@Newcomb Did you forget this post just now when you were considering Miner perspectives on the Vaimes doing it again post?
--- Post automerged ---

Shh Fluff.

I’m solving Miner, we don’t you asking him questions.

 

My problem with miners iso is that a lot of things that are not fluff are basically just lies/wrong in my opinion .. but like in such a way where it is just obvious and I don't know what to think.

 

Gonna be mildly impressed if you posted that as a wolf

 

Example one :
Scum fluff is more aggressive and actually in the game. Prodding asking things.

At least that is the experience with the two of his scum games I have. Town fluff hates being attacked and gets demotivated (esp if reasoning is meta related).

That is just not true. I have seen it more than once that Newcomb got read somewhat scummy esp early on for different reasons and got really annoyed because he didn't get to play his game in peace.


Both of those feel just wrong, but in a way where there is no point in saying those things as scum unless he actually somewhat believes it to be true.

 

Does he usually?

 

wolfy pop-in

I'm eating and catching up.

 

Do you have much experience with Gemma?

I'm just wondering because while I agree the writing does come off stilted and deliberate, I think that's the way she writes in games. But I'm pretty sure you pointe out the ones that I had a reaction to, so I understand.

 

Is he really trying to put a stop to it, though? I mean, he's not directly egging them on, but that's a far cry with actively doing anything about it.

 

It is normal for him to spend a lot of time doing long catchup wallposts.

And he got into trouble on mu for not interacting enough in realtime before.

But this feels like a new extreme even for him.

 

Tail end of this exchange; click it and read back a bit.

Decent evidence for Cobalt/Gemma not w/w, I think. It's just too... prickly/fluid, to be partners.

 

My miney sense is tingling.

Verdict of town.

 

Vote Jarizok

 

Him doing it while not acknowledging you talking about him doing it is something.

I wanna say this was a thing in the office but he did kinda exist in the present at least sometimes that game.

 

I really like Newcomb's posting on this page (11 in 100ppp). He can be with/above Jan.
--- Post automerged ---
Oh

@Newcomb

Cobalt snap-OMGUS'ing is more likely to be town than not, but probably by not that large a margin.

(Also Cobalt, you don't have to ping and quote me; they both send notifications.)

 

Your Miney sense sux.
--- Post automerged ---

Vaimes, who’s the scums?

 

dC, I like this read, but stop doing this, it's tilting me.

 

I am less sure about him tbh.

I don't know if you are defending him knowing he is town or if you are defending a partner.

But the way you talked about his posts and the posts you picked just rubs me the wrong way.

 

Hmm.

Okay so from that last I don't want to lynch miner. And I need to go back and look at the rest.

 

wow, I definitely meant to actually put the quote in

anyways

mm

okay

I felt like there's something off about Zenzao because he hasn't gambited with his readslist, but then I realized like a couple hours ago that everyone on the playerlist has seen him do it already so there's no one left to trick with it.

Other than that he's been okay. I really don't think he tries to ride the "WHY HELLO GEMMA" pony as scum if she' town, and I have a pretty strong townread on her. Haven't really paid a lot of attention to his Jan analysis, whoops.

 

dC so blatantly weathervane-ing with Gemma playing the role of the wind is a Thing. Gun to my head, it's a town thing, specifically a dC!town thing. It's.... probably never a w/w, thing. That would be bizarre as fuck.