Is that what you think the game is??

 

(Tried to find a good gif for this and failed. Smh.)

 

Seriously shove it. I posted yesterDay why I was absent.

 

And I'm hoping that today, if you're town, you'll have the time to show it.

 

I thought you played fine that game?

Anyway it's less straight metaread and more baselining. If it was straight metaread I'd be scumreading you, which yes would be very stupid. Rather I'm trying to use it as a frame of reference.

Anyway as I was saying, you've seemed kind of lost so far this game which makes it difficult to read you, so I kind of want to put you at mostly null? I'd want to see more from you today before committing to anything. Gun to head I'd lynch a few other people before you though.

 

Yeah, of the two of us, you're the one who needs to be doing the showing
--- Post automerged ---
And you didn't answer my #1841

 

Don't really think that's true tbh. But doesn't matter.

I think you're seeing me pushing you for being busy yesterday and I can kind of see where that's coming from because really gemma and fonti were just really townie yesterday and there was fairly compelling reasons for jari and Stan being town so you kind of just limped to the edge of my poe after i was townreading you.

So anyway yeah I think asmo and DC are the scummiest but don't actively think that's the team except in the sense that I have pretty strong townreads on most of the living players so one of them being town makes me look at people like you/stan/shitmaybeitisgemma and that all seems less likely.

 

Wait that's not stupid at all, please please please metaread me because I would /really/ like to get out of this game.

Do you have reads that you do feel strongly about?

 

It's funny you characterize your reads on Fontisian and I like that. Because, simply put that's garbage. Because look at you on your 2nd post of D2, prior to Newcomb's claim. Sure looks like you were getting ready to push on me already... And you digging that Fontisian/Shadow read, nice call.

Then if you don't think Asmo & dC work as a team, maybe you should be searching for people who do?

 

Wow, respect.

 

Saying what Jan said != getting ready to push you

Not actively thinking they're the team != thinking they aren't the team

 

Yessir. Working on it.

 

Saw this when I was skimming D2. Pretty basic at first site. Except, when I go through your iso, 1) There is no explanation and 2) You posted 3 times in the final 30 minutes (see below), despite sitting on your vanity wagons, these posts following a gap of only about 40 minutes to your last post prior to these.

 

Newcomb's town :V

Uh, other than that I'm actually pretty sure Waco is town based on how D1 went down and how he's come out swinging on tom

Beyond that, Cobalt is probably fine? Toneread? lol? :v. That leaves you/Vaimes/tom/Asmodeus, and I'm suddenly wining myself out over whether part of the font kill was "she's pushing on Asmodeus" or "people will lynch Asmodeus for her". I'm vaguely concerned by Vaimes's activity level cratering in recent times, tom is weirding me out today in the sense that he seems to be looking for excuses to maintain exactly his current thinking (which if Asmodeus IS in fact town is Very Bad), and you've been...I wanna say unmemorable? Like, what are your stances at the moment?

So I think there's probably exactly one in asmo/tom, and if the last one is actually alive then bugger if I know.
--- Post automerged ---
preview edit:

D1: tom not enthusiastic with shruglynches
D3: tom pushes the two shruggiest lynches of all and aggressively avoids considering anything else

 

Yes I did explain why I thought DC was scum. Thought I said i was at work too but idr. I posted a few times anyway.

What is your point? Do you find my eod scummy?
--- Post automerged ---

We are 5 hours into day 3, nothing has changed.

Not that it necessarily will change, nor would it be scummy if it didn't.
But aorn literally why would anything have?
--- Post automerged ---
Think both DC and waco are reachy as shit to push me right now.
But at the same time I've been expecting someone to

 

Yes, in isolation I might buy that argument. On the other hand, I can watch as you slowly downgrade your view of me as a possible partner for shadow as the day goes.

--- Post automerged ---

Ah see, there you go, let that out. You've been dying to do that haven't you?

 

Think both DC and waco are reachy as shit to push me right now.
But at the same time I've been expecting

So your issue with my read of you is that it progressed steadily?

I wouldn't say dying but yes I expected anyone pushing on me to do better than this I'm sure I've done something actually scummy by now.

 

@Newcomb as requested.

Spoiler alert be ready because this reads list contains something ~SPICY~

I'm including dead people here because lolnoflipsthisisahunt for the sake of worldbuilding

Cobalt
[ Jan / Font ]
Newcomb
[ Jarizok ]
Tom
Gemma
Stanari
dC
Waco
Vaimes
Asmodeus
[ Shadowlancer ]

Jan - DoB

Fonti - NK

Newcomb - has not been counterclaimed and could be counterclaimed with real priest still in safety by the acolyte, vig did not shoot after a red check was lynched, even if this were some sick world where Jarizok and Stanari were exactly the priest and acolyte there would've been a vig kill N2 if Newcomb were lying. Hard priest.

