Oh, Newcomb asked me a thing.

Ideally, at least half of them.

 

I'm so glad that Newcomb and Owner are town, by the way.

---------- Post automerged at 07:04 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:02 PM ----------

Wei as the remaining coven with Fluff/Kai LWs would be a dream, tbh.

 

I'm glad that you, Newcomb, owner, and Fable are all town.

 

I said I'm not a gambler, but I guess that's not true, huh?

... anyway, this is where live!Town!Assassin assassinates Wei as the Hunter.

Please.

 

Okay, so we have known town (living or dead) of
dC
dyachei
Rubicon
Owner
Newcomb

Almost Certainly Town Dead

Silvercrys3467
Miner

??? Dead

mallorean_thug

Almost Certainly Scum Dead

Jarizok

Scum Dead

tom

Thus the list of living possible scum is:

fluffiness
Beruru
weiyaoli
KaiDASH
Vaimes
Fable
Citrus

and there's three scum in them + mal

I think fluff/beru/weiy are town at this point, which leaves three scum in

Citrus
Fable
KaiDASH
Vaimes
mallorean_thug

or one of the townreads is off base. Most likely one there is weiy, but like I still don't feel like that's super likely? weiy hasn't pinged me, like, at all since showing up as a townread early on.

Citrus is Elder if scum, and...I haven't really been able to suss out the others.

So, tangent for a sec. Does anyone have any opinion on Elder vs. LW status for Jarizok/mallorean_thug/Vaimes/KaiDASH? If you townread these people, then just state what kind of scum you THINK they should be if they WERE scum.

 

How long have you been writing that?

 

Not very. I just got sick of not saying anything and didn't really feel like I had anything useful to add to what was going on.

Like, "hey guys weiy is still town" was about it b/c given that assumption I don't really agree with ANYTHING that's being said. So I just decided to write up a readpost saying that (plus some other stuff) instead.

 

Elder/Elder/Junior/Junior.

You can cross out the middle two, though.

---------- Post automerged at 07:33 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:30 PM ----------

Why is Wei not a witch?

---------- Post automerged at 07:35 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:33 PM ----------

Wait, I missed that.

I also want to know why Citrus is an elder if scum, and also why Mal isn't town.

("unless Mal is with Kai and he told Mal not to so he would die as town bla bla bla" doesn't count.)

 

What. How on earth am I potentially an elder witch??

 

Beruru ---

Citrus is elder if scum b/c shitty behaviour with Tom is a big part of why I think Citrus is scum. Like, the reaction to the CFD and the whole mutual defense thing. His behaviour after that has been passable sometimes and meh other times, but that by itself wouldn't make me want to lynch him so I think if he is scum he must be knowingly aligned with tom.

Like tl;dr if Citrus/Tom hadn't happened I'd probably be looking elsewhere, so based on that Citrus should be Elder.

Wei isn't a witch because too many other people are witchier than him. Like. I haven't hated anything he's done? There's just no case on him, like, at all. Even Kai at least has some D1 stupidity I could see as coming from scum.

mal was too low content for me to assess reliably. There's also the whole meta thing with Acio that makes me nervous putting that slot as a locked in townlynch.

Now, could you build me the towncase on Vaimes and the scumcase on Kai?

also gfdi I knew I forgot one, also want Elder/Junior assessment on Fable.

 

Do you have anything else about Citrus besides Tom? How about interactions with Jari?

 

I kinda didn't notice Citrus reactions with Jari since I was too busy just running Jari over. I can go back and reread, but could you give me a starting page number? (I'm on 20PPP and honestly I have done like zero rereading this game because the thread is 194 pages long)

 

Not using 100 posts per page?

And here I was thinking that was standard! I should be posting votals, like, every other post!

... I don't know what your page number would be, then. I can get a post number? Hold on a sec.

 

well I signed up and then have changed zero settings since :v

 

Why would you not use 100 ppp.

Why would you hurt yourself in this way?

I mean, I have limits too. This forum also has 250/500/1000 ppp, and I mostly don't use that because I don't want to set my computer on fire.

---------- Post automerged at 08:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:03 PM ----------

The first time Jari and Citrus interact in a meaningful way is post 309. So I guess you have to start from there? (rip)

 

okay...yeah that's going to take quite a long time >_>

I'll let you know when I have results (or if tbh, depending on in-game and RL happenings I might not even be able to get anything meaningful before EOD :/)

 

Just ctrl + f "Jari" and "Citrus" on every page, tbh.

---------- Post automerged at 08:13 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:10 PM ----------

Actually, if it's going to take that long, can you just trust that Citrus isn't an EW and operate in that world? That's a lot faster.

---------- Post automerged at 08:15 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:13 PM ----------

Finding Jari posts is probably better than finding Citrus posts, then, actually.

Just ctrl + F "Jari" every page.

 

I mean
If I did that then it's like
Citrus is town?
And I really don't think Citrus is town >_>

...I guess unless tom hard defended someone from the LW/Agent pool as a win/win (i.e. either he's defending town that will get confirmed later, or he's saving an ally)? But again it's like

why is Citrus hard defending his counterwagon. Unless he's read tom as an Elder with supreme confidence already, his play in that world is to piledrive tom as hard as he can.

also ctrl+F jari just turns up people quoting readlists with jari in them 80% of the time rip

---------- Post automerged at 01:24 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:23 PM ----------

Like

sell me on Citrus isn't an Elder? Without just saying my D1 valuation is wrong.

 

Your d1 valuation IS wrong though

 

Quiet, witch!

(seriously though, if I thought that I wouldn't have that valuation in the first place. So the argument basically just goes "Citrus's behaviour around tom was towny and tom was dragging Citrus down" "No, Citrus's behaviour around tom was scummy and tom was defending a buddy" and it doesn't actually go anywhere)