Title: Skin Deep
Author: Smileyfax
Rating: T
Genre: Romance/Parody
Status: Oneshot
Library Category: Romance
Pairings: Harry/Tonks
Summary:On their wedding night, Harry asks Tonks to reveal her true face. Romance abounds!
FanFiction.Net

I just cannot express the feelings this marvelous piece of art brought to my heart in mere words. I have read this five or six times in the past couple years and the awesome quality of this fic still leaves me spellbound.

Please, On this Valentine's Day, this is the best description of 'tru' love I could find.

Just read this once. Its very short. Its lovely.

6/5 FROM ME. AWESOME.

 

This is up there on the most idiotic shit I've ever read. 1/5 would give it a lot fucking less if I could.

 

Should be categorized as parody. It made me chuckle.

3/5

 

This idea could have been much so much more effective had it been written by a competent author.

As it is - 2/5.

 

Yeah I'd give it a 2/5. Made me chuckle is the only reason it gets that.

 

5/5 if nonjon wrote it.

2/5 for the effort. I've seen much better, funnier things in our 'TGYH' threads

 

Yeah, this seems like something you'd see as an impromptu scribble on IRC. If you're going to put what amounts to a single joke in the library, it had better be absolute perfection - this isn't.

1/5

 

Well. It's better than I thought, in that it's essentially technically competent as far as a quick read revealed. The joke is barely worthy of the name though. It's the sort of gag Nonjon might have tossed in as a one-liner, spread over 600ish words. Really?

Not library worthy at all.

 

I though it was amusing. Frankly, I have read just about the entire library and I need to find more fanfiction. If you don't like one-shots you can filter them out.

4/5 on the oneshot scale.