Still working on a post about GH.

Why the vote for Newcomb?

I remember a couple other votes for him too. What is the gist of the case on him?

What do you mean by impact? What sort of impact is he lacking? I feel he's been presenting a lot of points that I agree with.

 

I'm fine with his volume it's more what he is saying in his posts. It feels soft.

 

It's not. He usually isn't completely at the bottom, though.

 

Why these two?

 

Thrice, the aster now uppercut now ballet.



I've been frankly unimpressed, and want to poke the sleeping dragon.
--- Post automerged ---

This post feels soft.

 

This juxtaposition is interesting. Right after giving a pretty lazy village circle, he immediately snaps back that he "really, really wishes this were a simple game". But that statement doesn't ring true, because as far as I can tell Vaimes exhibited very little paranoia about his read, and just threw out village reads for hardly anything like it meant nothing to him. So to then lament about how "I really, really wish this were a simple game" .... what?

 

Yeah, I saw a lot of people townreading Zack and went "hmm, maybe I need to fix my read".

I think my Zack read is scattered through the thread, but it's not gathered in one place so I'll do that. I thought his early game was kind of snappy and vaguely unhappy which is still a bit mmm. The lack of followthrough read has decayed to basically nothing. His posting was better yesterday and people who know him seem happy with light townreads on him, so that together is enough to bump him to a slender townlean.

My opinion on fonti is ???. I have no idea how to read her and I think the last time I asked, people just shrugged at me. I have vague townfeelings on her but whenever I try to read her I just level myself into oblivion.

Sometimes confusing people is informative because I get to see what they're confused about. That episode, however, was probably just dumbassery. My readlist reflects the fact that I spent the whole morning just kind of...cooling on the Zack scumread. See above.



These two posts seem pretty good. I'll look at the remainder of them in a bit.

 

Hmm, yeah I missed this. Still think Kalas' approach to it was pretty weird.

 

:thinking:

 

Vote: Vaimes

 

Thread presence doesn't mean volume.

I'm willing to give him more time.

 

Fluff’s EXTREMELY ACCURATE VOTAL

Vaimes (3): yeav, Stanari, Zack
Koalas (2): Koalas, Proph
Stanari (2): Scott, GH
GH (1): Swedish
Proph (1): Jarizok
Fonti (1): tom
Dyachei (1): Fable
Zack (1): fonti
Fable (1): dyachei
Tom (1): Newcomb
Miner (1): Revenant
Yeav (1): .113
Scott (1): Vira
.113 (1): weiyaoli
Newcomb (1): Cuth
Cuth (1): Vaimes

Abstain (3): Tsaiah, Sooh, Miner

12 to soft lynch, 18 to hard lynch

 

Oh, good. Someone else noticed it, too.

 

Your mom feels soft.

 

I would be hard-pressed to name a single post from SR.

Except that 1v1 with Cuth, I guess?

 

This wagon formation.

Dya, thoughts on Proph/Vira/Newc/Stanari?

 

Vaimes is probably just a wolf by the way.

The catchup lazy village reads stuff just feels like a wolf who doesn't want to put the effort in.
--- Post automerged ---
Exactly, nothing stands out when I think about him this game. Background noise.

 

Yep.

I wanted to stop posting so much, and give time for other people to do their thing without me interjecting all the time -- but I had the same thought reading Vaimes' posts last night.

 

Proph probably scum.

Vira I'm told acts this way as a villager but I have my doubts.

Stanari is lackluster for her.

Newcomb I'm not sure on at all.

 

Okee, am looking back at the player list and have legitimately no idea who I wanted to say. Font/Fable was correct, but there aren't any similar names beyond them?

Meh, slot in t om or something. Maybe weiy, at this point?