Tom/Reg not w/w.

 

I don’t know how else you expect me to take a “Vaimes can be mafia” some other way.

Because it looked like he doesn’t want to be Priest checked.

The Thing is the Priest check.
--- Post automerged ---
Whyyyy won’t my phone let me copy paste text.

I’ll answer pings later I guess.

 

What, why is it totally disgusting otherwise? I voted her because I think that slank cover type post comes from mafia way more often than town and because I think it's a good way to see how she handles herself. I don't really know anything about her but if she's mafia then she's probably going to be at least a little nervous coming into the game. She didn't really respond to it though so idk. I don't think there's anything disgusting about that but I'm sorry if I offended you or anyone.

My take on Vaimes is that he's Vaimes. I think he's less likely to push on me like that as mafia because I think he'd be scared of getting on my bad side and it probably doesn't even occur to him to say that I'm faking nonchalance in that world? I'm not sure I entirely believe that he thinks pushing back on me will accomplish anything and I like the kind of scattered way he made that post since if he is mafia he's probably intently crapping his pants as he makes that post if that makes sense. Do you think that's a bad read?
--- Post automerged ---

Oh, right.

That's not a real read, though.

 

Hi I think it's a bad read.

 

If there’s no jovial tone established, how is anyone supposed to think it’s not a real read. :I

 

OH.

I get it now. Ok. I'm stupid.

And eh, I don't really think that's very good reasoning. If we don't know whether or not scum coached people or not, we probably shouldn't assume one way or the other and base our reads entirely on that, no?
--- Post automerged ---

The Vaimes one? Would prefer if you wait until Amberiat has responded, but would like to hear why you think that if you feel like wordsing.
--- Post automerged ---

Huh?
--- Post automerged ---
No, dude, I voted you because I wanted to see how you / others would react. I did also think that your posts were kind of flat and you ignored me which is the same thing you did last game when you were mafia but like, it's page 1 so it's whatever. It's the starting point for a read, not an actual read itself. Does that make sense?
--- Post automerged ---
Also it's not like you can read my tone anyway apparently :v

 

This whole thing is suddenly very deja vu.

Eh.

Also you didn’t vote me.

 

At work in a meeting, will be home in ~4 hours though.

 

What's your gut read on Vaimes right now?
--- Post automerged ---

Hey Regfan are you usually this serious? Granted my sample size of you is pretty small but your tone feels wayyy different from the last 2 games we played

 

For whatever it's worth, I didn't consider it "disgusting" or anything, but I also didn't really feel the need to reply to it. Seems like the sort of thing that's best disproven by "playing the game".

I've also eaten votes in response to that sort of post many times before as both alignments, heh.
--- Post automerged ---
I'm inclined to read regfan's frustration as genuine here but I wouldn't bet money on it.

 

Best post since my last one. Y’all other people need to step up.
--- Post automerged ---

This one was also decent I guess.

 

Is it, though? I feel like "these two guys who are arguing aren't w/w" is a pretty easy post to make as either alignment.

 

Sure it’s easy, but it’s also decently likely to be accurate. Got a solid shruggy nod from me.

 

Yeah, I was just thinking that too. Sorry.

I don't think I really do gut reads anymore. Probably town I guess if you forced me to lock in alignments right now, but my reasoning for that is kind of bad and he's nowhere near outside his scum range, so it would be a little premature. I'm not very worried about trying to get a solid read on him at this point though. How do you feel about the stuff I posted about him so far? How much of the thread have you read atm?

Am glad. Also, I think Reg's frustration is real regardless of alignment. Best thing I think is just to give him some space.

Not if you're Newcomb.

Heh.
--- Post automerged ---

Interesting. I was wondering before the game if you or fonti would scumread me, definitely not right off the bat though. Why do you think I might be scum?

Why is Vaimes very probably town? Talk about weird feeling?
--- Post automerged ---

Why do you want to lump yourself? What do you mean you feel bamboozled?

 

Gemmaaaaa. Engage me?

 

Boop.

I am now caught up. Where are you at on Cobalt?

 

@Gemma Now that I know the standard lump plan I'd like to clear myself. Getting NKd before I have to try to play this set up on later days sounds good to me. Plus I'm almost assuredly one of the weakest and most shrug lynchable players in this game so I'm a great Lump candidate!

And I just did not have that sort of plan in mind for lump and had to reevaluate everything that had happened.

 

He thought I was funny and I am, so that’s a good sign. Lemme see if I can wrangle a lean there for you.

 

Excellent reasoning, Jari.

 

What about if i just decide to leave you alive to double vote wrong in lylo?
--- Post automerged ---

Would love to say ive never read people that way...
--- Post automerged ---

Wait what
--- Post automerged ---

Its not nothing with me and reg's ranges.