FUCK.

Lissa was the Priest.

 

Yes, we know.

 

Also, Nutella is a villager.

 

So I'm trying out the Newcomb Strategy (TM) and I'm not really sure if it's working but here's where I'm at:

Arapocalypse

Cobalt
Cuthalion
Fluffiness

Group of clear/practically-clear people, moving on!!!

Fontisian
Ampharos

Fontisian is probably my absolute top townread here at the moment; I have a very difficult time believing that the twists and turns of their thought process/thinking can be faked, for which it seemed like they had no idea what was going on/had no TMI in their reads whatsoever!!!! One of the more notable moments of this is their Vaimes push, which they spent all of day 1 doing and wasn't exactly getting that much pushback... so why would you transition to moving off of it like that closer to EoD? Also just felt like such an organic move off of there, even if I don't necessarily personally agree... I guess if someone could talk about how they play as mafia just in case please? Really don't think it'd be them though!!!

I may have been hard-tinfoiling Amy for a solid hour earlier, partially because of how little pressure they've had this game, but going back over their ISO, I feel like if you just read through a ton of their early day 1, there's a whole ton of genuineness which just... sort of hits you over the head in a way which would be really difficult to continue on to day 2 the way they have, granted a bit less so!! Also there was this very solid moment when they were pushing Lyric by trying to get people to read their ISO, which was !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Gira
Grapefruit

Both the people who moved onto Lyric for the initial entrance into the thread about halfway into day way; beyond that... they're still at about the same level-ish? With regards to how they felt in the overall gamestate yesterday, that is!!!!

For Grapefruit in particular, part of me wonders if they'd really just ignore the push on Waco Kid and keep going on nutella, which does give me pause hence them being a tier down... but also part of me does get that because I feel similarly as well!!

Vaimes

This is still probably my least fleshed-out read, which I get the sense that a lot of people think is obvious town!!! I do think that them chilling a bit on the Lump-pushing later on day 1 is a generally solid look, and have somewhat liked them more later on a second look; this is just not really as confident as the reads above!!!!!! I don't know if it's just me or them here, help?

Nutella

I lowkey really hate that I'm back at nutella but... trying very hard not to just townread the rest of the entire game, so I guess I'm here!!! Her posting yesterday felt generally pretty solid, just that the fact that her interactions are very not great (particularly it feeling like she went back on the Lyric read for no reason) and I'm trying not to discount that!! Just... bar of towniness stuff!!!!!!

Nutella, can you talk more about your Lyric vote and general process around it?

Another thing: I was considering whether or not the last one's a busser and given that Visor was actively forced to claim at EoD I'm strongly leaning towards no, just because of how incredibly suboptimal that play would be!!!

 

Nutella was Lissa's N1 check. She is clear.

 

Indeed... unfortunate!!!

 

Why so?

 

Wait what?

...I thought it was Waco Kid!!!!

 

This is Lissa's very first post after Night.

Nutella was her check.

 

She never really wavered on Waco Kid, and I think bringing up nutella being town was probably just a read given the not being sure about that? Particularly in the last quote here!!!!!

Like, I don't really think Lissa would FPS this?

I don't know, thoughts?

 

Besides which, there's also this!!!!!

 

She wanted Waco dead. He was not her check.

 

Hrm

 

Why was she so uncertain on nutella though, have you read her ISO?

Really don't want to get this wrong because I swear, if nutella turns out to be mafia and gets miscleared off us misreading Lissa's check...

 

Dude, I'm pretty sure Waco was scum and her check.

 

Oracle should claim if Waco was a witch, otherwise we’ll assume town.

 

If there’s one witch left we can get claims out of PoE people.

 

I didn't lol

......

......

Yeah so uh. Not liking this and obviously my earlier thing about ara is invalidated now. And in fact makes her look pretty bad.

Vote: Arapocalypse

 

She would've outed for a red check.

 

Your desperation is showing.