I would like to lynch demonturtle and shoot Maltrus. If the game doesn't end there, I will surrender to the people who want to lynch Kai.

 

Obnoxious thought:

Scumteam with a ninja automatically knows there is tracker/watcher in play especially if their other two are goons

It seems unlikely a scumteam looks at that and believes in there being a cop in the game too?

So does sloths day two flail fit with that viewpoint? He was obviously testing for a gambit but is "real but result is wrong" something that fits with knowing there's no cop?

---------- Post automerged at 08:32 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:25 PM ----------

FIIIIIIINE

Lynch: Demonturtle

 

I don't have time for this right now, but here's a thought: that thing Acio pointed out is pretty legit + come on Kai didn't No Kill, that's so dumb. He's handing another lynch to town and he's always in the POE even with that.

So like. As much as I hate to say it I think Kai is town? Ugh.

Buuuuut he's also super mislynch bait if so, and he's absolutely a mislynch scum needs to pull out a win here.

Can someone look over D3 and see who if anyone was kinda soft-pushing suspicion on Kai? Like in the way that Cobalt explicitly wasn't, when kept badgering Acio and I about our Kai read. That was /not/ scum pushing for a mislynch. But I kinda feel like other people might have been I just can't remember and don't have time to dig it up right now.

---------- Post automerged at 06:56 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:52 PM ----------

Honestly I think our problem right now is that there are /too many town alive/. Like holy shit there are more dead mafia this game than dead town.

Everything seems kind of plausible because nothing seems super plausible because the worlds are all kiiiiiinda open.

Also someone help me out with this small bit of paranoia I'm having over Jasonslot.

 

Ok, so the other reason we'really always lynching demon today over Kai is if there's a mafia roleblocker, it /can't/ be Kai.

So if tomorrow comes and Miner or Cobalt claims to have been roleblocked, we're always lynching in Miner/Cobalt/possible roleblockers.

We can't get this possible clear if we lynch Kai today. Ergo, we're not.

 

Right so what I'm getting is I'm shooting Citrus/Mal

 

You're not because I'm town.

You're shooting Kai.

 

Why are you so insistent on lynching me, Mal?

 

Sloth's posts make me think that there's a scum between you and Miner. And Miner will be either clearing himself tonight, or pouring a bucket of wine on the thread that we'll sort out in the morning.

We're lynching you rather than having him shoot you because if a mafia roleblocker stops the shot, it clears Kai.

 

God darn it, there is 25 hours left in the day.

I will skim the thread, do some quick interaction analysis, and try to solve the game from there.

 

The Machine is not a fan of automerge. It loses votes that way.

Current votal:

 

Vote: Mal

Best guess?

Also this might be the beer talking but what are you on about with the Kai can't be roleblocker thing?

 

Vote: Prophylaxis

Newcomb's post has me thinking that you might be scum. Yeah, it would be weird if Jason had everyone fooled, but maybe he was being coached? After he was townread, he disappeared and hadn't shown up until he was replaced. I skimmed through your most recent mafia game and you were so active in that. It might be hard getting replaced in a game, but Mal seems to be doing it fine. I don't think you're a newbie, either. You just seem to be seriously coasting and placing your vote on whoever and not explaining any of your reads/

 

Well, for one, he can't both be a ninja AND a roleblocker. Well he could, but do you think that's a likely role in this game?

Then if he didn't ninja, he nokilled.

Do you think that Kai, as the last remaining scum, both nokilled AND didn't use his roleblock?

Instead of trying to roleblock the doc and kill font.

Or roleblock font and killed somebody else.

Yeah, I'm going to say that if somebody claims a roleblock tomorrow, either that person is lying and scum and Kai is clear, or there's a roleblocker and its not Kai and Kai is clear.

 

That basically stems from the fact that I haven't had the time to really dedicate to this game, and won't have it until tomorrow.

Until then, I've just been placing my vote on random people and coasting, hoping I could scoot through while we go 3/3 on scum lynches.

 

I believe the kills were consistent with a newbie listening to Sloth's advice. If Miner's town, then it's demonturtle. Let's go.

 

Right, your suspicion of Citrus came from this post:

Well, what did people have to say about this?

Spoiler

Oh right, its almost like this is a thing that Citrus does every single game regardless of alignment

Well, what about when somebody brought that up?

A couple people had some reactions to that case

Spoiler

If you're going to shoot me tonight, please shoot me for a better reason.

---------- Post automerged at 23:27 ---------- Previous post was at 23:05 ----------

Here's my wine defense:

Spoiler

Mechanical reason to clear me:

Towniest thing that Citrus posted:

making this votal:

Towniest thing I posted:

+

Biggest spew clear from Sloth:

+ he followed that up in 470 AND 495 AND 508

Biggest spew clear from Von:

and if Newcomb , fontisian, and Acionyx think that this is in my scumrange, they must have been playing/watching a very different WH14 than the one I lost.

 

P sure the game ends with demonturtle. Let's hurry up and vote, thanks.

 

I do seriously think that lynching demonturtle will end the game. If it doesn't I currently have several things wrong but think the correct course of action would be:

Last will and testament:

If I'm the only one to die, lynch miner > proph > font

If its me and font, lynch cobalt > proph

If its me and anybody else, proph > font.

Acio is 100% lock clear.

I was tinfoiling newcomb while replacing in, but not mentioning it so that scum could solve that for me if I was wrong. Based on how today has gone down, I don't think that possibility exists anymore. 99.9% lock clear.

It would suck to lose to Kai. But I think he's actually town. 95% lock clear.

I thought that Miner was scum. But I sincerely doubt that the scumteam has his role if he proves his role. We have time to include him in the PoE otherwise.

Proph is also probably town. But he's in the PoE. Maybe his promised spurt of activity could change your minds, and you can swap his spot with Kai.

Rereading, I am finally getting that tonal town read on Cobalt. If scum shoot font tonight and he tries to make excuses though, there's room for him in the PoE.

Font should be town in a sane game. But if we really haven't won by final 4 and she's still alive, she's just scum and Sloth just did a fantastic job of distancing from her. Day1 she didn't really want Sloth to die, and she's hyper bussed Von before to great results (see CatHunt). And the gambit she would have done here + how she's treated Kai are perfectly within her range. Again, less likely than the people before her in the PoE, but definitely very possible. Please lynch the witch if it comes to that. But not before.

---------- Post automerged at 23:58 ---------- Previous post was at 23:49 ----------

Votal:

So, to hammer demonturtle, we need 4 of Newcomb , miner11121 , Cobalt , Prophylaxis , and KaiDASH to show up and switch votes. I don't have anything else I want to do toDay, either proactive or defensive, and I don't actually have any more time to really play before deadline tomorrow between work and plans.

miner, if you decide to not shoot me like you should, please shoot Kai. Or you could shoot Proph, but I feel like the thread will be able to evaluate him better once he's actually posted, while the thread's opinion of Kai seems unlikely to change.

 

I really, really, don't want to lynch demonturtle, since if she's scum it would hurt my pride as a mafia player.

But I'll do it :/

Unvote; vote: Demonturtle

 

lynch Demonturtle