B A C K T R A C K

I still think she is town, though, I just remembered reading some posts that were like "Sloth/Snowvon/Demonturtle" and I'm like ??? why are you lynching the newb town?

Also, why aren't we lynching Kai?

 

You really want to not have to read the game, huh?

I can respect that.

 

Ah hi people. Are we mass claiming today?

I'm also curious if Kai's vote towards me d1 was RVS or his attempt to add to the Sloth suspicion that occurred.

 

@ Newcomb Why would I kill Titus if she was the only one scumreading me? I think that would be a very stupid move to kill her.

 

Have you read D3 yet? Do you think we should mass claim? What are your opinions on everything that's happened toDay?

A) PR read
B) Shooting people who scumread you is how you avoid getting lynched the next Day
C) Sloth made that kill, not you
D) So you could say "why would I kill Titus?" later
E) Medic dodge
F) Why would anyone shoot Titus?

Pick one.

Also, same question as Miner. Are you caught up? What are your thoughts on everything that's happened, etc.

 

Well, I guess when you lay it out like that. Those are a lot of reasons.

Yeah, I caught up. I think massclaiming can help. I think Kai might be scum, he doesn't seem to really be defending himself. Fonti and Colbat both have PR's, I am kind of confused that when Fonti tracked Kai, nothing happened, but there was no night kill last night so there's that.

I actually thought someone went after Citrus last night and they found out he was really bulletproof, but mal said he wasn't really bulletproof, so there went my theory. Colbat said he protected Fonti last night, so if scum did try to kill Fonti then they would've hit a road block, so that messed up the Kai is scum theory.

Kai could have not tried to kill anyone last night to try and clear himself. Does all of that make sense?

 

I'm caught up. Personally I think that people with power roles should claim, since we have enough mislynches that we can pretty much PoE our way to victory. I mean, we have two somewhat confirmed power roles in that we have a doctor and tracker. There's probably at least one more PR out there, so this should be all relatively straightforward.

9 alive, 3 PR (at least), 1 scum, and 5 blues. Not too hard to solve the game at this point.

---------- Post automerged at 01:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:01 PM ----------

Also this entire day was strange. I'm okay with lynching Kai, but I'm curious, what are the vote totals right now? And would I hammer the day if I voted?

 

It's possible that Kai no killed on top of me protecting Fonti, and we have no way of knowing whether a night protection and a no kill would say the same thing in night results from Eido, so.

 

They would be the same, I'm pretty sure.

And yeah, No Kill + you saving fonti anyway is, uh. A hilarious coincidence? But in the face of Kai's play it's not something I can just write off as being too unlikely to be true.

 

hi do you think that's a realistic level of modgaming you're assigning to me?

 

I'm not sure what you're asking me.

 

I believe Kai is town.

I'm doing a reread and will make a decision at the end. Cool?

 

Sooooooooo massclaiming or naw?

 

Were you really? Post 781 is still accurate except for my vote which I moved to demonturtle.

Please put your vote wherever you think its the most helpful. Needing 7 to hammer means that there's no danger of that.

Then I'd like to hear your (and [MENTION]@demonturtle[/MENTION] , and [MENTION]@Prophylaxis[/MENTION] 's ) opinions on the following.

Are you comfortable clearing Kai- based on font's claim + other assumptions?

Are you comfortable clearing me based on font's claim + other assumptions?

Are you comfortable clearing Cobalt based on his claim, or at least waiting for the additional information we might have tomorrow?

After we've lynched, or all agreed not to lynch, those 3 players, who should we be looking at next? Should we start looking at them today?

---------- Post automerged at 22:55 ---------- Previous post was at 22:54 ----------

Hmm, somebody should teach me how to tag people in posts here.

 

You get a vote just like everyone else.

Definitely interested in the results of your re-read.

---------- Post automerged at 07:56 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:56 PM ----------

Just the one @ sign.

 

Like, you think no killing to dodge tracker / medic is a thing that I would do?

Me.

 

Hi Kai-, you're currently voting Cobalt.

Do you think that's a realistic level of modgaming you're assigning to him?

 

I don't really have a solid idea of how you play as scum other than a) you've touted that you're mechanically very good at it, b) you're apparently good at Angel/Demon WIFOM which means you're good at WIFOM, and c) your WH14 scumplay which matches this one exactly.

So... I guess?

Like. If you want me to consider even the slimmest possibility that you're town, arguing with me about what you would or wouldn't do as scum is not going to be a productive line of discussion.

Find me the last scum.

 

I put one @ sign. And then I saw the MENTION tags in the editor and used those too. Oops.

Uh, demonturtle Prophylaxis , see this post.

---------- Post automerged at 23:08 ---------- Previous post was at 23:03 ----------

I don't see any mechanical reason not to massclaim. But I'm not terribly experienced with closed setups, so who knows. But IIRC more than half the people who haven't claimed yet have expressed interest in a massclaim. My preferred massclaim order would be something like

Proph
Miner
Newcomb
Acio

but you could probably just go ahead.

Unless somebody else interjects to veto this.

 

I don't particularly think we're going to get anything useful out of it, but I can't see it hurting all that much either, so.