Yes... that's written from the assumption that Shadow and Manasi are witches?
--- Post automerged ---
I mean, I'm not saying that's 100% definitely true, not getting that ahead of myself, but that seems to be the general consensus, so.

 

Talking about how you will assess potential future events makes that assessment of future events irrelevant.

Also hello

 

I would prefer to lynch Manasi because people are randomly townreading her for no reason and I think it's a more interesting wagon, but you guys do you.
--- Post automerged ---

I don't think it does.

Hello to you too.

 

Eh, I could swap back to Manasi. She feels like she's super not into the game, and that's probably scummy, but could just be her being busy and stressed, so I feel kind of bad. Bleh.

 

I mean we have a Hunter shot so at this point what we need to hear is if anyone has a good reason why the lynch+shot shouldn't be on shadow/manasi in some order.
--- Post automerged ---
@shadowlancerx if you're Nurse, DoB, Survivalist, Fanatic who was checked, Loose Cannon, Hunter, or Priest, claim.

 

O.

Tru.
--- Post automerged ---

I still feel Manasi is towny but that’s apparently an unpopular opinion

 

I guess Oracle would claim too?

Maaaybe UT?

Man I guess only like, Gambler/Judge doesn't claim here?
--- Post automerged ---
Inquisitor also wouldn't claim I think?
--- Post automerged ---
Wow I just realized Nurse is a really fucking dumb role with Role Kill being a thing.

 

Still in beta testing.

 

Yeeeah let's take that role out next time, or tweak it a little so that it's not so useless.
--- Post automerged ---
I guess if we thought Gemma / Vaimes were really really strongly v/v we could have the Nurse +life a random color, and that would do it, but like.
--- Post automerged ---
Personally I'm not at a place where I'd be the game on Gemma being a villager so that's not a plan I'm endorsing at the moment.
--- Post automerged ---
*bet

 

lynch cobalt

 

I think Inquisitor, Gambler, unchecked Fanatic, Judge, Nurse can all die unclaimed.

Also, Nurse looks like a great role for scum. Its just completely useless for town based on what I can tell.

 

I don't care so much about that, I just feel the reads have been static and there's no real town mindset.

 

@M Plus 7 You wanted to chat with me today?

 

Claims in Priest, Oracle, Surv (or +life fanatic), DOB, LC imo

If it's a town!Hunter getting lynched I think it's probably better if Witches didn't know for sure that it's not happening.

I have some reasoning for other roles too, but I think only Hunter is likely to be contentious.

 

I agree with Kai. We should probably ping @shadowlancerx to let him know.

 

I can live with that.

And yeah Nurse can die quietly even though it just seems... wasteful, idk.

 

That seems like a bad idea.

 

Are you in a better headspace to talk about your feelings on manasi and fluff wagons?

I actually like the nurse giving a life to a random (non-jari) color musketeer.

 

I second this, it’s pretty much the only way for nurse to not be useless, as was pointed out.

The only thing is, if we’re being skunked by one of Vaimes/Gemma we could potentially be screwing ourselves. I doubt it, but I have a really bad feeling that the game is not as easy and straightforward as it’s appeared to be so far.

 

I think that manasi and shadow are kinda in the same boat at the moment where they are playing like dyed-in-the-wool disengaged scum.

I can buy worlds where one or both of them are just straight up not acclimating to the environment (manasi) or not having fun (shadow) but the combination of disengagement, not strongly pushing anything, bursts of activity followed by long silences, etc etc etc, just hits too many flags and I'm not swimming in other suspects at the moment. (Although at some point I'm gonna have to have a come to jesus talk with myself about Gemma and Dels).

Fluff is Very Fluff. You can go through the whole "he'd be trying harder as mafia" spiel but meh. He's had some salient mechanical points, which I appreciate but are pretty NAI. I don't really know what to do with him at this point. I don't want to fall into old patterns but I don't really see a way forward.