I'm sure you realize that a short, trite post is just as likely to make me seem suspicious. Not the least of which because when I do post, and have something to say, I tend to be rather wordy. That, and there wasn't any way to answer Irene without properly explaining myself. I've come to learn that she is quite intelligent, but her mind works in ludicrously mysterious ways.

 

Sorry about not posting much guys, it's just that I recently started placement and as such, I've had no spare time at all, but from what I've read so far I think Fen is pretty suspicious right now as by now, the priest would have checked Matt. The only problem is though is that if dhulli was BoD, and Fen is traveller or survivor, that could really screw us over. As such, I think we should have a look at some of the other players to see how they've been acting, also Ashaya has been acting a lot quieter lately, is there a reason for this?

 

Ok, Irene's out of the suspect pool for right now. Who else is there?

The obvious suspect is Fen, so I guess I'll chuck a deadline vote at him for now. I'll look back at the posts and see if there's anyone who stands out to me.

Deadline Vote: Fenraellis

 

Either Town has struck the pay, or we're being rolled.

And I feel naked as hell without protective layers of spreadsheets while playing a hard pro-town.

And so, I'll sheep. You'll tell me to vote Fen, and I'll vote Fen. Until I make sense of this mess.

/angry

Deadline Vote: Fenraellis

Meanwhile, I don't trust this bandwagon at all. Bandwagons tend to fail. D8

 

Vote Player: Geabe

As of right now, he's the guy I trust least. There's been something off about all of his posts, and if the detective can investigate Matt (or post some form of results regarding Matt, because I'm guessing he was already investigated at some point), that would clarify things a great deal.

 

I agree with this so hard. I'm sick of tl;dr's. It's why I haven't been posting much.

The reason is because of all the walls of text, rampant suspicion against everyone, giving me nowhere to start. Though I am suspicious of Irene's lover being the Warlock, making her a member of the Warlock faction, actually....

Also, I've been busy having a life. Hopefully we'll get a lead somehow, and I'll be driven to post due to actually believing someone is guilty. I will check in later and see what else has been said, and vote.

 

What's there to defend? I've listed the chances of me being scum versus innocent, and by the looks of things Fenraelis is doing a good enough job being overly defensive of himself not being the Warlock. At a certain point you just gotta ask yourself what makes me more suspicious than Fen, because you haven't really told me why, Silens...

 

Well, I could point to the first big TL,DR; I dumped in this thread after the first deaths came out, but really, it comes down to the fact that while Fenraellis is doing a spectacularly bad job defending himself, I'm fairly certain he's the Survivalist based upon the data I have. According to my charts and logic (which might be flawed, but I've got faith in them), if he was the Warlock last night, he would have died, and since I'm not presuming dhulli was the BoD, that makes you the one I suspect the most... after Geabe, of course.

 

I don't like this bandwagon against Fenraellis. He just hasn't stood out to me the way some other people (Vira and Geabe) have at times. I'm not saying he's not scum, but Fen isn't at the top of my list at the moment.

Still, if lynching him helps clear some stuff up, and we only need one more vote, I might be persuaded, but right now, I'm dubious.

 

Reading back through parts of the thread, two people seem to come off more suspicious then others.

First is Silens. It's possible that he's just extremly zealous and happy to get to the lynching, but to me it's the most bloodthirsty people that are usually guilty of something. Surprisingly, I don't think he's a witch. Maybe I'm misunderstanding this, but it seems that Silens is very suspicious of Matt and dismissive of Fen being guilty of anything even though both have the same amount of evidence against them. To me, that suggests that Silens is the Thrall and Fen is the Warlock.

On the exact opposite end of the spectrum, we have addictedforlife. It's always possible that they're just shy and quiet, but so far they've only posted about how they don't know who to vote for and one reluctant vote for lungs. With SW2 and Riley the renegade lurker fresh in my mind, that makes me suspicious.

Out of the two, I'm definitly more suspcious of Silens though. But for now I'll stick with my Deadline vote on Fen to see what happens.

 

How close are we to a lynch on Fen?

(Obligatory apology for not posting much - I've had a crazy weekend - but I'm reading through the last few pages now to catch up...)

 

You know what? The more I think about it, the stupider it is for me to keep my vote on Fen. If I'm right, he's not going to die by lynch. If I'm wrong, I'd be killing an innocent. Again. Normally I wouldn't have a problem with that but Fen has a proven track record of being pretty good when he's pro town.

Plus Silens just seems a bit too eager to carry Fiat's torch. So...

Rescind Vote

Vote Player: Silens Cursor

 

Is anyone else thinking that Jon is doing a pretty awesome job directing the flow of conversation in this game? Although he is the mayor, I am just commenting.

Not quite sure how I'm going to vote this phase. For some reason I thought the phase started this afternoon - and then I find it out started yesterday. I'll be re-reading the posts and see what's going on with Fenraelis and everyone else's suspicions.

 

Current votal

Fenraellis (0+3): | Jon, Castiel, Lungs,
Vira (0+1): | The Santi,
The Santi (1+0): hgf,
Geabe (1+0): Silens Cursor,
Silens Cursor (1+0): Vesvius,

 

Changing from deadline.

Rescind Vote.

Vote Lynch: Fenraellis