Do you think they're together?

I disagree but I suspect that's because I'm tunneling Cuth scum.
--- Post automerged ---

Okay but like in your mafia career of X years you saw one person do it and you're no longer willing to even attempt to evaluate the relative likelihood here?

 

No, because mafia think about shit like this and there's no reason to try and WIFOM it. Before, I would have been shocked to have seen it. Now, I think mafia that do that are just trying to out-logic the town.

 

NGL I thought I'd get shaded today and was looking forward thunderdoming. Kinda disappointed that didn't happen.

 

Fable is totes a wolf.
--- Post automerged ---

Well yeah but how likely is it that Miner decides to dump wine on his reads? This isn't rhetorical, I can legitimately see a small fraction of worlds where he does it deliberately and a significant fraction of worlds where he does it but not deliberately; I just want to know how likely you think it is.

 

I think there's a slightly higher chance of not happening than yes, but I'm no longer comfortable giving it percentages or a much higher likelihood of happening.

 

Good enough, thank you.

 

Could see this being w/w.

It's a decently in-depth read, but the little things that ping me about it are that a) it doesn't really take Scott's alignment into account, just kind of like, subtly giving Vira points for the case, and b) the hedge at the end. It's not damning or anything - could imagine that hedge coming from a villager - but there's an element of like... positioning, to it?
--- Post automerged ---
@Cuthalion

Hypothetical:

We lynch you here, but give you pseudo daykill. You flip town, we 100% agree to lynch the person you tell us tomorrow.

Who ya got?
--- Post automerged ---

@Vaimes
@Jarizok

I think this exchange makes dya/fonti not w/w. This is a read that might actually end up really really mattering, so... thoughts?

I can go into why I think it but I don't want to bias you.
--- Post automerged ---

^ tail end of that exchange

 

I also remember thinking at one point that Dya's push on Fonti for "sounding like WH" was kind of weird to be w/w.

This isn't really related to the above, it just reminded me of that.

 

Yeah, I’m down with Fonti/Dya not w/w.

 

Why? What does this read hinge on for you?

 

@Fable
Do you think Cuth can be with Fonti (re: Miner's null tier of Cuth/Fonti/a flipped scum I don't remember)? Can you talk about Cuth partner possibilities in general?

 

I'm probably just going to flip a coin tomorrow tbh.

 

@Newcomb
Where are you at in terms of potential Cuth partners?

Can you actually answer the first question though?
--- Post automerged ---
@Cuthalion

Lolcats please!

 

Do we have a vote count?

 

Doin' a thing.

Spoiler

He calls Scott wolfy in his first post into the game, but... this whole post reads as a series of little digs at villagers? Like, the sort of question that is not really asking anything solid but just like "doesn't this look kinda bad to you guys?"

Spoiler

This entire post is pretty constructed and narrate-y catchup-y. Don't really like how he says "I can agree with his read on Scott", but then immediately says he doesn't get/disagrees with p much the entire read.

Spoiler

Think these posts are fairly telling for his alignment, just based on what he singles out?

1. Notes stan trying to figure zack out, lightly townreads it, asks her what.
2. Says... he hasn't been mentioned much itt and that he hasn't really paid much attention to GH, at this point while the wagon on GH was crescendoing.
3. Talks about Vira, asks why her vote is on Scott, waffles about on her.

something something rule of three

Spoiler

...wolfreads Stan for... the thing he townread her for earlier, but... because she only has him as a mild town read?

Spoiler

I don't know. I actually... vaguely like this? From a perspective of not knowing how GH normally plays, and it manages to... be more than fair to GH while still walking through it nicely i don't evensdafksslhghlj'hsl;hgl;lkfzzt
--- Post automerged ---

I believe it's still four on me and five on thin air.
--- Post automerged ---

This looks... not great in retrospect of 113 alignment?
--- Post automerged ---
Tired of weiyding through his walls. Going to take a look at fonti, briefly, sketch out my read on her w.r.t. her specific posts.
--- Post automerged ---

Spoiler

Tired of weiyding through his walls. Going to take a look at fonti, briefly, sketch out my read on her w.r.t.

The wall post is... the most reminiscent of her wolfgames I've read as far as tone goes, as far as the approach goes, but everything else (i just grabbed random quotes from early game) is a lot more... abrasive, thought not, for example, in the way that yeti was? She says "let me talk to you about it, but it's more of a "I have a very solidly defined stance, I'm going to stick to it stubbornly and get mad at you if you say it's bad", compared to the attitude in the wolf game of "let me talk to you about it" and then actually doing it and focusing a lot on... persuading people as opposed to taking stances and keeping them if at all possible. Pretty definite difference imo, but then again I haven't played with her too many times/read all of her games so I could be wrong I guess.
--- Post automerged ---
I was going to vote shadow after reading weiy posts but then i read weiy d2 and don't really feel like it bye.

 

Hi, I’ll be back tonight.

I get the feeling that neither Cuth nor shadow are wolves. What do then?

 

Suffer.

 

Cuth doing a giant wall like that freaks me the fuck out.

 

Deadline tonight right?

 

Vote: newcomb