Only soup I care about is miso

 

I meant what I said that I can't mentally try to find a wolf elsewhere if it's not Cobalt, until we get the flip. That said, the 24h night helped me remember how to be patient, so I can also let Cobalt have the 48h to work if that's what he wants. ...But I can also just vote if that's what people want, and/or if Reg is really sure.

 

Hi you.

 

Ugh i just realized there was a way for us to 100% win today.

 

And that is?

 

It involved gravedigger targeting Eido last night.

And I guess it was a win today or tomorrow, but that's fine.

 

I ain't saying he a gravedigger, but he ain't messin with no live, live playas
--- Post automerged ---
but seriously, no idea what you mean about gravedigger targeting Eido last night

 

Gravedigger would have learned Eido's role.

I'm not saying that he was the Acolyte and tom tried to use it as an un-CC'able fakeclaim, but...
--- Post automerged ---
Depending on what Eido was, the last witch is going to claim exactly one of three roles (Acolyte included).

So this game is kind of uh. On lock. Make scummy people claim, kill within the three (but probably) two roles, win.
--- Post automerged ---
Depending on what Eido was, the last witch is going to claim exactly one of three roles (Acolyte included).

So this game is kind of uh. On lock.

Also it's Graverobber, you swine. :V

 

Vaimes, Grapes, Fontisian and Fluff are always town here. Would bet the game on all of those.

I don't think Umami being coached/told to newbtowntell in the thread is completely impossible, but I feel like the way it happened feels fairly genuine, think the movement from Gemma to myself and the "If this is wrong are you willing to die" is a very weird and unlikely way for a partner to play or handle it, can very much see newbtown playing that route though. Just don't think it's likely the slots scum, if we're wrong on others maybe reassess here late but yeah, putting this slot to the side too.

Cobalts very probably just the last mafia, gone into this in depth already, rate the odds of the game ending on his lynch ~90%. Find most of his defences sort of "I wouldn't do this thing if scum were in that position!!" when he'd started doing them before scum were in that position. Find his interactions and treatment of both Tom/Gemma and theirs of him to fit as partners. Just all up see a lot that makes sense with him as scum.

If the game doesn't end there then suggest looking inside Dels/Citrus I guess.

I might actually look at Citrus before Dels, partially because there's some reasons I think Dels is just town here and I'd rather not have to go into them atm but mostly because the self-vote thing I was town reading is sort of weakened now that we're looking at a Gemma/Tom world, with Gemma being a leading wagon, and a lump wagon starting on Tom if he lets Gemma get lynched there he's effectively backing himself to endgame and I can see him sort of trying to fall on the sword and put that responsibility on someone else. I still think Town!Citrus just having a bad read is the most likely situation, but yeah, if the game doesn't end at Cobalt maybe look at Citrus again, especially since he didn't vote/push Gemma and didn't lump Tom. I also found his whole "here's some reasons for Cobalt being scum but he has enough votes, vote: Dels" was kind of ??? in that there's no real mention or comment about why he's decided to vote Dels in particular there and it can have some scum motivation in opening up two competing angles that aren't himself to mslynch.

Long story short I think Cobalt -> Citrus wins this game like 95% of the time.

Vote: Cobalt

 

i'm still lost about how you guys know that gravedigger/robber person targeted Eido

 

We don't 'know', it's just the most likely thing that happened.

But anyway yeah, Cobalt can claim in his next post alongside with explain his whole 'Lump plan' and we can go from there.

 

Possible the Graverobber checked a witch, just to see what info coven would have.
--- Post automerged ---
'Cause depending on who died when, worst case scenario is the coven has Eido's role plus whoever the Angels have been protecting.

 

Let's not stress about it. As long as we have no role hints from the town core, we'll be fine.

Cobalt, claim.

 

@Cobalt - If you're around/online, popping in here and claiming would be nice.

 

We want claims from Cobalt, Dels and Umami in think, right? Maybe Citrus?

 

My major question is: Is Cobalt's claim going to change whether we lynch him? Since we don't know what Cobalt knows and it seems at least moderately likely that he knows the role of at least one murdered player and can make an okay false claim, it seems like his claim probably won't convince us not to lynch him. If he is a townie and we ignore his claim and lynch him anyway, we're just giving the remaining witch more information to soup for no reason

 

For Umami, for me, it's less about the noobtells and more about the times when he randomly would get super serious and formal and ask people really hard-hitting questions. I mean he only did this, like, 2-3 times, but still.
--- Post automerged ---
she* i think, sorry
--- Post automerged ---
glad to have earned your trust =P pleasure to meet you btw, reg

 

We're doing this one at a time, we're going with Cobalt first. I'd go Citrus next, then Dels and then Umami (But it's never going to get past Citrus IMO)

 

The last witch can only fakeclaim Eido’s role. Anything else will invite a CC.
--- Post automerged ---
And if Cobalt claims something that is very unlikely to have been Eido’s role then he can live.

 

Possibly yes. There's only two dead townies this game, Jarizok (Who we know was a priest) and Eido.

So he either claims a role that's of a living player, we get a CC and we lynch and kill between them. OR he claims Eidos role, and if the gravedigger checked Eido (Most likely scenario) they'll CC him saying "Nope, that was Eidos role", we lynch and kill between the CC's and win.