lol. What about my content is scummy to you apart from the fact I made a case on you? Where's the analysis?

 

Fluff, I don't think eco is the best lynch for today,

 

MathBlade, please answer my question.

 

Time for some Vote Count Analysis of Day 1. I have only coloured in dead players + Font, becuase even if she's a SK then she acts as Town from the Mafia's point of view.

Vote Count 1.3
Tom (4): Fontisian, His Fluffiness, Miner, Vaimes
Vaimes (3): The Waco Kid, Cobalt, Typhon
Fontisian (3): Mallorean Thug, Mathblade, Jarizok
Miner (3): Delphine, Jan, Tom
Typhon (2): DLGN, Quiddity
Abstaining (1): Corrdorr

1.4
Tom (5): His Fluffiness, Miner, Quiddity, MathBlade, Cobalt
Typhon (4): DLGN, Mallorean Thug, Vaimes, Fontisian
Fontisian (2): Jarizok, The Waco Kid
Miner (2): Jan, Tom
Vaimes (1): Typhon
Jarizok(1): Delphine
Abstaining (1): CrimsonFox

Vote Count 1.5
Fontisian (4): Jarizok, The Waco Kid, Typhon, Cobalt
Jarizok(4): Delphine, Fontisian, Vaimes, Jan
Tom (4): His Fluffiness, Miner, Quiddity, MathBlade
Miner (2): Tom, CrimsonFox
Typhon (2): DLGN, Mallorean Thug
Abstaining (0):

Vote Count 1.6
Fontisian (5): Jarizok, The Waco Kid, Typhon, Cobalt, MathBlade
Tom (4): His Fluffiness, Miner, Quiddity, Fontisian
Jarizok(3): Delphine, Vaimes, Jan
Miner (2): Tom, CrimsonFox
Typhon (2): DLGN, Mallorean Thug
Abstaining (0):

Vote Count 1.7
Tom (6): His Fluffiness, Miner, Quiddity, Fontisian, Vaimes, Jan
Fontisian (5): Jarizok, The Waco Kid, Typhon, Cobalt, MathBlade
Miner (2): Tom, CrimsonFox
Typhon (2): DLGN, Mallorean Thug
Jarizok (1): Delphine
Abstaining (0):

Vote Count 1.8
Jarizok (7): Jarizok, CrimsonFox, Mallorean Thug, Typhon, Vaimes, Fontisian, Jan
Fontisian (4): The Waco Kid, Cobalt, MathBlade, Tom
Tom (4): His Fluffiness, Miner, Quiddity, Delphine
Typhon (1): DLGN
Abstaining (0):

Vote Count 1.9
Jarizok (9): Jarizok, CrimsonFox, Mallorean Thug, Typhon, Vaimes, Fontisian, Jan, His Fluffiness, Tom
Fontisian (4): The Waco Kid, Cobalt, MathBlade, DLGN
Tom (3): Miner, Quiddity, Delphine
Abstaining (0):

1.10
Jarizok (13): Jarizok, CrimsonFox, Typhon, Vaimes, Jan, His Fluffiness, MathBlade, Tom, Fontisian, Miner, Quiddity, Mallorean Thug, Delphine
Tom (2): Cobalt, The Waco Kid
Fontisian (1): DLGN

*******

Initial observations:

Tom is almost entirely voted for by unknowns, primarily Fluff, Miner, and Quiddity, and sometimes Math. I think the group of three absolutely HAS to contain at least one scum as Tom definitely fell into the "potential mislynch" category, scum would have been keen to push him hard.

dLGN spends almost all day hanging out on Typhon. He is the only unknown to vote Typhon (apart from Q in 1,3). Spending all Day on a wagon going nowhere is not a good look for dLGN at all.

There was a remarkable lack of unknowns voting unknowns, displaying a clear lack of bussing/distancing. In fact only Miner got any votes at all and those were from known town and confirmed scum Jan (which could be distancing).

The progression from 1.8 -> 1.9 -> 1.10 is amazing. In 1.8, Jarizok is at 6 straight townies and scum-Jan. Then in 1.9, we see Unknown-fluff and Town-Tom join the wagon. 1.10 groups Fluff and Math and Miner and Quiddity together.