Jarizok - Was pushed as an easy consensus lynch and I don't believe he was a witch there. I'm usually super wary null or scumreading him but I found him null with no concerns so I'm pretty sure that was just an easy D1 mislynch.

Tom - Probably the most pure tonally other than (initially) Vaimes. His campaign for lump was LEGIT, and I don't think scum!Tom pulls it in the way he did. That and he's universally townread which as I understand is difficult for him to pull off as scum? Either way, I'm just leaving him there because feels.

Gemma - I wrote her off because of some super deepmeta level townspew from Jan, and I think the way she got frustrated D1 was extremely towny. I disliked the way she sheeped Fonti but I guess that's just how they work, and now that Fonti is dead town I'm pretty sure Gemma is also town.

Stanari - I have her down as unaligned with Shadowlancer and initially thought she was a witch with Jarizok because of her hard push onto Shadow at EoD1 - apparently Jan had the same feels about her EoD, which is why he shot her. However, Newcomb's check flipped that whole read on its head, and I don't think witch Stanari tries to bus that hard even for cred later given the fragility of a 3-person team and losing one to a D1 lynch. So, probably town.

dC - I initially got lots of townvibes from dC and I also have him down as unaligned with Shadow although I can't exactly remember which of his posts made me write that. Lately his posts have been much the same but I just haven't seen anything from him that screams town at me? Maybe it's just because D2 was a bore for me and I didn't bother posting or interacting much, but he's pretty mid-level but no concern from me. If Asmo is scum I'd be a bit more concerned w/r/t the posts from dC about Mal in early D1, but I'll let that rest until/if it becomes relevant.

Waco - I think a lot of my feels on Waco still revolve around how I felt day one wrt his Lump campaign being infinitely more fake than Tom's. I need to re-read him in order for this to go more in-depth as a read but I have not seen many posts from Waco that sound like they're coming from someone who is town, I can say that much off the top of my head.

Vaimes - Jan made a joke earlier in the game about flipping my reads list to find witches and I'm... starting to think that was startlingly accurate. I guess despite all my analysis and reading I just wound up being hilariously wrong this game, with Shadow mindmeld pocketing me and my top two scumreads being the priest and townFont. I did ease up on my Font read after some good posts of hers but bottom line is I was just wrong. That stops now. Vaimes concerns me because the consensus read on him is (iirc) mostly tonal and not at all content-based, and I'm starting to think he was just tone pocketing me. Reasons for this include the N1 and N2 kills when looked at as a unit - Jan and Fonti both died, both townreading Vaimes, both the people who have the most experience playing with him and reading him and are therefore the most dangerous players to him when they're both not on his team. Throw in a complete nosedive in activity when Shadow got outed and we have ourselves a potential witch. Now, I'm not hard-committing to this read yet, because I still need to go and ISO Vaimes and pick apart things and really dig into it, but just based on feels right now I've moved him pretty far down my list because things just do not feel right. ~spicy~

Asmodeus - The consensus discussed Shadow partner and I'm willing to lynch especially because the night kill may have been heavy wine wrt Fonti wanting Asmodeus lynched. If we follow Fonti's wishes and lynch Asmo, did they kill her because they wanted us to do that and he's town, or did they kill her to throw us off that lynch if he's a witch because that's what they want us to think? Wine. All the wine. But still a good lynch.

Shadow - Outed dead witch.
--- Post automerged ---

@DC I just saw this lmfAO
--- Post automerged ---
oops, poor DC

@dichotomousCreator

 

And the progression might make sense. Except 1) As you acknowledge I was out of the thread for IRL reason, so how did I get scummier? 2) The quoted posts have nothing to do with my actions D2 regardless, and you taking guesses at my mindset, as by your own words, "you don't know scum!waco" so where do those reads come from I wonder?
--- Post automerged ---
So the only reason for you to downgrade me in that context is simply as an agenda.
--- Post automerged ---
@Cobalt, the flipped read list comment was from me...

 

the fuck do you mean nothing has changed tom the claimed priest didn't die

that's a huge expectancy deviation

anyway cobalt's readlist has convinced me I should prefer to scrutinize Vaimes instead

(although if you want to thunderdome me at this point I am not liable to say no)