Especially with jari being scum who could haunt whichever buddy is most likely to be priest checked.

 

Yes but no one is going to pay any attention to alignment checks in this game anyway. Priest is just a non-role pretending to be important lol.
--- Post automerged ---

Um, I think people were saying that the coven would have most likely swapped out a musketeer if the rolled 2. Opinions vary on the priest hunting over role killing bit.
--- Post automerged ---
Oh great, I just realized this is one of those awful setups where it's actually somehow optimal in some scenarios to mislynch day 1 and 2.

 

Coven most definitely would not keep two Musketeers.

The alcohol is kicking in bye.

 

Could you talk about why you're townreading Vaimes so strongly?

 

ok so this is what i missed last night

um

idrk what to say tho

gemma's been just totally fine imo? super townie, lots of good thoughts, we are on the same wavelength, she seems to be really evaluating things, when she gets questioned about something she reacts without too much defensiveness or shyness, it's just all good? she felt like she was truly paranoid of me

fonti could be a wolf i guess 'cause there's nothing that makes her, like, HAVE to be town, but if she's a wolf she's a really good one 'cause i don't see anything. her forcefulness and authoritativeness seem good to me? i am pocketed by the way she came to a townread on me day 1.

 

I did that already. #1444

 

Thank. I did read that, I just have a terrible memory. Is there anything specific about the Jari/Vaimes interactions that you think is unaligned, or is it just a general pushed by wolf thing?

 

Wait.

This locks in Vaimes and Gemma as town. Two wolf musketeers would’ve definitely swapped, then they only have to kill one townie for an extra KP.
--- Post automerged ---

I asked that prior to Gemma’s claim and Font’s... continuation of Fontiness.

I’m fine with the both of them.

 

They still get a confirmed second kp after one of them dies, and if neither ever die then that means wolves win. Come on, this isn't that complicated.

 

What? But they'd get the kp earlier if they traded away musketeer, and if neither dies, neither dies either way. Am I being dumb and missing something? Seems 100% optimal to trade the role.

 

Uh, I saw something when I was rereading late yesterday (the stuff around EoD mostly). Don't recall the posts though.
--- Post automerged ---

KP later is better I think regardless? And its a *useless* role, so it is probably better to trade it unless they got another useless role, that part is true.

 

If the game starts with two musketeers (W and V), wouldn't the town musketeer realize that wolves swapped musketeer out and why?

 

Fluff smart!

 

Also doesn't overly matter because Vaimes and Gemma probably town.

 

Hey @Manasi, did you ever get a read on Dels?
--- Post automerged ---

10 points to flufflepuff.

 

Wait how would switching out musketeer role work with 1 or more townies in the 3?

God this setup...

Let's kill shadow he a wolf with jari

 

Vote: Shadow

 

As much as I'd like to repeat my day 1 mistake-but-not-really-a-mistake of taking the fancier play over just lynching Shadow, we probably should just lynch Shadow.
--- Post automerged ---
I think what would be most productive is if anyone has any strong thoughts on Fluff or Cobalt. Or thinks someone besides those two is the final witch.

 

Uh, final witch?

 

final? Shadow (if hes a hit)+ Jari is only 2. unless you're assuming manasi is scum