Ok actually sleeping now since I have work in like 5 hours.

 

Okay, so...possible scum!Hunter worlds:
- holy hunting world (not sure what the EV on this is for scum, but I would have thought it lower than offing confirmed town)
- scum!Inquisitor finds holy N2 (plausible, but highly specific on scumroles)
- Newcomb/Owner are scum and Agents were both dead when they claimed (loltinfoil)
- scumteam is just bad (always a possibility)

town!Hunter world:
- Hunter shot Miner or Silver believing them to be scum, ignoring all conversations in-thread about what they should do

Thiiiiink I believe Hunter is scum. Related: Is there ANY reason for a town Hunter not to claim at this point?

 

Hunter should claim and justify shot?

 

Let's start with the people who had Silver as a scumread.

Let's also do the thing where we specifically claim Not Hunter or Hunter.
(Not the Hunter.)

 

Obviously hunter claim or lack thereof solves the issue

---------- Post automerged at 09:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:44 PM ----------

Not the hunter

 

Do I really have to say?

 

Not Hunter

 

Not Hunter

 

So either beruru is the hunter or somebody has already lied, that's fun.

---------- Post automerged at 10:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:50 PM ----------

Oh actually I don't think newcomb was exactly V reading miner but I would be very disappointed if he actually killed him.

 

NoT Hunter, as you may have suspected.

 

Not hunter, also not reliably here for the next 4 hours @ me if you need me.

 

I could be wrong, but I think I'm starting to reach levels of paranoia I have seldom reached in a mafia game rn

---------- Post automerged at 11:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:32 PM ----------

That tinfoil is bad bad bad

 

I have another stupid plan idea (not about Hunter).

 

Wanna explain why, maybe?

 

Rubicon night killed -> Rubicon town
Rubicon town -> Tom scum
Tom scum -> only dead town player D2 was dyachei
Mallorean didn't claim -> Mallorean wasn't an agent
Rubicon died N2 -> at least 1 agent alive D3

Newcomb + Owner claimed agent D3
Per above, either dyachei + living player were agents or 2 living players were agents
100% town agents that are not newcomb + owner should claim

Thus Newcomb + Owner are agents

---------- Post automerged 07-28-2017 at 12:01 AM ---------- Previous post was 07-27-2017 at 11:49 PM ----------

Hunter has to have been an EW. Y/N?

 

That's actually the most irrelevant thing, what are you even doing

 

Also I'm just going to throw it out there:

Would it be a good idea to have some degree of claiming toDay?

Things to keep in mind:
1) A scum Undertaker AND a scum hunter means witches have to 'steal' a role from a dead townplayer, which is difficult. Especially difficult for LW's with the thrown out roles
2) EW's can claim Tom's role with impunity due to it not being revealed by Rubicon
3) We may want to force an assassin claim first and decide how to proceed from there
4) Halftime will likely activate soon? Idk how it works, if we hit less than half the starting players after toNight does that mean N5 is halftime? Or when does it occur?
5) Do we want to have a priest claim for the checks or nah? (would need to feel relatively safe wrt Assassin and maybe LC before considering this, otherwise things get complicated because [redacted])

---------- Post automerged at 12:04 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:04 AM ----------

He started it

---------- Post automerged at 12:05 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:04 AM ----------

Wait kai are you talking about the hunter EW part or the other part?

---------- Post automerged at 12:15 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:05 AM ----------

Just 2 measly pages? Mehk

 

Witch Hunt #9: Half-Time Edition!

Votal 4.1.

Kai [2]: Vaimes, Fable.
Citrus [1]: DC.
Fable [1]: Kai.

Not Voting [6]: Beru, Citrus, Fluff, Newcomb, Owner, Wei.

With 10 alive, it will be 6 votes to soft lynch and 8 votes to hard lynch!

 

Debating tinfoil on owner and newcomb.

Mass claim is bad, we haven't had any holies outed in thread and witches are obviously concerned about that.

Halftime is the first night with at least half of the players dead. Half of 17 is 8.5,and at least half would be 9.

So the first night that starts with 8 players or less is Halftime. Assuming no extra kills today, it'll be tomorrow night.

 

It is at this point I should discuss the difference between "tinfoil" and "loltinfoil"

"tinfoil" is an unlikely but possible world that could have been brought about by specific scum actions and coincidences. It should generally be considered way behind other worlds, but comes up when the game has reached a seemingly odd state. Fable being scum in RWBY was a tinfoil world.

"loltinfoil" is a world that requires abject town stupidity in order to exist. Examples include worlds where holy players let themselves be lynched silently, or, yes, both Agents doing the same.

---------- Post automerged at 03:52 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:45 PM ----------

(EBWOP: Or, indeed, Agents not CCing)