the moon comes out from the clouds) So how the FUCK did Lupin transform in the underground tunnel/basement of the Shrieking Shack? You mean to tell me the super strong werewolf couldn't rip his way out of a rotting shack?!?!?!)

 

:brain begins to vibrate: STOP!!! :Red gooey mess of grey matter flies across the room as charlies skull pops like a massive pimple: :shock: :wink:

 

Haven't you seen the 3rd movie, I doubt this thing could rip anything.


The whole Lupin thing is weird not only the werewolf part.

 

aye I've seen it and we've bashed it enough, lol. I refuse to accept the movie version of them, which would lead us to believe the bear-like dog and the insane scary werewolf that Sirius and Lupin were supposed to be, are really animals that look like they're either A)addicted to crack, or B)on the Lohan/Olsen diet.

 

why either i say they are on crack and the diet...thats they only way two big animals can be so thin

 

Why "Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince"? such question will never be answered.