I'd bet my absolute socks that Fluff/Math/Miner/Quiddity have 2 scum in them, and one of Cobalt/dLGN is the last.

I think that both Fluff AND Math is unlikely, given three scum grouped together on 1.10 seems unlikely. Miner and Quiddity are basically interchangeable since they voted almost identically. But that does mean they're unlikely to both be scum.

So combining that with earlier reads, I think I'd have to go for Fluff/Quiddity/dLGN. I want to town read Quiddity so bad, but Miner just doesn't fit the team as well.

 

So that's you admitting Math is your scummate? Cool.

 

Vote Mathblade

We who are about to die salute you.

---------- Post automerged at 05:39 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:30 PM ----------

If we assume that cobalt, fluff and myself are town and that q/dlgn and eco/miner are unaligned, math becomes confirmed mafia. Does anyone disagree with those assumptions?

 

Yes. Obviously.

---------- Post automerged at 22:42 ---------- Previous post was at 22:40 ----------

But actually, you raise a good point that dLGN and Quiddity are probably unaligned, which invalidates my scum team above. Hm.

 

I just don't know.

I have no idea. :/

---------- Post automerged at 14:57 ---------- Previous post was at 14:56 ----------

Since I am Town I do.

---------- Post automerged at 14:58 ---------- Previous post was at 14:57 ----------

...Fonti I am pulling a Titus gambit here.

You really don't want to vote me if you understand.

 

That fits with my thinking, fonti.


Eco, I disagree with the analysis of 1.8->1.10. I think given the context of what was happening it's kind of meaningless except for dLGN off wagon insistence.

---------- Post automerged at 06:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:03 PM ----------

Math, you were pushing for a fonti lynch just before, now she could be town? What changed?

This indecision feels like Math is trying to decide if they want to do a D2 Jan or not.

 

Hiya. Harvey here. VT.

---------- Post automerged at 06:07 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:06 PM ----------

fontisian What does this mean and should I vote Math for it????

---------- Post automerged at 06:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:07 PM ----------
Quiddity

Honestly a lot of what's influencing my read of Eco is meta surrounding Corrdorr.

If he drew scum or a power role in a new place like this, he would have been ALL OVER THE THREAD.

The fact that he fell off so quickly indicates to me that he was bored. Which wouldn't have happened if he was scum.

I know we aren't supposed to meta surrounding replacements, but I've only gotten good vibes from Eco's posts and when you consider the CF freakout, I think it was pointed out that it's likely it was coming from towny anger.

 

Cobalt dLGN spittake please

 

Like I know what math means.

 

Only other person that had a rational fucking response to the Jarizok wagon.

Probably not gonna lynch him.

 

Cobalt, you and fluff are on opposite sides of the miner/eco dictonomy. See if one of you can convince the other.

 

Okay less of a spittake then lol

Read my analysis of his D1?

 

You are likely choosing between him and Q. Does that affect your read?

 

I liked the last few posts from Fonti.

The problem is I know I can't be lynched or Town loses. There is an old game Fonti had with Titus. Titus got NK'd instead of the Outed PR.

 

I don't like to comment on activity, but dLGN lurking this out makes me like the him/Math world more.

 

I was trying to get Typhon to claim acolyte and saw me say Jan was guilty so I would die instead of Typhon. It just erm...When Typhon asked me if I was he got 90% of it. But also ruined the gig because he asked me if I was. I was trying to save Typhon and get another result. I was going to claim N1 results on Typhon had I needed to :/

I just didn't expect scum to see through it.

Fonti would die because the game would be over. I am a VT. Eliot. Made a few references to beaches.

---------- Post automerged at 15:27 ---------- Previous post was at 15:26 ----------

At that point I had to backpedal.

Titus has been training me on some of her gambits and how to listen more. And so I tried one and well...I am not Titus

---------- Post automerged at 15:28 ---------- Previous post was at 15:27 ----------

The last thing I have left is listening. :/ Soooo trying that.

 

Unvote
Vote Dlgn

Do something.