Read this awhile ago, and it actually made me laugh out loud, so 5/5 for that, although as others have already said, the reread wasn't as good.

 

I remember reading this a while back, and re-reading it after the tenth chapter was released.

4/5 because it made me laugh and gave me an idea for a fic of my own.

 

Well I've never read this fic before, so I gotta give it 5/5. Made me lol quite a few times and it was written pretty well.

 

This is one of the great humor classics. I could have sworn it was already in the library since people have mentioned it several times in passing, but better late then never.

 

Hilarious but some parts were annoying (mostly the H/G)
so 4.5/5

 

5/5

This is the fic that got me started reading Harry Potter fanfiction, before that I generally stayed in the Anime\Ranma 1/2 ghetto. The funniest thing is I don't think I'd ever read the actual Harry Potter BOOKS at the time I read this fic, but the humor inspired me to go hunting them down!

--bornagainpenguin

 

This fic was pretty much amusing until I finished Chapter 9. After that I couldn't find any chapter ten or so on. Anyway, I'll try nonjon's link and see if it has a copy of more than just 9 chapters.

A 4.5/5 IMHO.

 

As with pretty much everyone else i read this first along time ago, and i agree that the use of instant messaging is applied here alot better than in 'This means war'. After reading this fic i found it to be a really good laugh, not the sort of fiction i would recommend to a newbie or anything but overall a brilliant humour fic. 4/5

 

I don’t know where I was when everyone else was reading this, I’d never even heard of it till I saw this thread. I did think it was absolutely hilarious though, start through to finish.

5/5.

 

Wow, this takes me back a while, light, fluffy and a good humorous read and even the H/G didn't bother me since the character was not too infuriating. Well written and very fun.

 

Actually, on fanfiction.net somebody tried something of a sequel with bad results as far as i remember!

 

Just browsing the library... and well, Anya reposted this, in its entirety, on FFN a few months ago. http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3689325/1/The_Original_Naked_Quidditch_Match

That having been said, this was the first story I came across in HP fic, with the Paradigm of Uncertainty being after that. I laughed myself sick, and got some chuckles out of it upon successive rereadings. 5/5

 

Fairly a good fic with plenty of laughs intermixed. there is the ideal of magical emails going from person to person and the twins' crazy antics that get them into this mess.

There is the thumbs down for the H/G (for those against that pairing) but at least she was devious and not a little crying sack of Headmaster's secret projects or anything. It is sort of in the concept of the ever famous 'this means war' from how the Headmaster is kind of laid back.

It's a nice one with Ron being as protectice of 'Ginny's innocence' as a few others. Quite enjoyable. Reread it occasionaly. 5/5.

 

My opinion is the same although I am going to give it a 3.5 instead.

 

I read the "This Means War" fic a while ago, and while it was good, it had nothing on this. 5/5, hilarious!