OMG
I'm sad other people replied to that before I could

Is what I wanted to say

 

That's a shame, because sometimes I, too, feel sad when other peoppebr.

 

Also sorry vaimes but Shadow is right, when it comes to something important that needs to be drilled in ("Hunter should shoot Manasi"), it's smart to repeat it as much as possible because townies are dumb and they just forget shit even the stuff that has already been repeated a dozen times. Maybe less of a worry here but I've learned the hard way that you can repeat a command a dozen times as emphatically as possible and townies will still just forget it or assume you didn't really mean it. Maybe less likely to happen here than elsewhere, but still

 

Yeah, it definitely wouldn't be an issue here, which is why I hmm'd at it. Plus the way he worded the post.

 

Vaimes vote Umami with me!

 

Also it's not ~really that important, because there's always the chance that the shot will bounce and we'll end up killing her ourselves.

 

Your open mindedness about Manasi showing back up is Noble but considering her only contribution was to say "Don't eat me" and leave I'm going to assume it really was just a whim for no reason

 

Maybe I'm just bad at reading into motivation.

Scumchat: "Hey Manasi you were Priest-checked"
Manasi: "Cool, I'll beg for my life for one post and peace out"

???

 

Ftr I kinda agree with you that it can still just be Cobalt/Shadow

Tom is wolf though but I don't have certainty that that's a hit and Cobalt/Shadow just makes the game so much easier to understand

No one seems like the 4th witch =/
--- Post automerged ---
Tom is wolf y* not Tom is wolf

 

When she's already been Not Present for most of the game, it just looks weird.

 

Manasi: "blergh I'll get around it eventually" ... "ok here i am fulfilling my duty oh it didn't work, really what a surprise, oh well i tried, bye guys sorry team"

 

That's better.

 

Gemmas logic for why it's not Cobalt makes sense ish but uh I know we already discussed this but remind me why it can't be a desperation play again? Cobalt can say he would ride the credit to a victory but would he really wanna let himself go down to 1v11 going into night? I didn't realize there would be two nightkills when I last said this but it'd be...

1v11 tonight
Manasi and townie die
1v9 day
Townie lynched
Two nightkills
1v6
Townie lynched
Two nightkills
1v3 lylo

So if cobalt.was scum and let Shadow die, he'd have to survive the next 3 lynches (and town would know they had three hits)

So in that case, town might Lynch Tom yes and then Cobalt would be hoping that 2 of Dels/m7/fluff/Kai? Get lynched before him?

Idk I can see the appeal in just saying fuck it and claiming Oracle on your partner. But I can also see why it's risky

 

Then look in your clears *bonk*

 

But umami is so townie! Aren't they?!
--- Post automerged ---
Everyone has a line of how much effort they will put in to a losing situation. One boundary is "stop posting" the other is "fight tooth and nail". You have to weigh how much you value your time to spend it on a situation that won't ever get you a success, but also feel like you've done enough due diligence that you're not being lazy or letting your team down.

Manasi chose her point on that scale.

 

Well my logic was predicated on the idea that Cobalt would be a prime rolekill target actually.
--- Post automerged ---

[insert reasoning here]

 

(He is not.)
--- Post automerged ---
I'm shelving "desperation play" for now but he and shadow are not townreads.

Just "okay this is what I'll work with until things get more dependably clear."

 

Umami referred to herself with female pronouns last game as far as I remember.

 

No, I had that same reaction. Not actionable, but I had it.

Do you buy the Cobalt/manasi antialign based on how Cobalt staunchly went to bat for manasi D1?

 

Everyone has a line of how much effort they will put in to a losing situation. One boundary is "stop posting" the other is "fight tooth and nail". You have to weigh how much you value your time to spend it on a situation that won't ever get you a success, but also feel like you've done enough due dilige

I thought she quoted Muz calling her a she and asked why the pronouns changed
--- Post automerged ---
f u draft u think just cuz I'm phone posting u can sneak by me