Hmm, I need to reread.

I can accept that, but would still prefer to shoot/lynch in the same bucket to hopefully guarantee getting a scum.

You'd like to change that bucket to Typhon/Tom instead of Slip/Koalas?

 

Oh yeah miner was always town. Didn't mention that with my worlds.

Miner is town if Newcomb is town.
And if Newcomb was scum, then him trying to lynch his partner miner all of d2 is not a thing.

 

Koalas not voting for me for the last 48 hours was interesting when his initially read was me and Slippery as the two people who were scummy to him. He's consistently voted for Slippery, but he didn't vote for me at all. I find that a little odd. It could be his read on Slippery felt stronger to him. But I'm curious why he didn't jump on the chance to vote for me. Or maybe he would have done that in the last 24 hours if I hadn't claimed? I don't know.

 

There is definitely at least one scum between you three. You seem fairly certain that Vira/New are unaligned.

 

I am thinking about it.

Slippery/koalas means we only have 1 claim needed, which is a plus in general.

I don't have a lot of reasons to townread typhon.
I would like others to talk to me about him, because he was ignored a lot, i think.

Typhon :
Could you go in depth on some of your reads?
Why is tom one of your top townreads? I think you had him early on in there.
Look at my world building game, do you agree with it?


I will reread koalas next. I cannot remember a lot of scumhunting he did after the clash with slippery on d1 either (as Von mentioned earlier)

 

I didn't vote for you because I was waiting for the Priest claim. Which you really should have claimed a lot earlier in the Day but w/e.

---------- Post automerged at 12:53 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:52 AM ----------

Scratch fairly certain. Not even considering it Jan?

 

Even if Newcomb and Vira are scum together it does not change everything.

Just means the other circle has 1 instead of 2 witches.

Vira / Newcomb / insert other 5 people here.

Our lynches work similar to the world where Vira is town.

---------- Post automerged at 05:56 ---------- Previous post was at 05:54 ----------

The world is weird considering Newcomb started going hard on vira with his catchup post.
Calling her out several times.



Can you explain the priestclaim comment?

Did you wait for HER to claim priest or SOMEONE to claim priest?

If you were waiting for anyone to claim priest, why did you vote beforehand matter?
If you were waiting for her to claim priest, why and when did you get a priest read on her?

 

I have more experience playing mafia. The general rule that not everyone follows is when you are the cop, and you have to claim you hold it to the later part or close to the end of that day phase. Not everyone agrees with it, but you get more reactions if you hold it for longer. Um but with Witchhunt being a no reveal setup, I can see the virtue of claiming earlier on as it gives town an extra piece of the puzzle to work with. In some regards, yes I could seem questionable claiming rather late in the day as you have time to prepare it, but someone could easily counter and say if you claimed earlier you could have had it prepared from the night phase. So that's more of null tell.

So priests usually claim day 3?

 

Kalas is self-conscious about his vote because he is a Witch.

---------- Post automerged 10-09-2016 at 00:01 ---------- Previous post was 10-08-2016 at 23:59 ----------

Like.

Does any townie ever come into the thread Day 3 NOT voting for any of their scumreads because "oh I need to wait for the Cop to claim before I do anything!"

 

There's no hard rule on when to claim. The past 24 hours could have just been put to better use, everyones been coasting, myself included, cause you were the apathetic lynch.

 

said no villager ever about a scumread

kill the Witch

 

You're actually being incredibly dumb right now Snow. I hadn't voted yet because owner was the lynch that was going to happen. Apathetic lynch as in she was being completely apathetic. She didn't care which is why this thread has been so dead toDay.

 

I see you writing a lot of words that have nothing to do with your other scumread, SlipperyAxe###.

 

Yes, there's no hard rule about claiming. But if there was a chance that I could get through the day without claiming, I was going to do that. Because no one would kill me in the night (in most cases) because I'm more prone to get lynched. Most times, I don't claim unless I'm on the verge of possibly dying. I guess overall with the kind of checks (bad checks) I had; there was no way I was going to just claim that without pressure.

 

If we kill koalas then i would ask for slippery to not get shot straight away.

He has no power left and if we can confirm koalas alignment as scum, then slippery would be close to confirmed town.
Just reread their interaction again. No was they are scum together.

 

Owner was not the lynch that was going to happen.

Are you scum with tom?

 

When you choose to claim says a lot about your mindset. How you thought you could possibly get through today without claiming playing the way youve been playing is beyond me.

 

Koalas could you please explain why you said you were waiting for the priest claim?

You have to see that if there are 2 scum between typhon, tom and you, then you know that the priest is between von owner and the other of the two of you.

Which makes it reasonable for you to believe owner might be the priest (after the shot bounced on mal and mal claimed hunter).

Like the case is easy to make for scum!koalas.
But why did town!koalas want to wait?
What was the difference for you between voting or not there?

 

Have you been reading the same thread as me?

 

I forgot you feel fairly certain about tom being scum.

Any chance you can make an actual case on that?
(or link to it if i missed it)