Oh, I'm dumb.

I forgot the scum have Daychat.

---------- Post automerged at 09:48 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:47 PM ----------

This is my thought process right now:

1. Lynch Kai.
2. ???
3. Profit

 

Ok, so obviously if there were a counter doc claim, we'd just lynch both. We have the lynches to spare.

So scum fake!claiming doc here only works as a gambit that town doesn't have a doc, AND after scum no-killed last night.

I don't think that's reasonable.

If anybody disagrees, we should talk about it.

Because this became the most important disagreement we can have right now.

 

Reasons to kill Titus n1 if I'm scum:

 

1. You get to say that right now.

---------- Post automerged at 09:52 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:51 PM ----------

2. There's no other way to fight the me/Acio/fonti townblock other than killing in a way to maximize the potential for it to crumble to paranoia.

 

See this kind of WIFOM always kind of works out in the accuser's favor.

I love Newcomb's play so far and feel very comfortable with him, but even though I think Kai might be scum I feel like "You never would have done that and that's exactly why you would have done that" is kind of weak towards Kai in this situation.

Can someone outline exactly why he's scum?

 

I guess Devil's advocate is that scum HAVE to gambit in this gamestate unless they're not in the PoE.

 

I'm not drinking the Wine, after Prime got me to do it in WH13.

 

Also, Newcomb, can you give me a reads list at this moment, in descending order from most towny to least?

 

He's not trying to solve the game.

That's pretty much it.

Meta-wise, his behavior is consistent with just a zero-effort shrug after rolling scum right after WH14 where his four-person team got absolutely routed in two Days.

 

Can someone outline the reverse?

 

Well the same thing happened here if he's scum again so I can see why he would just lol not try in that scenario.

---------- Post automerged at 12:56 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:55 AM ----------

I'm not saying he isn't, I think he's a great lynch toDay. Just some more reasons would be helpful as far as getting perspectives to try and figure out where everyone's mindset is coming from depending on how he flips.

 

Oh my god.

 

Newcomb
Acio
JasonProph
Miner
fontisian
Cobalt

demon
CitrusMal








Kai

 

Question: did eido actually put an unlimited doc that can self target into the game?

 

Basically the same thing newcomb said. His WH14 play could basically be described as "resisting any attempts for people to read him" and he's even /less/ transparent this game

Like that's the whole deal, out of all the players this game he's just, nothing.

 

We're not gonna engage in discussion involving whether or not my role has limited stocks, for the sake of town's game.

---------- Post automerged at 01:00 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:00 AM ----------

Okay. It's great that you both can just say that without really trying but could I maybe get a PBPA or something with more substance?

I'm just trying to poke at this townblock to see if any of you are just really convincing scum sitting pretty right now.

 

What exactly do you think a PBPA of Kai would reveal when the entire case is "he's literally not doing anything."

"And here, in post #454, we see Kai doing literally nothing."

......

 

Funny thing is that our job is simpler if you killed should we not hit correctly today

---------- Post automerged at 12:03 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:01 AM ----------

^^^^^^^^^^

 

I mean, I guess.

:/

Like, Newcomb is my strongest townread but I feel like Acio might be pulling one over on him??? This is just considering alternate worlds in case Kai flips town and we have to look elsewhere.

Where are we with other PR claims, it's just Fonti and I so far, right?

---------- Post automerged at 01:03 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:03 AM ----------

or ya know we could lose nobody and mechanically confirm two town in the process

but sure let's go with a dead doctor, that's useful

 

Can I veto this? Cause the gambit world result is font dies in the night and we have a bucket of wine in the morning.

Other than discussion that tinfoil, and waiting for the newbies to post a bit, I'm very comfortable lynching Kai- today.