While I like seeing read lists, I'd settle for consistent content over a number of smaller posts too, or at all in general. But I can live with your suggestion, it's how I caught you in Endgames anyway...

(In-offensive, mainly consensus reads, little reasoning).

I'm ok with my vote still

---------- Post automerged at 01:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:40 AM ----------

Not that I know of, I did @ notification you on it

---------- Post automerged at 01:45 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:41 AM ----------

As long as you're sure.

 

Lmfao. Same.

 

Hey Atum!

10 chars/

 

The Waco Kid

I'll give my thoughts on that when I'm awake.

 

Also Menace, I'd like to re-iterate my request for reads from you. I'll settle for top 3 town & scum

 

I'll add that there's another reason I ask for the claim, connected to reason I don't explain it. For players newer to the site, town!gravediggers tend to fight against being told to claim more while scum one are more likely to capitulate easily. I'd put your level of resistance on the slightly towny end of the spectrum.

 

Can I do the same?

I want to say one is between Luckylee and Fonti.

While Fonti is good enough to poke Lee just as a "hey buddy i need you to be somewhat active", considering her play thus far I do not think that makes that much sense.

Just because she herself is not in a spot to do that. Playing passive to that extend and poking exactly your scum partner is a really unlikely scenario.

Her bit on the mechanics is not towny, because if she does not do that Von (and myself) would kick her till she actually weighs as much as a duck.
It is also not scummy tbh, but i would not give her cred for it.


Lee is scummy because he asked for a fight and then dodged my amazing pillowfight techniques with excuses about his dildo moves.
His content is also lackluster at best.


As of right now one of them is more likely scummy, but not both.


The 2nd scum in my eyes is Koalas, but that is just because he is always scum.



I talked about towns earlier, but i might do it again in a bit, busy playing boardgames right now tbh.

---------- Post automerged at 08:58 ---------- Previous post was at 08:50 ----------

The one thing i actually liked Fonti doing is her reaction to Citrus a bit earlier.

Felt natural to me, she basically only gave him a townread, but her wording is kinda taunting, which i like. (Slight townread from that)

Everything else is a nullread at best (i think), and she has not done enough for me to be not a scumread.

 

Okay, so on a reread I don't have all that much more. I like Citrus some more now. He took until about late page 10 to start properly contributing, but once he did he seemed pretty aggressive and engaged others, so there's that. Hopefully him defending me didn't colour my perceptions too much, but seeing as I only had him in mind to look over based on that one post I think I'm comfortable marking him down as a townread.

I'm in agreement with Waco about Lucky, his readwall is meh and even his attempts to engage with others mostly come down to asking them for their opinion rather than venturing any himself.

Waco... on the one hand, he's also got a lot of posts asking other people things and not so many saying them himself. On the other, in the discussion with Citrus he stuck to his guns and explained where he was coming from, while I think scum might have backed off, and he has been poking at and interacting with a lot of people instead of restricting himself to a handful of lurkers.

Snowvon... ugh. A lot of people, people with a lot more experience playing with him and playing mafia in general, with more recent experience in both, seem adamant that he's town. And yet (leaving aside the fact that I'd be an idiot to simply accept that at face value) he seems to have faded into the background after his spate of activity in the first day. He hasn't said that much, commented on what Citrus and Waco are doing, chimed in on GD antics in any real way, he has yet to pressure Fluff on anything (or anyone really). Argh. Maybe it's just because I'm playing after a long time, but I just don't see what everyone else seems to.

Also, I have a hard time seeing it as simple coincidence that Cobalt claimed GD just over 24 hours after Kai's first post, meaning it's past the deadline for Apprentice. Not sure the extent to which that would matter, it's not like the Apprentice couldn't make that decision anyway, but it feels... odd.

 

Damn. My ability to play mafia like shit is impressive as ever.

So since everyone wants to try hard day one this game has become impressively tedious, I've decided.

I'm the dirty old bastard. Also I'm super duper town.

Trololololol.

Lynch me if you dare shitters. I'll probably shoot someone randomly, in the spirit of Ika.

 

So luckylee is town, and continues his streak of always getting the vengeance roles lol

I'd be ok with bombarding votes on atum or menace, assuming koalas comes through with something substantial eventually. Any preferences?

I should probably drop lungs back into null too at this point

---------- Post automerged at 10:57 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:57 AM ----------

It wasn't me koalas, it was autocorrect, I swear!

 

Eh, I can see scum!Lucky pulling that stunt too, it does make it that much more unattractive to lynch him.

 

I mean, he could be, but I think it's very unlikely? Like pretty sure he didn't have to claim there, pretty easy to derail his wagon this early if he wanted

 

Killing him today is always bad anyway.

If he is scum we gives scum a second chance to hit the priest, because he can shoot a town of his choosing.

If he is town he will make a uncofirmed shot, which might hit the priest.



Either way not my kill of choice for today.

Also Goodjob, claiming your role just gives the witches more info for their priesthunt, and we need to protect Von as much as possible.
You only claim if you are kinda close to getting lynched and think this is your only chance of survival, not because you are lazy.

 

Waking up to a DOB claim. Fun times.

---------- Post automerged at 12:56 ---------- Previous post was at 12:49 ----------

Moridin: weekends are busy for me. This weekend is extra so, because for some reason my professor thought it'd be okay to give us a test on the same day that like 5 other assignments in that very same class are due???

I agree with this.

---------- Post automerged at 12:58 ---------- Previous post was at 12:56 ----------

Uh. Hm.

Witches don't have Daychat in WH, so that makes me feel less ??? about Cobalt claiming when he did.

 

Trololololololololol.

 

Missed your antics, Lucky.

---------- Post automerged at 13:26 ---------- Previous post was at 13:08 ----------

Ew, Waco is getting close to dethroning me. I may have to Night kill him.

Anyway. Let me think about where I'm at.

Lungs
Jan
Kalas
Tempus Fugit
Atum
---
Snowvon
Newcomb
Waco
Moridin
Citrus
Menace
fontisian
Luckylee
Cobalt
Fluff

Above the --- are people I don't really have reads on. Gray is townlean and orange is scumfeels.

Talking about the grays: Menace is a weak townlean but I sort of liked his first post (reaction to the thread and the self-vote looked genuine). fontisian is meh but her being okay with Citrus speaking for her felt towny. Luckylee is Luckylee, but if he's scum I feel like that will be resolved easily enough? Either someone CC's him, we lynch the real (and very likely scum if no CC) DOB, or maybe even the Priest checks him, or whatever. And Cobalt claimed Gravedigger, so he isn't dying Day 1 ever (short of a huge scumslip), but Moridin did point out a Thing that kind of sucks but we'll put that to the side for a second because his claim did look kind of hesitant. And then I have mild vague scummy feelings about fluff, but I will acknowledge that scumreading him is a Thing I am prone to doing all the time offsite.

As for Atum, he's Always Busy and it isn't alignment indicative. Just sad.

Unfortunately, it looks like Koalas actually did roll scum again. I'm just saying, Lucky, he's not a horrible shot. Take it from me!

 

I already have a spinner set up with everyones name and whoever it lands on is getting shot when I die.

 

As long as Koalas' name is the biggest piece of the pie.

 

They usually do during pre-game though, for clarity

 

Oh right, we had like a hidden pregame.